If they beat them twice and all that separated their ladder position was number of games played against the three easy beats, it would be a valid thing to debate yes.Are Richmond better than Syndey?
Yeah dude I think it’s just time to stop
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
If they beat them twice and all that separated their ladder position was number of games played against the three easy beats, it would be a valid thing to debate yes.Are Richmond better than Syndey?
Yeah dude I think it’s just time to stop
They should do one for Collingwood and Essendon due to similar levels of crapness.Curious... Do we think there will even be a 2025 thread created or is everyone resigned to the fact that the Wobbly Wobbles are set for an extended trip down the bottom of the ladder for the next few years?
Does it really?I love this it shows real salt.
Is that a promise?I won't be involved in a 2025 thread unless the parameters are clearly defined
Facts are if you win more games than your opposition teams you have a greater chance of making the finals, currently 10 teams have done that.Does it really?
I just read it as stating facts.
Is that a promise?
C'mon..look at the ladder... Carlton were defeated by a crap Collingwood twice!!They should do one for Collingwood and Essendon due to similar levels of crapness.
I won't be involved in a 2025 thread unless the parameters are clearly defined
You guys are in Mexico with the Bombers. Would be a much better match up between the 2C'mon..look at the ladder... Carlton were defeated by a crap Collingwood twice!!I'm ok with bringing the Bombers into the thread but clearly Carlton are at a similar level of mediocrity and deserve to be here in the discussion.
If you stop posting in the thread next year I will go on a hunger strike. Don't do it man!
lol fitness and system. Why is Blues season relying on winning games against minnows despite having the best list on paper?So why is Collingwoods season over despite having a good system???
I feel like Carlton have thrown away their season. I feel a successful season would be Carlton finishing in the top 4 but also winning games they were favourites in.Looks like Collingwood won't go back to back
So whilst Carlton may finish higher... Does it really mean much unless they take the flag?
They should do one for Collingwood and Essendon due to similar levels of crapness.
I won't be involved in a 2025 thread unless the parameters are clearly defined
Collingwood are crap this year but Carlton have lost to them twice...You guys are in Mexico with the Bombers. Would be a much better match up between the 2
Meow is a master!
Carlton folk are like shooting fish in a barrel for him.
Indeed he is.Meow is a master!
Carlton folk are like shooting fish in a barrel for him.
There's truth in what you say, just not in the intent of what you're saying...Not even in the same body of water
In your opinionThere's truth in what you say, just not in the intent of what you're saying...
Just edited for accuracy...Anyway, as for the OP, likely scenario after this weekend, Pies a 2 - 0 record against Carlton, and Carlton clinging on to their spot in the top 8 by percentage from Hawthorn.
Meow's perspective comes from a supporter of a genuine "big three" Victorian powerhouse club. (Hawks and Pies being the other 2). He comes from the perspective of a club which knows how to be successful and avoid wooden spoons. Carlton folk surely could benefit from his expertise. But instead, they just knee jerk and shoot the messenger.Indeed he is.
It's very refreshing to hear the perspective of a neutral in this thread.
I prefer this, which is factJust edited for accuracy...
Indeed. You are 100% correct.Meow's perspective comes from a supporter of a genuine "big three" Victorian powerhouse club. (Hawks and Pies being the other 2). He comes from the perspective of a club which knows how to be successful and avoid wooden spoons. Carlton folk surely could benefit from his expertise. But instead, they just knee jerk and shoot the messenger.
Yeah, you keep saying this, but continually fail to share that list, and accompanying rationale.So powerhouse clubs only need to win 3 flags in 60 odd years?
The list is long, but unfortunately for the Pies, they aren't in the top 8 on that count either