What If?

[Taleoftwotitans]

What if everything that happened didnt happen????

Dum Dum Dum....

 

[ColinWood]

What if Fev had no off-field issues?

 

[rockwolf]

What if Nathan Brown never broke his leg?

 

[nicshata]

What if Nathan Brown never broke his leg?

what if he broke both legs

 

[Lotch]

What if Stuart Dew never came out of retirement?

 

[Blues177]

As an Essendon supporter: What if Hird didn't miss basically the next 3 years after his brownlow win?

General Question:
What if West Coast beat Sydney in 2005 and Sydney beat West Coast in 2006?

Completely unrealistic at this point....:
What if all the best players for each position in history could be gathered in their respective primes in one place and time and trained with current rules/interpretation to play one epic match with their lives on the line?

Essendon would have won the 1999 grand final

 

[tonk]

I'm scared to click that link

There's nothing there.............what if there was.

 

[BABYBOMBERS2007]

What if Caro ran the AFL

 

[Blues177]

What if Malthouse had agreed with the Director of Coaching position at the Pies?
Would Ratten still have a job?
If not,who would be coaching the Blues this year?

Ratten may have survived...just... and then the blues would aim for Paul Roos for the 2014 season as his son would have completed secondary school by then. Even if Carlton were to finish 5-8th under Ratten in 2013.

 

[LightTower4]

What if in the 1950's to 1980's the church had the bent Christian Brothers at that school you seem to worship reported to the police rather than moving them on to another parish.

 

[Rack Watts]

What if Hawthorn had have kept Josh Kennedy?
What if Cousins didnt lose his shit?
What if Lloyd played on for another 2 years?


As a Don's supporter, this was the hardest thing to deal with as a kid, many tears were shed, What if Wanganeen didn't go to Port Adelaide?

Non footy: What if Cliff Burton didn't pass away and Mustaine didn't have drug problems?

 

[Prestigerrycomo]

What if Fitzroy never went to Brisbane?

What if the ball rolled through for a goal in the 2010 grand final? (Milne just missing the ball)

What if Carlton never got caught going over the salary cap?

What if the AFL stayed at 16 teams?

And from my own clubs perspective, what if Aker didn't lose the plot in his last year?


What are your 'what ifs'?

What if Milne had been correctly pinged for the push in the back against Harry O which resulted in his second goal? Funny no one ever mentions that one.....

 

[Kaiser Powser]

What if Milne had been correctly pinged for the push in the back against Harry O which resulted in his second goal? Funny no one ever mentions that one.....

Because, aside from having a spare saturday in Oct 2010, nothing would be different.

What if Gary Ablett had stayed at Hawthorn?

 

[Blues_Man]

What if Hawthorn picked Selwood over Thorp *cries*

What if Richmond took Buddy over tambling ?

 

[Blues_Man]

Because, aside from having a spare saturday in Oct 2010, nothing would be different.

What if Gary Ablett had stayed at Hawthorn?

What if greg Williams had stayed at Geelong ?
What if the Swans had of taken Wayne carey ?
What if Buckley had of stayed at the Lions ?

 

[Blues_Man]

What if this thread wasn't made? I'd be a fair few seconds younger

No you wouldn't ...you can tell you are a Pie supporter

 

[legend166]

What if the Swans didn't trade away the rights to Carey?

 

[2one2]

What if Milne had been correctly pinged for the push in the back against Harry O which resulted in his second goal? Funny no one ever mentions that one.....

Everyone can play that game. I wonder what would have happened if Pendlebury was pinged for throwing the ball 55 metres out with 15s left. Either a 60 metre kick after the siren or the ball bouncing the wrong way with a minute and a half would be much bigger tipping points than one goal at some random point in the match. Sorry you didn't get that free kick you wanted.

 

[Arwib]

What if the Swans didn't trade away the rights to Carey?

No Plugger, an entirely different 1996 season, Carey sleeps with Paul Kelly's wife instead?

 

[mufassa]

Essendon would have won the 1999 grand final

Just like the 2001 flag they won with him? Hang on a second.

 

[Stylo]

What if Nathan Brown never broke his leg?

Richmond premiers 2005...

 

[ExTasDeeMan]

What if Mark Waugh had decided that personality didn't matter in a partner?

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Just like the 2001 flag they won with him? Hang on a second.

You obviously cannot recall 2001. Hird had a groin strain and barely played.

But that's a good what if Mufassa:

What if Hird was fit in the 2001 GF?

 

[mufassa]

You obviously cannot recall 2001. Hird had a groin strain and barely played.

But that's a good what if Mufassa:

What if Hird was fit in the 2001 GF?

What if it was a made up story about Hird's groin in 2001?

 

[Prestigerrycomo]

What if Mark Waugh had decided that personality didn't matter in a partner?

He'd have something like this