Banter Carlton is better in 2024. Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[Fadge]

Up until now here is your reality

View attachment 2079749

So Carlton, with the best team they have assembled in over two decades, in a season where you all had such high hopes and expectations, are outside the top 8 with 2 rounds to go?

And are starting underdogs in an upcoming game against the 16th placed team?

Thanks for reminding us.

 

[Robertio]

So Carlton, with the best team they have assembled in over two decades, in a season where you all had such high hopes and expectations, are outside the top 8 with 2 rounds to go?

And are starting underdogs in an upcoming game against the 16th placed team?

Thanks for reminding us.

We are still above the Pies mate.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

So Carlton, with the best team they have assembled in over two decades, in a season where you all had such high hopes and expectations, are outside the top 8 with 2 rounds to go?

And are starting underdogs in an upcoming game against the 16th placed team?

Thanks for reminding us.

Well half our team isn't available for selection mate. So you do need to bear than in mind when making your analysis of us.

 

[doppleganger]

Up until now here is your reality

Reality for Collingwood is

Currently missing finals - bugger. But get to deathride Carlton and Freo when hoping for a hail mary
Beating Carlton twice

Reality for Carlton fans

Currently missing finals - bugger
Losing to Collingwood twice -
Becoming clear that 2023 was one out of the box, and they still were worse than Collingwood!

Which Blueshake was worse 2022 or 2024?

 

[Robertio]

Reality for Collingwood is

Currently missing finals - bugger. But get to deathride Carlton and Freo when hoping for a hail mary
Beating Carlton twice

Reality for Carlton fans

Currently missing finals - bugger
Losing to Collingwood twice -
Becoming clear that 2023 was one out of the box, and they still were worse than Collingwood!

Which Blueshake was worse 2022 or 2024?

Ha ha ha this still hasn't moved the Pies up the ladder. Which year was better 2022-23 or 24?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Reality for Collingwood is

Currently missing finals - bugger. But get to deathride Carlton and Freo when hoping for a hail mary
Beating Carlton twice

Reality for Carlton fans

Currently missing finals - bugger
Losing to Collingwood twice -
Becoming clear that 2023 was one out of the box, and they still were worse than Collingwood!

Which Blueshake was worse 2022 or 2024?

Nothing will ever top 2022. It was as if it was scripted by god himself!

 

[doppleganger]

Ha ha ha this still hasn't moved the Pies up the ladder. Which year was better 2022-23 or 24?

2023 Premiers, so should be pretty obvious.

What about for Carlton?

2022 - jamie elliott grim reaper knock you out of finals
2023 - dead rubber win, but Pies are premiers
2024 - GOATcos carries us to victory, and then do the double for Sir Scott in his 400th

Which season is a Carlton's fans view of their best season compared to the Pies, of the last three?

 

[doppleganger]

Nothing will ever top 2022. It was as if it was scripted by god himself!

2023 GOATcos kicking first goal, and then setting up the go ahead goal deep in Q4, as we were premiers topped it.

 

[Robertio]

2023 Premiers, so should be pretty obvious.

What about for Carlton?

2022 - jamie elliott grim reaper knock you out of finals
2023 - dead rubber win, but Pies are premiers
2024 - GOATcos carries us to victory, and then do the double for Sir Scott in his 400th

Which season is a Carlton's fans view of their best season compared to the Pies, of the last three?

Someone should tell the AFL the ladder they put out is wrong, 10 teams including Carlton are ahead of the Pies.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Someone should tell the AFL the ladder they put out is wrong, 10 teams including Carlton are ahead of the Pies.

The ladder is fine

 

[Fadge]

Well half our team isn't available for selection mate. So you do need to bear than in mind when making your analysis of us.

Are 'The Cavalry' there though?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Are 'The Cavalry' there though?

STILL blaming injuries when will they realise that Voss is a spud and they've got no viable on-field leadership

Peaked in 2023

 

[Robertio]

The ladder is fine

View attachment 2079834

I can't believe you want to go the ladder route lol.

 

[Robertio]

STILL blaming injuries when will they realise that Voss is a spud and they've got no viable on-field leadership

Peaked in 2023

What's the Pies excuse?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I can't believe you want to go the ladder route lol.

View attachment 2079846

Yep it's a BEAUTIFUL sight ❤

From cushy in 2nd, talking about GFs etc... to NINTH, talking about trading the whole squad and sacking the coach !!!

And SO quickly (thanks partly to us)

Keep posting that ladder

 

[Corn Cobbers]

What's the Pies excuse?

No excuse required, we are still premiers

 

[bradfisher14]

Imagine being below Essendon on the ladder

 

[Robertio]

Yep it's a BEAUTIFUL sight ❤

From cushy in 2nd, talking about GFs etc... to NINTH, talking about trading the whole squad and sacking the coach !!!

And SO quickly (thanks partly to us)

Keep posting that ladder

That still doesn't get the Pies any higher mate, we've had injuries all year so i reckon this year has been a success and just a preview on what's to come.

 

[Robertio]

No excuse required, we are still premiers

Pies supporters always talking about the past.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

That still doesn't get the Pies any higher mate, we've had injuries all year so i reckon this year has been a success and just a preview on what's to come.

That's the sort of talk we love to hear carry on then

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Pies supporters always talking about the past.

"current" premiers

 

[geelong_crazy26]

it’s like comparing two turds floating in the sewerage. Both plummeted out of finals contention in the most dramatic style.

 

[Robertio]

"current" premiers

Current no 11 on the ladder.

 

[manicpie]

it’s like comparing two turds floating in the sewerage. Both plummeted out of finals contention in the most dramatic style.

Don't worry, you'll be joining us in the sewer before the season ends

 

[manicpie]

Current no 11 on the ladder.

That's quite the fall from grace when you think about it