Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Worm4]

There's a lot of knot tying happening . Seems doppleganger doesnt want to address my scenario in post number #9120.

 

[doppleganger]

Both sets of supporters agreed when Carlton/Collingwood made finals that we would take it into account which is why the thread continued past the H+A season. And taking into account finals btw seems a pretty nice/simple concept.

Regardless, this thread says who will be better and it seems pretty clear to everyone but you what that means.

Sure, Pies fans were happy to let some deluded Baggers move the goal posts and better them twice. Just the kind of fans we are.

And now the thread is no longer who finishes higher...despite Bagger fans wanting to shift the goalposts back again!

 

[Cyclops]

Oh that's cute, obviously we weren't Top 4 at the end of round 24 but after Finals we were third and GWS fourth.

Do we can still be better than you if we win the flag? That's a relief.

 

[gab213]

Do we can still be better than you if we win the flag? That's a relief.

I have never argued that you weren't better last year but this year it's looking probable that we will finish as the better performed team.

 

[carlton_99]

And now the thread is no longer who finishes higher...despite Bagger fans wanting to shift the goalposts back again!

Helps to read the post you are replying to - clearly stated that it is "who's better" and that it's clear to everyone but you what that means

 

[Worm4]

So , the big question is who is better as of last home and away game and doesn't include finals. This thread could be closed in about 6 hours time. What a relief

 

[doppleganger]

Helps to read the post you are replying to - clearly stated that it is "who's better" and that it's clear to everyone but you what that means

If Carlton are better than the Pies they wont lose tonight.

 

[Worm4]

If Carlton are better than the Pies they wont lose tonight.

Richmond are better than Sydney then. Saints better than Collingwood

 

[carlton_99]

If Carlton are better than the Pies they wont lose tonight.

But then it will be 1-1 in the H2H so we would be even I'm assuming?

 

[doppleganger]

But then it will be 1-1 in the H2H so we would be even I'm assuming?

Then you can go tie breaker, re performance against other teams. The ladder an ok option for that, despite different fixtures.

 

[gab213]

Then you can go tie breaker, re performance against other teams. The ladder an ok option for that, despite different fixtures.

 

[Worm4]

Then you can go tie breaker, re performance against other teams. The ladder an ok option for that, despite different fixtures.

So you make the rules then ?

 

[doppleganger]

Richmond are better than Sydney then. Saints better than Collingwood

If there was a Pies v Saints who will be better thread, and the Saints won two games HTH against the Pies during the season, a fair argument that the Saints were better than the Dirty Pies.

But this is a Carlton v Collingwood thread.

 

[Worm4]

If there was a Pies v Saints who will be better thread, and the Saints won two games HTH against the Pies during the season, a fair argument that the Saints were better than the Dirty Pies.

But this is a Carlton v Collingwood thread.

Yeah, nah. Saints better. They beat pies on collingwoods home deck. No return games required.
For all you know, Carlton v Collingwood might only play against each other once next year, rendering the 2025 thread void for discussion

 

[carlton_99]

Yeah, nah. Saints better. They beat pies on collingwoods home deck. No return games required.
For all you know, Carlton v Collingwood might only play against each other once next year, rendering the 2025 thread void for discussion

An imaginary Brisbane/Carlton thread would have been done in OR using this logic lol

 

[Fadge]

Don't bother they think Port and Melbourne had better seasons than GWS and Carlton last year.

Yeah, I guess the Bulldogs didn't do all that flash in 2016, I've always thought they finished 1st but I guess it was 7th

It was one of the Carlton dudes that posted a table of the teams with the biggest drop after a premiership season, with Adelaide finishing 5th in 1998 - to argue that Collingwood could potentially have the biggest fall in ladder position after a premiership year.

You guys really do have to make up your minds...

 

[Cyclops]

Pies still on track to 4peat, so happy days.

 

[Fadge]

Collingwood supporters wnt the season to finish at H&A- they know they are no f=good at finals unless...



FLUKEARAMA and UMPIRAMA BABY

Yeah, Pies no good at finals...

Except for the FACT Collingwood have won more finals games than any other team in the competition...

 

[Worm4]

Yeah, Pies no good at finals...

Except for the FACT Collingwood have won more finals games than any other team in the competition...

Probably lost more finals than any other team in the competition as well

 

[Fadge]

Pies still on track to 4peat, so happy days.

Been there, done that.

 

[Worm4]

Been there, done that.

Its 2024 last time I checked

 

[Fadge]

Probably lost more finals than any other team in the competition as well

Carlton have only lost 5 finals this century, Collingwood have lost about 15.

In the world of Carlton supporters, that makes them 3 times better than Collingwood over that period...

 

[Cyclops]

Its 2024 last time I checked

Wait you have the check what year it is?

Wait 'til you find out who the reigning premier is.

 

[Fadge]

Probably lost more finals than any other team in the competition as well

Probably equal with Geelong and Sydney - the other teams who have regularly qualified for finals over the same time period.

 

[carlton_99]

It was one of the Carlton dudes that posted a table of the teams with the biggest drop after a premiership season, with Adelaide finishing 5th in 1998 - to argue that Collingwood could potentially have the biggest fall in ladder position after a premiership year.

You guys really do have to make up your minds...

What does that have to do with what I said? I don't speak for other people or control what they post.