Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Chronz]

McGovern

 

[CarmenSandiego]

We're talking about going into next year.

2 (knee reco's) plus 1 (knee reco) = 3 (knee reco's).

Point out the 30 plus year olds on Collingwood's list with similar injury history?

No we weren’t.

Poster I was responding to was saying our top players were available all year (2024), I listed our top 10 BnF of 2023 & their availability for 2024. Docherty finished 7th, thus for 2024 he was a huge loss.

You just derail things with stupid repetitive troll shit.

 

[South of the Yarra]

I've seen 8 to 3, glorious

Wondering how many living pie supporters have seen more

My 'Dad' has seen 11

 

[South of the Yarra]

Personal attacks are getting out of hand by both sides

Footy, cheeky banter, even trolling (I guess) but leave the other crap for the bay

Perfectly said

 

[Fadge]

No we weren’t.

Poster I was responding to was saying our top players were available all year (2024), I listed our top 10 BnF of 2023 & their availability for 2024. Docherty finished 7th, thus for 2024 he was a huge loss.

You just derail things with stupid repetitive troll shit.

This thread is about 2025.

If you're relying on a post 3 x knee reco 31 year old Docherty to elevate your team into premiership contention, good luck.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

This thread is about 2025.

If you're relying on a post 3 x knee reco 31 year old Docherty to elevate your team into premiership contention, good luck.

do a word search for:

‘The turn of the century’
‘The last 25 years’
‘This millennium’

See who’s the biggest culprit of talking about everything but 2025.

Grow up.

 

[Fadge]

do a word search for:

‘The turn of the century’
‘The last 25 years’
‘This millennium’

See who’s the biggest culprit of talking about everything but 2025.

Grow up.

Just 'responding in kind'.

Be sure to highlight as such to Carlton posters who go back much further in time.

Or don't.

P.S. Have you had a bad day? You seem quite angry.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Love it how 32yo is suddenly a bad thing now. Aren’t there 7 32yo or older in your ‘top 15’ for the pies?

Yep and you lot have been calling them geriatrics. None of them have had 3 knee recos though.

 

[Chronz]

It is a thread on the Main Board.

All supporters are very welcome.

To be fair Yoda_ can dish it out but cannot handle a return serve. I remember a certain incident on the pies board where I called him out for laugh liking posts on a gameday fred. Did not like it one bit when I kept @'ing him after the a comeback win. Was quite the meltdown.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Yep and you lot have been calling them geriatrics. None of them have had 3 knee recos though.

Blokes beat cancer twice.

I’ll back him to contribute if he still thinks he can, no matter what scritchyscrooflog & fudge think of him

 

[Fadge]

Blokes beat cancer twice.

I’ll back him to contribute if he still thinks he can, no matter what scritchyscrooflog & fudge think of him

Credit to him.

Still doesn't change the fact I wouldn't be counting on him to elevate Carlton into flag contention.

 

[Yoda_]

To be fair Yoda_ can dish it out but cannot handle a return serve. I remember a certain incident on the pies board where I called him out for laugh liking posts on a gameday fred. Did not like it one bit when I kept @'ing him after the a comeback win. Was quite the meltdown.

thankfully people grow up and mature

 

[Wosh]

Chief surely Essington is banned like Norf is ?

Yes and if you report it we will see it and remove it.

 

[Worm4]

This thread is about 2025.

If you're relying on a post 3 x knee reco 31 year old Docherty to elevate your team into premiership contention, good luck.

You think that McStay who turns 30 , and mitchell 33, during the season will elevate the pies to premiership contention.

 

[Chronz]

thankfully people grow up and mature

Loosen up a bit, this is a banter fred.

 

[Arr0w]

Well if no one reports it it’s on them. We don’t sit here reading this thread, ew

You are missing out on all the entertainment Wosh

 

[Wosh]

Also keep the personal stuff out of it, if banter over a game makes you pop a vein then go do something else until you cool down. No abuse and absolutely no bringing family or anything else personal into it.
Use the report button, thanks.

 

[Wosh]

You are missing out on all the entertainment Wosh

It's like Days Of Our Lives Arrow, you can miss months then come back to it and the same storyline is still on loop with the same actors.

 

[Chronz]

thought genuine debate and common sense could have a reasonable discussion, my mistake

You won't find that in here!

 

[Cyclops]

and umpires, lets at least try to keep it real see that North game, lol and you still didn't make the 8. You gotta sack McRae if you don't make the 8 this season, and trade out all your good players for draft picks.

Lol you want him so badly you can taste it.

 

[Arr0w]

Lol you want him so badly you can taste it.

You're just one eyed Cyclops

 

[beerbandit]

My 'Dad' has seen 11

Ive a grandparent who is 11 Pies v 10 Blues. So how far do you want to stretch the string Arr0w.

 

[Fadge]

You think that McStay who turns 30 , and mitchell 33, during the season will elevate the pies to premiership contention.

Collingwood's squad has already been there, 14 months ago.

And it has been improved with Houston and Perryman.

 

[Arr0w]

Ive a grandparent who is 11 Pies v 10 Blues. So how far do you want to stretch the string Arr0w.

Double the distance from one end to the middle?

Seriously though, that's a great innings

 

[beerbandit]

Double the distance from one end to the middle?

Seriously though, that's a great innings

Yep born 1920. Still sharp as a tack