Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Pistol Night]

Imagine adding 2 years to each player on the Collingwood list in your discussion, fadge and his cohorts would be piling into you for making up boolshit and calling you a liar

Add 4. **** it

 

[Pistol Night]

The same level of analysis should be used on Beema's comments on our age profile.

Incredibly... We actually have young players on our list who will end up replacing Docherty, Newman, Cripps etc... we're in no rush to do so however.

We do have a few too but im sure they are shit

 

[Worm4]

Richmond might have outsmarted us all with Tassie coming in

Will cross that bridge when we come to it. Until then, it's going to be the year of the microwave memberships

 

[beema limapep]

My work is done here.

Merry Christmas you filthy cretins.

 

[Pistol Night]

Will cross that bridge when we come to it. Until then, it's going to be the year of the microwave memberships

Might as well cook the campaigner now rather than get angry when they are inevitably bad. They'd take it after 3 flags and the drafts coming up. Flags in the bank are worth more than hypothetical wish ones

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

We do have a few too but im sure they are shit

Finn McSpud and Ned Long? Absolutely

 

[Pistol Night]

Finn McSpud and Ned Long? Absolutely

Agreed. You're very hard to debate rationally with.

 

[carlton_99]

Military like preparation and dedication is key. The bloke is at training day 1 every year with the 1-4 year players every year. I recon we lose in 2023 without him in that last quarter. Literally directing on filed. I think a lot of great players retire too early. Fine line though

Guess you gotta still enjoy the game. If the enjoyment isn't there for pre-season training you'll struggle to stay motivated

 

[Pistol Night]

Guess you gotta still enjoy the game. If the enjoyment isn't there for pre-season training you'll struggle to stay motivated

Dusty looked as motivated as me at a school concert this year

 

[doppleganger]

I think Sydney's under 26s have way more depth than Carltons though. 80% of Carltons better players are either over 30 or just about 30.

Spot on

Blakey, Warner, McInerney, Rowbottom, Campbell, Gulden, McDonald all born in the 2000s

Baggers spent almost 10 years in Mexico "building" and have nothing to show for it. 2025 or bust for the Baggers.

 

[Worm4]

Spot on

Blakey, Warner, McInerney, Rowbottom, Campbell, Gulden, McDonald all born in the 2000s

Baggers spent almost 10 years in Mexico "building" and have nothing to show for it. 2025 or bust for the Baggers.

Think we were a bit more south - like the Antarctic

 

[Pistol Night]

Spot on

Blakey, Warner, McInerney, Rowbottom, Campbell, Gulden, McDonald all born in the 2000s

Baggers spent almost 10 years in Mexico "building" and have nothing to show for it. 2025 or bust for the Baggers.

They have time but they’ve had 3 years of prime opportunity also. Improvement isn’t necessarily linear. Who knows if the team play at the same level this year. Improvement isn’t necessarily not being a smart arse but what improvement will come this year? Smith hopefully hits the ground running? Walsh and Cerra healthy?

 

[Arr0w]

They have time but they’ve had 3 years of prime opportunity also. Improvement isn’t necessarily linear. Who knows if the team play at the same level this year. Improvement isn’t necessarily not being a smart arse but what improvement will come this year? Smith hopefully hits the ground running? Walsh and Cerra healthy?

This was the first of our prime years

As for how we will improve, read the same stuff when the "analysts" picked us for 13th the last 2 years

 

[Pistol Night]

This was the first of our prime years

As for how we will improve, read the same stuff when the "analysts" picked us for 13th the last 2 years

Yeah who knows. Premiership windows are pretty variable. Port are making a mess of theirs. Sydney have shit in theirs. Geelong keep coming back like an ugly stripper you accidentally make eye contact with

 

[doppleganger]

Think we were a bit more south - like the Antarctic

Blues took up permanent residency in Mexico City.

Pies had a post premiership holiday in Baja California.

 

[doppleganger]

They have time but they’ve had 3 years of prime opportunity also. Improvement isn’t necessarily linear. Who knows if the team play at the same level this year. Improvement isn’t necessarily not being a smart arse but what improvement will come this year? Smith hopefully hits the ground running? Walsh and Cerra healthy?

Agree, still a chance in 2025.

If they can't deliver more than 13 wins next year they won't with the Crippa.

 

[Pistol Night]

Agree, still a chance in 2025.

If they can't deliver more than 13 wins next year they won't with the Crippa.

There’s time but you other teams continue to improve, revise game plans etc so they need to strike now. After 2021 who had us going prelim, flag?

 

[Fadge]

I think Beema needs to turn his attention as to which minute of the first quarter he thinks he might want to turn the TV off , for the next 20 games or so.

Which minute of the first quarter did you turn the TV off when Carlton last played?

 

[Fadge]

The same level of analysis should be used on Beema's comments on our age profile.

Incredibly... We actually have young players on our list who will end up replacing Docherty, Newman, Cripps etc... we're in no rush to do so however.

Awesome.

Carlton should easily be able to replace non-Premiership players with.... non-Premiership players.

 

[Fadge]

Imagine adding 2 years to each player on the Collingwood list in your discussion, fadge and his cohorts would be piling into you for making up boolshit and calling you a liar

Even though he explained how he arrived at the ages he posted, but no surprise you either ignored it, missed it, or couldn't comprehend it.

Most likely the latter.

 

[Fadge]

This was the first of our prime years

Yes, of course it was.....

 

[Arr0w]

Yes, of course, but Pies will finish top 4 while Carlton will finish 13th or lower

Worst "analyst" on BF

 

[Fadge]

Worst "analyst" on BF

Stalking again.

Do I need to remind you?

 

[Arr0w]

Agree, still a chance in 2025.

If they can't deliver more than 13 wins next year they won't with the Crippa.

Was this based on "How will Carlton bridge the 5 game gap"?

Great 'analysis" that one

 

[Arr0w]

Stalking again.

Do I need to remind you?

You responded to me fudgee

Or was that "resonding"