Who are the AA selectors?

[WALL-e]

Goddard to the bench then yeah?

Do you think Maxwell and or Goodwin were chosen to provide a captain option?

 

[Dangas]

Craig Bolton deserves the spot, Presti is overrated

 

[saintgary]

Agree that Bolton deserved his spot, very underated. One of the only defenders who could stop Riewoldt this year.
But I still don't understand how one of the best defences in history couldn't get one defender in the AA. Poor effort.

And Maxwell only got in on hype. My god, I have never seen a player hyped up so much in my life. Will probably get VC or Captain. Sure he's been good, but geeze.

Swan in the forwardline shows just how much of a disgrace this is. Not to mention no Black in the AA 40 squad and Milne was named in the AA 40 squad. Even as a saints fan I know this is a bit of a joke.

 

[Undecide]

Since when has the team been anounced

 

[Clay Davis]

That is absurd. Goddard is a much better player and had a much better year than Maxwell.

 

[Dangas]

Since when has the team been anounced

go to afl.com.au or listen to SEN1116, online,

 

[The_President]

Since when has the team been anounced

1116 SEN - Victoria

FB - Enright, Scarlett & Lake
HF - Goodwin, Bolton & Maxwell
C - Montagna, Hayes & Selwood
HF - TBA
FF - TBA
R - Sandilands, Judd & Ablett

 

[Pie eyed]

Apparently, you can't spell......

But, you support Collingwood.....so it's expected.

OH well at least you have "spelling and grammar" to keep you entertained for the next few years.

How that Hunt going?

 

[LuvMyHawks]

Foxtel have advertised all day that the awards will be made LIVE at 9.30pm..Is that false advertising or what???

 

[deadfish]

Goodwin Sanderlands out, Goddard Clark in. Otherwise good team so far.

 

[owenkraveki]

AA standards dropping like a deadweight.

AUSSIEGUN should include the "knobhead selectors factor" for his 2010 team..

 

[Neville Bartos]

Maxwell had a very good year and did a better job as captain than almost everybody would have expected. I think they made a lot of him leading from the front and probably hyped him into an AA spot accordingly.

Has happened before and will happen again.

If true, then Sam Mitchell who in his first year lead the Hawks to 2nd on the ladder and ultimately to the flag should have been a shoe-in last year.

Maxwell is a good player but he's 2-3 rungs below All-Australian

 

[Dangas]

AA standards dropping like a deadweight.

AUSSIEGUN should include the "knobhead selectors factor" for his 2010 team..

...standards only high when Hawks are in the side?

 

[The Panther]

Gerald Healy gets Bolton a place every year.

 

[The_President]

...standards only high when Hawks are in the side?

But of course.....

Just like this years finals, it's not exciting without the Hawks.....

Just like this years AA Team, it's not exciting without any Hawks.....

Ya dig?

 

[The_President]

Gerald Healy gets Bolton a place every year.

Bolton deserved his spot ahead of Maxwell & Goodwin.

 

[Johnson#26]

Presti?

 

[Dangas]

But of course.....

Just like this years finals, it's not exciting without the Hawks.....

Just like this years AA Team, it's not exciting without any Hawks.....

Ya dig?

haha

 

[Dangas]

Gerald Healy gets Bolton a place every year.

Yer exactly right, because he deserves it

 

[The Panther]

Yer exactly right, because he deserves it

LRT has been far superior to Bolton this year. He's chronically overrated.

 

[The_President]

Presti?

You're a funny guy

 

[saintgary]

Bolton had to get CHB as he was really the only the decent CHB in the 40 man squad let alone the competition.
Fisher was well down on his form and Bock missed a good part of the season.
Scarlett, Lake and Presti are all FB's and can't really play CHB. Lake and Presti espcially.
He defiently deserved it.

 

[owenkraveki]

...standards only high when Hawks are in the side?

Fair go, champ, you're not seriously vouching for the selectors are ya? They've been shit for a while but this is a new low!

And I'd only have Buddy, Sewelly and Mitchell in the 40 man squad, we've been shizen this year.

 

[Dangas]

LRT has been far superior to Bolton this year. He's chronically overrated.

I do agree

 

[thejester]

I can understand why Maxwell has been picked - but Goodwin? Champion player in his day but didn't think he'd had an outstanding season, certainly not as good as Goddard.