What would you trade for Brad Green? Serious replies only

[notting18]

Judd is a melbourne boy he wants to come back

Yeah everyone knows juddy is a melb boy... how do u kno he wants to come back though? source??

I know a few ppl who know him (not well but chat once and a while) and havent heard anyhting about moving so id be a lil suss about this

 

[ernie burger]

proabably david fanning

 

[PieLebo87]

Brad Green & Miller for Judd, that actually sounded pretty good to me.
Would Eagles accept that with a draft pick added ASWELL? Would Melbourne offer it?

 

[tomthetiger]

You cant be serious. I don't think id trade Judd, a captain of a team, brownlow medalist, and champion of the game for the first 4 draft picks in this years draft. It just doesnt work that way.

 

[poyds]

My brother is best friends with judd. and i no for a fact he wants to come back, i no his mum and she is keen on him coming back. im only writting what i no, but i highly doubt dees would go 4 him, but i deff like given them green mid/forward nd miller back/forward nd a draft pick. sounds gr8

 

[sinepari]

That is absolute BS and I know that for a fact.

 

[poyds]

That is absolute BS and I know that for a fact.

prove it then, i no this for a fact, where r u getting ur info, im getting mine straight from his mums mouth
mate jst dnt cry when he comes back home 2 melb, nd hopfully the dees

 

[The Flying Belgian]

My brother is best friends with judd. and i no for a fact he wants to come back, i no his mum and she is keen on him coming back. im only writting what i no, but i highly doubt dees would go 4 him, but i deff like given them green mid/forward nd miller back/forward nd a draft pick. sounds gr8

Perhaps send this in an SMS and maybe then it'll make sense.

 

[sinepari]

prove it then, i no this for a fact, where r u getting ur info, im getting mine straight from his mums mouth
mate jst dnt cry when he comes back home 2 melb, nd hopfully the dees

I don't name my sources. Pretty immature if you do IMO.

We'll see.

Oh and by the way, claiming it's from his mums mouth does not constitute proof.

 

[Vidman]

Brad Green is worth pick 18-25 IMHO depending on how much a club needs him.

Go Roos

I think the lions would definitely be interested. But probably involving aker, however, and i admit my bias here i think aker is around the 15 spot in value, spot on in Greens value.

So I would propose Aker and no.3 for Green and no.1.

 

[smasher]

No club in its right mind would want Tarrant.

 

[gandaal]

No club in its right mind would want Tarrant.

Rubbish. They'd be 16 clubs who'd take Tarrant.

 

[xyakks]

My brother is best friends with judd. and i no for a fact he wants to come back, i no his mum and she is keen on him coming back. im only writting what i no, but i highly doubt dees would go 4 him, but i deff like given them green mid/forward nd miller back/forward nd a draft pick. sounds gr8

Sounds like you don't "no" anything, boy.

 

[goal sneak]

Green for Tarrant???

Green + 2nd rounder for Akermanis + 2nd rounder???

 

[Ants]

I rate Green pretty highly.

I'd swap him for pick #20.
I'd consider, but probably reject, trading pick 2 for Green + pick 13.

 

[Patty#32]

Leigh Harding and Leigh Brown

 

[Vidman]

Leigh Harding and Leigh Brown

aker to melbourne
brad green to north melbourne
leigh harding and leigh brown/2nd rnd pick to brisbane

overall i reckon thats not far off?

Being a lions supporter I'd want an extra pick say a third, a lot will depend upon the contracts and how it affects the salary cap, but i realise that might be too much.

 

[cobba]

Rubbish. They'd be 16 clubs who'd take Tarrant.

How there are only 16 teams in the comp??

 

[cobba]

aker to melbourne
brad green to north melbourne
leigh harding and leigh brown/2nd rnd pick to brisbane

overall i reckon thats not far off?

Being a lions supporter I'd want an extra pick say a third, a lot will depend upon the contracts and how it affects the salary cap, but i realise that might be too much.

Done Deal, we will even chuck in Eddie Sansbury

 

[gandaal]

How there are only 16 teams in the comp??

Collingwood want him and will keep him. Therefore 16 clubs would take him.

 

[tiger4life]

chris hyde + either 2nd or 3rd round pick (depending on how much melbourne wanted)