Who DON'T you want to draft?

[Capitano_Cotch]

Don't want Jaksch or Grundy (hope they both go top 10)

Stamos, I think Grundy could be great in your forward line!
Plus it would give you 2 very agile ruck/forward options with Kreuzer/Grundy.
Bit of a Cox/Naitanui situation!
I rate it

*In saying this, Grundy will not last to your pick.

 

[blueiris]

1Grundy-Can't see the point in drafting another ruckman.
2Sam Mayes-Don't get me wrong the kid has huge talent but would much rather a tall key forward then a small one.
3.Tim Membrey-see above
4.Dayle Garlett-has huge talent just don't think our team seems to know how to handel the bad boys (Aker Fev)

 

[Omega Blue]

no to plowman or jaksch, just can't get any warm fuzzy feeling over them.

 

[Bennylank]

Im not so keen on Membrey for the pies, particularly as we already have a few third tall types. If the plan is drafting him to potentially move into the midfield, why don't we just draft a (proven) midfielder. I would take menzel or stringer if they fell to the pies, but not both.

 

[Igloo]

Im not so keen on Membrey for the pies, particularly as we already have a few third tall types. If the plan is drafting him to potentially move into the midfield, why don't we just draft a (proven) midfielder. I would take menzel or stringer if they fell to the pies, but not both.

Geez, if I were the Pies and Menzel and Stringer fell to the three picks I'd take both of them in a heartbeat. You could afford to do it, imo.
But I think there's a 0% chance they'll get there

 

[NiceCunnington]

Not crazy about Hrovat.

 

[LB2Snake]

Something about Kennedy I don't like. Just feels like a bloke who would leave to go back to SA. Yeah he's short etc, but he can seriously play by the looks of his vids. Just a touch of the noooooo for me.

 

[100action]

Ben Jacobs, Oliver Wines, Jason Mccrae, Dayle Garlett, Tom Clurey, Josh Simpson

 

[aussierulesrules]

Ben Jacobs, Oliver Wines, Jason Mccrae, Dayle Garlett, Tom Clurey, Josh Simpson

At any picks, or just your first two? Clurey at 22 would hardly be bad.

 

[Shade]

I hope collingwood has nothing to do with Hrovat

 

[Number 10]

I hope we don't pick up McBean. Such a shit name and looks a bit flakey.

I also don't want a KPD.

 

[aussierulesrules]

There are others I would personally prefer at this stage to Tanner Smith, Hrovat and Wright. Also not keen on Dylan Roberton, who I hear is training with us. Just don't see the need to be adding any more "not quite tall enough for a key position backs", at this stage, unless they are absolutely exceptional, which I don't get the feeling he is.

 

[saintsrfreak]

McBean. Yep we're light on in the ruck department, but if we reach for him I'll be annoyed because he's more of a KPP in my eyes anyway.

Our history with recruiting skinny talls is hopeless exhibit a Wood, Ceglar, Richards and Fanning within the past decade. So I just wouldn't hold out hope that McBean could buck that trend.

Seems like McBean = Ceglar

 

[strobe00]

Membrey with our first pick. A couple of mocks have nominated us picking him at 17.

Seems a ridiculous waste of a pick to me.

Comfortable in saying it won't happen. (but crossing my fingers in any case)

 

[typewriter]

I really dont want Memburey and i have doubts about Garner

 

[Yoda_]

I personaly dont want Aitkens at 35, even though we are linked to him..

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

KPP's with pick 15.

 

[year of the roo]

Stringer, Menzel, Garlett, Hrovat, Clurey, Corr, Membrey or Jacobs at 15.

Any of those at 38 would be fine though

 

[FD2646]

No to Hrovat - too small, too slow = not enough hurt factor for Subi oval and a go home factor - no thanks.

Membrey - if we didn't have Chris Mayne maybe, but would you really spend a 1st rounder on a 3rd tall?

 

[StonesThrow]

Tall key position players, of course.

 

[DeeWong6996]

No KPPs at 4 please.

 

[Danair]

Mason Wood.

 

[LBJ6]

At 4 I do not want - O'Rourke, Grundy, Plowman, McCrae, Menzel, Stringer.

Toumpas or Wines, please.

 

[Lazar Goz]

McBean

 

[Lazar Goz]

Too tall and don't think he will accomplish to much at the Swans