Universal Love Who is the best player who has played for the Melbourne Football Club since and including 2000? WINNER: Max Gawn

Who has been the better player for Melbourne?


  • Total voters
    40
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

I have to choose Neita just for the towering beauty of his drop punt. He kicked them high and with a lot of spin which is aesthetically so pleasing. He honestly could have added at least 10 meters or more with a flatter, lower-spinning flight; but I’m glad he didn’t.
 
Oliver's GF goal is my favourite sporting moment of all time. The image of him turning and raising a finger to the crowd is permanently burnt into my brain. He could spend the rest of his career snapping windscreen wipers off cars and sleeping on Max's couch and I'd still vote for him just for that.
 
Oliver's GF goal is my favourite sporting moment of all time. The image of him turning and raising a finger to the crowd is permanently burnt into my brain. He could spend the rest of his career snapping windscreen wipers off cars and sleeping on Max's couch and I'd still vote for him just for that.
he was pointing to the guy whos windscreen wipers he snapped.
 
As a kid two of my favourites where Davey and Neita. I love Oliver but nothing beats the towering presence of Captain Neitz in the forward line. Could be a big brute of a forward and then the most humble guy you'd meet off the field

Arguably the hole he's left in the forward line that hasn't been filled since
 
David Neitz (1993-2008)
Debut: Round 1, 1993
306 games, 631 goals
  • Club record for games captained
  • Club record for games played
  • Club record for goals kicked
  • Club B&F
  • 2x All-Australian
  • 7x leading goal-kicker
  • Coleman Medalist
  • Australian Football Hall of Fame


Clayton Oliver (2016-present)
Debut: Round 1, 2016
162* games, 51* goals
  • Premiership player
  • 2x AFLCA Player of the Year
  • 3x All-Australian
  • 4x B&F


EDIT (20/11/23): Results:
  • David Neitz: 23 (61%)
  • Clayton Oliver: 15 (39%)
David Neitz advances to the next round. Clayton Oliver has been eliminated.
 
Round of 8 - Adem Yze v. Jeff Farmer
Adem Yze (1995-2008)
Debut: Round 13, 1995
271 games, 234 goals
  • Club B&F
  • All-Australian


Jeff Farmer (1995-2001)
Debut: Round 1, 1995
118 games, 259 goals
  • All-Australian
  • 3x leading goal-kicker


EDIT (21/11/23):
  • Adem Yze: 17 (47%)
  • Jeff Farmer: 19 (53%)
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The board has 10 people in the Ku Klux Klan voting against Farmer I see, wow, I knew we had some nasty people around here but didn't realise it was that many..disgusting.

You need to go on BLM marches with myself and TK to cleanse your soul.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Universal Love Who is the best player who has played for the Melbourne Football Club since and including 2000? WINNER: Max Gawn

Back
Top