Opinion Who gets the snip? Keeffe, Mackie, Schade & McCarthy confirmed, see post #342

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Not sure if there's a minimum amount that need to be cut, but you need to use at least 3 picks in the draft (including rookie upgrades)

We have already upgraded Thomas and Cox. And unlikely to trade pick 6 unless Tomlinson is still on the radar. Technically we could be finished already!!!! Unlikely though.

Possibly delist/rookie Sier?
Possibly delist Oxley (contracted?)
Possibly delist Blair (contracted?)
Possibly trade Fasolo (looks likely to stay)

 

[adammania9]

Just cut Oxley - surely he's not on anything crazy that we can't pay out already. He won't make it.

 

[Horaceg]

Just cut Oxley - surely he's not on anything crazy that we can't pay out already. He won't make it.

I think Oxley has currency and would be OK at the Lions or Suns. I don't think he Spuds it up as much as many think.

 

[Horaceg]

We have already upgraded Thomas and Cox. And unlikely to trade pick 6 unless Tomlinson is still on the radar. Technically we could be finished already!!!! Unlikely though.

Possibly delist/rookie Sier?
Possibly delist Oxley (contracted?)
Possibly delist Blair (contracted?)
Possibly trade Fasolo (looks likely to stay)

is Blah contracted, I thought he got one year, last year.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

is Blah contracted, I thought he got one year, last year.

Not sure, have heard he has one more.

 

[Schraderbrau]

I think Oxley has currency and would be OK at the Lions or Suns. I don't think he Spuds it up as much as many think.

Can't run, physically weak = very bad in modern game especially if position is defender.

The silver lining is that if oxley plays regularly in 2018 it will mean we'll have a top 4 pick in a super draft.

 

[jackcass]

Not sure if there's a minimum amount that need to be cut, but you need to use at least 3 picks in the draft (including rookie upgrades)

Based on list changes rather than draft picks I think.

 

[Carringbush2010]

So Hardwick had a different list this year?


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

Actually they did have a slightly different list this year bringing in Caddy & Prestia but that wasn't the magic pill, they developed better this year and Dimma was told to stfu and listen when needed to. So imo it's a bit of list and a bit of culture change at coaching level so they ended up with good ins and a well coached team.

 

[Damon_3388]

Actually they did have a slightly different list this year bringing in Caddy & Prestia but that wasn't the magic pill, they developed better this year and Dimma was told to stfu and listen when needed to. So imo it's a bit of list and a bit of culture change at coaching level so they ended up with good ins and a well coached team.

Having a proper physical ruckman around the stoppages (as opposed to a tap-and-watch guy) helped immensely too.

 

[Maggie5]

Actually they did have a slightly different list this year bringing in Caddy & Prestia but that wasn't the magic pill, they developed better this year and Dimma was told to stfu and listen when needed to. So imo it's a bit of list and a bit of culture change at coaching level so they ended up with good ins and a well coached team.

Actually I thought that Nankervis was a huge in for them.

 

[Carringbush2010]

Actually I thought that Nankervis was a huge in for them.

Thanks Maggie forgot nanks - don't know how I forgot him he was huge for their structure

 

[jackcass]

Actually they did have a slightly different list this year bringing in Caddy & Prestia but that wasn't the magic pill, they developed better this year and Dimma was told to stfu and listen when needed to. So imo it's a bit of list and a bit of culture change at coaching level so they ended up with good ins and a well coached team.

And Nankervis.

Who exactly told Dimma he had to STFU and listen and who determines when he needed to?

 

[whiskeytown]

Keeffe gone. Delistings and retirements are a real trickle this year compared to others.

Only two gone from the senior list. Would think they need to cut another 1-2 at least if they are going to draft 3-4 in the national and preseason draft.... why the delay with naming the others?

 

[DinoSoar]

Keeffe, Schade, Mackie and McCarthy delisted and with White retired, that brings us to 2 off the AFL list and 3 rookies.

 

[whiskeytown]

Keeffe, Schade, Mackie and McCarthy delisted and with White retired, that brings us to 2 off the AFL list and 3 rookies.

Keeffe and Schade were elevated I think. Making it altogether 3 off senior list and 2 off rookie

 

[10571z]

Another great move by our list management keeping Keeffe on the rookie list for 3 years.

 

[jackcass]

Keeffe, Schade, Mackie and McCarthy delisted and with White retired, that brings us to 2 off the AFL list and 3 rookies.

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/news/2017-10-10/magpies-confirm-four-delistings

Surprised McCarthy wasn't given another year. Was really raw but there were moments that you thought he could be a player. Other 3 unsurprising. Interesting to see if any of them get a 2nd chance.

 

[nahnah]

Blairy lives to fight another day

 

[Maggie5]

No real surprises so far. I would prefer a period of stabilisation.

 

[jackcass]

Blairy lives to fight another day

So far.

 

[jackcass]

Has anyone broken the news to TG yet?

 

[domin8tors]

Another great move by our list management keeping Keeffe on the rookie list for 3 years.

keeping him on the list you'll find was more about standing by our players and sending a message to the rest of the group that we stand by our own. Good PR. no issue with it.

 

[danielnajdek]

And Oxley is still on the list....

 

[nahnah]

Has anyone broken the news to TG yet?

yes, in meme form

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Blairy lives to fight another day

Signed a two year contract extension on the day Buckley re-signed.