Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[BennyGFunk]

not very often you get the treat of knocking carlton out of finals in consecutive years. fun times to be a lions supporter.

The Gabba holds no fears for us

 

[Fadge]

I thought it was a gutsy performance all things considered, but it’s not really about that game.

It just makes no sense to refer to the Dockers as ‘falling over’ when it was simply a loss. But if it helps you sleep better, go for your life.

A 'gutsy' performance, losing to the 14th placed team in a game you needed to win to qualify for finals, in a year that you're meant to be a genuine premiership contender after building and rebuilding for more than two decades?

Wowee.

 

[Fadge]

Cameron is like Pittonet if he didn’t have a TDK to compete with (Brodie Grundy)

Good player, top 100 for sure, top 6 ruckman. AA squad?

Who’s selecting the team, the Collingwood cheer squad?

You were told midway through the season that Cameron was in the mix for the AA Squad, and you all scoffed at the thought.

Schooled again.

But there are some of us that understand footy, and those of you who just watch it through your rose coloured glasses and only see what you want to see...

 

[Fadge]

And whose fault is that ffs? Had you not choked against Collingwood (for the second time in two seasons), you could have had the double chance and definitely gone to a PF after the SF.

You could say that Collingwood have ruined your year twice in a row. After you beat them twice last year and were full of confidence in the GF after Collingwood came off scores of 9.6.60 and 8.10.58 in the previous two finals. Now because they kicked 3 goals in the last 3 minutes against you a few days ago, you get to beat us in the EF before losing in the SF.

View attachment 2093164

So what you're saying is...

Collingwood >>> Brisbane >>> Carlton

 

[Worm4]

A 'gutsy' performance, losing to the 14th placed team in a game you needed to win to qualify for finals, in a year that you're meant to be a genuine premiership contender after building and rebuilding for more than two decades?

Wowee.

Just checking, were Collingwood meant to be a genuine contender this year ?

 

[Fadge]

Just checking, were Collingwood meant to be a genuine contender this year ?

Collingwood expect to contend for the premiershop most years, but haven't been building and rebuilding for more than two decades to get to where we are today, and have the 2023 flag in the back pocket.

So don't go comparing Carlton with Collingwood - there is no comparison.

 

[RPCB]

So what you're saying is...

Collingwood >>> Brisbane >>> Carlton

We only choke in H&A matches, and give teams 3 quarters to kick a winning score in a PF.

Brisbane do their choking in a GF and the last 3 minutes of Round 24 up by 3 goals.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Collingwood expect to contend for the premiershop most years, but haven't been building and rebuilding for more than two decades to get to where we are today, and have the 2023 flag in the back pocket.

So don't go comparing Carlton with Collingwood - there is no comparison.

Eight flags to your three since 1958 there is no comparison indeed.

 

[RPCB]

Eight flags to your three since 1958 there is no comparison indeed.

Collingwood fans don’t count VFL anymore.

 

[Worm4]

To those Carlton supporters who were bagging out Darcy Cameron during the year (I don't care enough about who it was to specifically recall exactly who they were) - thoughts on his inclusion in the AA Squad

Well i know for a fact that you held McKay in a similar stratosphere as well. Egg on face much ?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Collingwood fans don’t count VFL anymore.

The 12 team state comp? Try winning a flag in a REAL league with 18 teams

 

[Fadge]

We only choke in H&A matches, and give teams 3 quarters to kick a winning score in a PF.

Brisbane do their choking in a GF and the last 3 minutes of Round 24 up by 3 goals.

Yeah, I guess you'd have to play in a Grand Final to 'choke' in one...

 

[Fadge]

Well i know for a fact that you held McKay in a similar stratosphere as well. Egg on face much ?

No egg on my face.

I said McKay hadn't performed in the top 100 players in the competition across 2022 and 2023, and provided data to support that.

He's clearly had a better year this year, and deserves his spot in the AA squad (though we all know, like Cameron, he's not making the team).

 

[Fadge]

The 12 team state comp? Try winning a flag in a REAL league with 18 teams

When your books are audited.

 

[RPCB]

The 12 team state comp? Try winning a flag in a REAL league with 18 teams

What’s this? Did you just say Collingwood only have one real flag?

Kind of stepped into that one didn’t you?

Yeah, I guess you'd have to play in a Grand Final to 'choke' in one...

Although we are all enjoying this Collingwood/Brisbane love-in on here, it’s weird.

Your supporters were giving theirs shit only last year. I suppose you need support from some of their supporters on here against the big, bad Carlton. Can’t fight your own battles.

 

[VinnieB]

That was last year wasn't it though? We've been to the Gabba already and won up there.

All this talk about a nine or ten goal winning margin for the lions will suit us down to the ground imo.

Yeah. Will probably be more like 12-14 goals.

 

[Fadge]

Although we are all enjoying this Collingwood/Brisbane love-in on here, it’s weird.

Your supporters were giving theirs shit only last year. I suppose you need support from some of their supporters on here against the big, bad Carlton. Can’t fight your own battles.

When were Collingwood supporters 'giving Brisbane supporters shite'?

The Collingwood and Brisbane supporter bases generally have a healthy respect for one another, borne out of a number of recent classic encounters, including having matched up against one another in 3 Grand Finals since the turn of the century (more than any other clubs).

Carlton, meanwhile... neither supporter base has any respect for them. For obvious reasons.

 

[VinnieB]

What’s this? Did you just say Collingwood only have one real flag?

Kind of stepped into that one didn’t you?


Although we are all enjoying this Collingwood/Brisbane love-in on here, it’s weird.

Your supporters were giving theirs shit only last year. I suppose you need support from some of their supporters on here against the big, bad Carlton. Can’t fight your own battles.

Lions fans know we were a 5 goal better side in the GF.

 

[DopeMaster]

Put this in your pipe Collingwood and smoke it.

View attachment 2093146

 

[Fadge]

Yeah. Will probably be more like 12-14 goals.

Brisbane will get to a healthy lead and put the cue in the rack, winding down to win by a comfortable margin.

In the same way they did in last year's Preliminary Final.

 

[RPCB]

When were Collingwood supporters 'giving Brisbane supporters shite'?

The Collingwood and Brisbane supporter bases generally have a healthy respect for one another, borne out of a number of recent classic encounters, including having matched up against one another in 3 Grand Finals since the turn of the century (more than any other clubs).

Carlton, meanwhile... neither supporter base has any respect for them. For obvious reasons.

Respect and Collingwood…

In the same sentence. Jeez.

 

[VinnieB]

Brisbane will get to a healthy lead and put the cue in the rack, winding down to win by a comfortable margin.

In the same way they did in last year's Preliminary Final.

I think it all comes down to whether Curnow plays. If he doesn’t, yeah, they could reduce the margin to 8 goals.

 

[carlton_99]

McRae would ask them to return the car nicely

 

[Robertio]

You were told midway through the season that Cameron was in the mix for the AA Squad, and you all scoffed at the thought.

Schooled again.

But there are some of us that understand footy, and those of you who just watch it through your rose coloured glasses and only see what you want to see...

You scoffed at Harry McKay and he seems to be in the squad as well.

 

[Robertio]

Brisbane will get to a healthy lead and put the cue in the rack, winding down to win by a comfortable margin.

In the same way they did in last year's Preliminary Final.

Who are the Pies playing in the first week of finals?