Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[carlton_99]

If one team loses to the other twice than the other must be better, no?

No and not having this whole discussion again

 

[Robertio]

Should the title of this thread be changed to " who will be worse"

Pies leading.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

If one team loses to the other twice than the other must be better, no?

Especially when they are both in the same section of the ladder. There's no argument. The team that won twice is "better".

 

[Robertio]

Especially when they are both in the same section of the ladder. There's no argument. The team that won twice is "better".

Maybe the team who has won more games over all is better, you blokes would want the higher draft pick if you finished below Carlton or would you give it up(if you had a first round pick).

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Maybe the team who has won more games over all is better, you blokes would want the higher draft pick if you finished below Carlton or would you give it up(if you had a first round pick).

Because you got an extra game against North you think you're better than a team that beat you twice.

 

[doppleganger]

Because you got an extra game against North you think you're better than a team that beat you twice.

Not just North.

North and Richmond.

Poor Baggers know they have nothing, Pies better again in 2024, just like we were in 2023 and 2022

Await a zinger about the 1960s from a crusty old Bagger

 

[Robertio]

Because you got an extra game against North you think you're better than a team that beat you twice.

You couldn't beat a few teams that we did mate, that's how the whole system works, strange a few of you don't know that.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

This is gonna age like an Essendon finals win.

Oh yeah a bit like Fadge claims that the current 2024 Pies team were all set up to have an Essendon 2000 sort of year.

 

[RPCB]

Because you got an extra game against North you think you're better than a team that beat you twice.

Why are you shitting on a club that led Collingwood by 9 goals? Seems a bit weird.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Not just North.

North and Richmond.

Poor Baggers know they have nothing, Pies better again in 2024, just like we were in 2023 and 2022

Await a zinger about the 1960s from a crusty old Bagger

No we could still finish in front of you mate. Three flags since the late 1950's is a pretty shit record wouldn't you say?

 

[doppleganger]

Why are you shitting on a club that led Collingwood by 9 goals? Seems a bit weird.

Pretty simple, we beat them and are better than them.

Just like we are better than Carlton, we led by 6 goals in Q4 in our last clash and beat the Baggers again.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Why are you shitting on a club that led Collingwood by 9 goals? Seems a bit weird.

Led by 9 goals and lost.

How did the AFL justify giving Carlton, the team that finished 4th, double up games against North the team that finished last? It's not supposed to happen.
There needs to be an investigation.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Because you got an extra game against North you think you're better than a team that beat you twice.

Is this the same Roos team that the Pies barely beat yeah?

 

[RPCB]

Pretty simple, we beat them and are better than them.

Just like we are better than Carlton, we led by 6 goals in Q4 in our last clash and beat the Baggers again.

Nope.

The umpires beat them.

Led by 9 goals and lost.

How did the AFL justify giving Carlton, the team that finished 4th, double up games against North the team that finished last? It's not supposed to happen.
There needs to be an investigation.

Because we have played one game against the team that finished 18th in 2023.

I think your post should have stayed in your head, where it sounded better.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Pretty simple, we beat them and are better than them.

Just like we are better than Carlton, we led by 6 goals in Q4 in our last clash and beat the Baggers again.

Apparently Carlton folk don't understand the concept that a win is a win and that = 4 points.
Could be where they're going wrong.

 

[Robertio]

Pretty simple, we beat them and are better than them.

Just like we are better than Carlton, we led by 6 goals in Q4 in our last clash and beat the Baggers again.

These salty posts because you are behind Carlton are hilarious, don't change mate you are good for a laugh.

 

[Robertio]

Apparently Carlton folk don't understand the concept that a win is a win and that = 4 points.
Could be where they're going wrong.

Do we need to explain how the ladder works again mate, more salty posts.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Nope.

The umpires beat them.



Because we have played one game against the team that finished 18th in 2023.

I think your post should have stayed in your head, where it sounded better.

How on earth did the team that finished 4th get given two games against the team that finished 18th.
It's scandalous. It reeks of brown paper bags full of cash ala Carlton 1990's.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Do we need to explain how the ladder works again mate, more salty posts.

Yes please Robertio. Can you explain to me what it means when you are in 9th spot on the ladder?

 

[RPCB]

How on earth did the team that finished 4th get given two games against the team that finished 18th.
It's scandalous. It reeks of brown paper bags full of cash ala Carlton 1990's.

This really shouldn’t be that difficult.

West Coast finished 18th in 2023. We only have one game against West Coast in 2024.

 

[Robertio]

Yes please Robertio. Can you explain to me what it means when you are in 9th spot on the ladder?

Ninth spot on the ladder is higher than any spot below it mate, if Pies finish above Carlton then they have had the better season and Carlton supporters would acknowledge that because we know football.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

This really shouldn’t be that difficult.

West Coast finished 18th in 2023. We only have one game against West Coast in 2024.

Ok my bad.
So how does a team that finished 4th get given two games against the team that finished 17th then? How does that happen?

 

[Robertio]

Ok my bad.
So how does a team that finished 4th get given two games against the team that finished 17th then? How does that happen?

Don't know mate, we finished 3rd.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Ninth spot on the ladder is higher than any spot below it mate, if Pies finish above Carlton then they have had the better season and Carlton supporters would acknowledge that because we know football.

Can't be outside the 8, right next to another team on the ladder that's beaten you twice and seriously think you are better than them. Only a loser club with a loser culture would think like that.

Time to man up Carlton. Face your failure and mediocrity. This denial is what's holding you back.. amongst a few other things

 

[Robertio]

Can't be outside the 8, right next to another team on the ladder that's beaten you twice and seriously think you are better than them. Only a loser club with a loser culture would think like that.

Time to man up Carlton. Face your failure and mediocrity. This denial is what's holding you back.. amongst a few other things

Go and grab a latte mate you're making me feel clever this morning.