Universal Love Who is the best player who has played for the Melbourne Football Club since and including 2000? WINNER: Max Gawn

[Scythe94]

Totally forgot we had a Brown on our list.

Better yet, we have two

 

[Dancing Potato]

Better yet, we have two

 

[Headless]

Headless, perhaps we should lock this thread until then?

Yes.

Yes, it's the only way.

 

[Headless]

WHO WILL BE THE FINAL TWO?

 

[Toump Ass]

The real poll question for Gawn v Farmer should be ‘will anyone else vote for Farmer besides A11dAtP0w3R and Topkent?

No way I'm voting for that loser Gawn.

 

[Crimson Azure]

No way I'm voting for that loser Gawn.

Trac however.

 

[PerfectFooty]

I like Petracca but he sure has got further than i thought. Must have been some meh matchups, but now i can't vote against Big David

 

[Topkent]

I honestly thought this would be closer based off the younger crew being morons. Happy Neita is way Infront. He's a legend

 

[Headless]

David Neitz (1993-2008)
Debut: Round 1, 1993
306 games, 631 goals

• Club record for games captained
• Club record for games played
• Club record for goals kicked
• Club B&F
• 2x All-Australian
• 7x leading goal-kicker
• Coleman Medalist
• Australian Football Hall of Fame

David Neitz | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

Christian Petracca (2015-present)
Debut: Round 6, 2016
176* games, 170* goals

• Premiership player
• Norm Smith Medalist
• 4x All-Australian
• 2x B&F
• Leading goal-kicker

Christian Petracca | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

EDIT (25/11/23): Results:

• David Neitz: 18 (72%)
• Christian Petracca: 7 (28%)

David Neitz advances to the final. Christian Petracca has been eliminated.

 

[Headless]

David Neitz (1993-2008)
Debut: Round 1, 1993
306 games, 631 goals

• Club record for games captained
• Club record for games played
• Club record for goals kicked
• Club B&F
• 2x All-Australian
• 7x leading goal-kicker
• Coleman Medalist
• Australian Football Hall of Fame

David Neitz | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

Max Gawn (2010-present)
Debut: Round 11, 2011
203* games, 98* goals

• Premiership player
• Club captain
• 2x B&F
• 6x All-Australian
• ALFCA POTY

Max Gawn | Demonwiki

Demonwiki.org is the ultimate resource for Melbourne Demons fans. Explore team history, player profiles, match results, and more. Stay updated with the latest news on the Demons.

demonwiki.org

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

You'll all be surprised to know that I'm voting for David Neitz

David Neitz

Age

49

Ht

191cm

Wt

100kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

10.8

3star

K

8.0

3star

HB

2.7

2star

M

4.9

5star

T

0.9

3star

G

2.1

5star

No current season stats available

D

10.4

3star

K

6.6

3star

HB

3.8

3star

M

2.6

3star

T

0.6

3star

G

1.0

4star

.

Most games, most goals, most games captained, not a choker, doesn't do shit podcasts. What a legend.

 

[Scythe94]

There was only ever going to one player who could top Neita in this comp for me, and it's Gawn. Premiership captain, 6 x AA, AFLCA POTY and one of the best rucks of all-time.

Neita is a Melbourne great and was a phenomenal captain, but no player has given us the H2H on-field advantage that Max has.

Neitz tops Gawn in some of the intangibles like leadership and attitude, but Gawn comes out on top in on-field performance. Six full seasons for six AAs is ridiculous.

It's easy to be critical after our last two years of finals performances, but I won't be taking Gawn's career for granted, personally.

 

[Topkent]

There was only ever going to one player who could top Neita in this comp for me, and it's Gawn. Premiership captain, 6 x AA, AFLCA POTY and one of the best rucks of all-time.

Neita is a Melbourne great and was a phenomenal captain, but no player has given us the H2H on-field advantage that Max has.

Neitz tops Gawn in some of the intangibles like leadership and attitude, but Gawn comes out on top in on-field performance. Six full seasons for six AAs is ridiculous.

It's easy to be critical after our last two years of finals performances, but I won't be taking Gawn's career for granted, personally.

Neitz is an AA at both ends of the ground and his competition to make AA is a shit load harder than Gawns. Probably the weakest era of rucks of all time currently

Gawn has been massive in alot of our losses but we win 21 still if you swap him and Neitz around. Wouldn't have been a premiership captain if he played in Neitz era

 

[Cuzz09]

Kicked a pretty important goal that day didn't he?

Was a fairly epic play all round

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[booshboy]

Its probably Gawn, but I cant vote against Neita. nearly 700 goals when he played as an AA level CHB for the first half of his career. Criminally underrated outside MFC fans. Was every bit the player Richo was and got nowhere near the credit.

 

[knackers29]

There was only ever going to one player who could top Neita in this comp for me, and it's Gawn. Premiership captain, 6 x AA, AFLCA POTY and one of the best rucks of all-time.

Neita is a Melbourne great and was a phenomenal captain, but no player has given us the H2H on-field advantage that Max has.

Neitz tops Gawn in some of the intangibles like leadership and attitude, but Gawn comes out on top in on-field performance. Six full seasons for six AAs is ridiculous.

It's easy to be critical after our last two years of finals performances, but I won't be taking Gawn's career for granted, personally.

...But Neita's beers are better!!

 

[Dancing Potato]

...But Neita's beers are better!!

View attachment 1860512

I've met the great man twice at the Brewmanity stall at beer festivals.

Humble bloke, happy to have a chat and take a photo. Legend.

 

[Scythe94]

Neitz is an AA at both ends of the ground and his competition to make AA is a s**t load harder than Gawns. Probably the weakest era of rucks of all time currently

Gawn has been massive in alot of our losses but we win 21 still if you swap him and Neitz around. Wouldn't have been a premiership captain if he played in Neitz era

Not sure I agree with that – Gawn's had Goldstein, Sandilands, Naitanui, Grundy etc to compete with, who were all very good at their peak. Obviously not the best era ever, but still pretty good.

Don't think you're giving quite enough credit to Gawn for 2021 though – not sure we win the flag with Neita at FF and Jackson rucking full-time. Not to mention he won the minor premiership off his own boot and completely dismantled Geelong in the prelim (would've won anyway, but one of the best finals performances ever).

Neita is definitely underrated outside MFC supporters, but realistically, he's a rung below some of the best forwards from his era, whereas Max sits at the top of his.

Always hard to compare players from different times/positions, so can appreciate the arguments from both sides (and don't get me wrong, I bloody love Neita – he gave me some of my most cherished footy memories, plus he's a ripper guy). Think Max will certainly be more revered once he finishes up though.

 

[Topkent]

Not sure I agree with that – Gawn's had Goldstein, Sandilands, Naitanui, Grundy etc to compete with, who were all very good at their peak. Obviously not the best era ever, but still pretty good.

Don't think you're giving quite enough credit to Gawn for 2021 though – not sure we win the flag with Neita at FF and Jackson rucking full-time. Not to mention he won the minor premiership off his own boot and completely dismantled Geelong in the prelim (would've won anyway, but one of the best finals performances ever).

Neita is definitely underrated outside MFC supporters, but realistically, he's a rung below some of the best forwards from his era, whereas Max sits at the top of his.

Always hard to compare players from different times/positions, so can appreciate the arguments from both sides (and don't get me wrong, I bloody love Neita – he gave me some of my most cherished footy memories, plus he's a ripper guy). Think Max will certainly be more revered once he finishes up though.

Goldsteins a good ruck, not a great one at all. Sandilands last AA was 2014 he's not even Gawns era. He's competed with Grundy and Natanui and 2 of them get picked every year anyway. Gawns been #1 no doubt about it but it's a shit era.

Gawn was massive in the finals not arguing, and he kicked a goal after the siren sure. Cost a few close to the siren aswell. He was one of the reasons we lost against Carlton missing easy af shots and then spoiling a goal on our ****ing goal line lol

 

[booshboy]

you look what the two had to work with as well.

Gawn has May, Neita had Alistair ****ing Nicholson AKA Premiership Kryptonite.

both Brayshaw & Viney would be the best mids in Neitz' teams outside Yze who spent plenty of time forward.

The only thing Neitz has over Gawn is that he wasnt coached by a complete flipping moron.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

you look what the two had to work with as well.

Gawn has May, Neita had Alistair ******* Nicholson AKA Premiership Kryptonite.

both Brayshaw & Viney would be the best mids in Neitz' teams outside Yze who spent plenty of time forward.

The only thing Neitz has over Gawn is that he wasnt coached by a complete *ing moron.

Still blows my mind how Nicho got games ahead of Chris Lamb.

 

[Topkent]

Still blows my mind how Nicho got games ahead of Chris Lamb.

Nicho was so shit he was cult hero for me. he was like the shit Danny devito style twin of Neitz.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Nicho was so s**t he was cult hero for me. he was like the s**t Danny devito style twin of Neitz.

He was meme more than a cult hero. Far too shit to receive cult hero status.

 

[booshboy]

He was meme more than a cult hero. Far too s**t to receive cult hero status.

yeah he was the bad luck Bryan of the AFL. I ****ing hated him.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Dutchy Holland, Peter Vardy

Peter Vardy

Age

48

Ht

181cm

Wt

83kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

11.0

3star

K

7.6

3star

HB

3.4

3star

M

3.1

3star

T

1.4

3star

G

1.5

5star

No current season stats available

D

10.4

3star

K

7.6

3star

HB

2.8

3star

M

2.2

3star

T

1.2

3star

G

0.6

3star

, Nathan Carroll

Nathan Carroll

Age

44

Ht

191cm

Wt

91kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

12.5

3star

K

6.6

3star

HB

5.9

4star

M

5.3

5star

T

1.5

3star

No current season stats available

D

11.0

3star

K

7.4

3star

HB

3.6

3star

M

4.2

4star

T

2.4

4star

... cult hereos.