Who Really is the best player in the AFL

[tin can sam]

Judd at his best is the best in the comp. Only Franklin can match him in terms of freakishness. Ablett is great and has been the best in the comp over the past 2 years but his best is no where near Judd's. Kerr at his best is better than Ablett.

No chance at all.

Ablett at his best even has Cousins covered, he just hasn't done it for as long.

 

[SaintsPremiers08]

One of:

Ablett
Franklin
Judd (When fully fit)
Pav

Pav dominates in a shit team. Imagine what he'd do if he played for Geelong or Hawthorn

 

[Spade]

I think the umpi's would be the best judge that after all they tell us who [their] the best player is and they also tell us who [their] the fairest player is WOT A JOB

keep diggin

 

[Marsup]

For me I can't split Ablett, Franklin and Judd.....

Then behind them Hodge, Brown, Black, Kerr, Fevola, Scarlett, Cox

So for me Cooney would struggle to make the Top 20!

 

[budge11]

No chance at all.

Ablett at his best even has Cousins covered, he just hasn't done it for as long.

Hmmm...

 

[Big Nasty]

Hmmm...

What do you mean Hmmm...