White played a lot of KPD. 103 goals over 10 seasons isnt the making of a great KPF. Greatest output being 35 in 96. Have you forgotten who won the coleman last year?
Opinion Who is the Eagles best ever full back?
- Thread starter KevinTaylor
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I dare say Josh has played some of his best footy over the past 4 years.
And that displaces 25 years of history before that.
We've had so many great centre half forwards in our history.
Like White, and, um...hmm....well Hanson and Ben McKinley. Surely you haven't forgotten McKinley.
Controversial - but I would have Spinks just edging out McKinley. Edging out Ilija Grigic
McIntosh.
sydney eagle
Norm Smith Medallist
As a centre half forward in an "All Time Eagles Team" I would like to suggest Ross Glendinning. He only played for the Eagles for a couple of seasons at the end of his career, but was our leading goal kicker at that time.
- Oct 9, 2009
- 12,604
- 14,325
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Suma > JK > Cummings > Lynch > Darling > Wilson > Glendinning(?) > Gov > Hunter > McIntosh > White > Hansen
Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
No Heady
- Oct 9, 2009
- 12,604
- 14,325
- AFL Club
- West Coast
He's not a KPF though.No Heady
Mickey Rae
Club Legend
- Sep 17, 2015
- 1,653
- 2,548
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- The Mighty Royals
Although at the end of his career he was still a champion with us (still in good shape as per photo left!)
Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
He was for a while there. Weve never had a gun forward line untill now.
beau wilkes spanger and e mac were deadly in the spoon era
Champion bloke as well! I got a flat outside his house and he helped me change it!! Daughter is quite the looker!!
QS
Brownlow Medallist
This is the problem with these types of questions, its a different game and people answer a subjective question with a subjective answer therefore you never get objective consensus really. I was around for McKenna, but only young so I can only recall what I did. Bit rich to say he was _that_ good that he cannot be surpassed, Shep has a lot of playing left and _if_ he keeps it up, I think he's more important in a best ever defence given modern footy.
We are not the talking Kemp v Cousins here, Shep has a hell of a long way to go to be even talked about in the same sentence as McKenna. Now if he has another 8 years and better than he did this year then maybe a discussion like you put forward could be discussed. There is nothing Shep does in his game that McKenna wasn't doing, McKenna was the king of dropping off his man and taking intercepting marks, his disposal was as good as it gets.
Like I said I love Shep, he is one of my favourite players but he just is not in Mckennas world in my opinion.
Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
McKenna might, big might, be surpassed.
But the half back line of
McKenna, Jacovich, Worsfold
wont be.
But the half back line of
McKenna, Jacovich, Worsfold
wont be.
Woosha will be surpassed as a player many many years before Bluey.
Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
Yeah probably but as a complete half backline those guys had it all.
Held back alot of teams scores in a high scoring offensive era and scared the hell out of blokes.
Bluey was nominated for half back in AA team of the century, there was no way a West Coast player was ever going to get a spot though. To be in the conversation was an outstanding effort.
I loved Shep this year too but I can't see him surpassing the hunchback any time soon (ever).
I loved Shep this year too but I can't see him surpassing the hunchback any time soon (ever).
- Sep 28, 2009
- 23,823
- 34,240
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Reading FC
David Haynes was better than the lot of them
QS
Brownlow Medallist
I think the first 6 words of my original post agrees with everything you've said bud.
Similar threads
- Poll
- Locked
