Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Worm4]

So how does one separate both clubs? We've been over this before. You go to the next best metric.

The next best metric is the head to head in Grand finals, when it really counts most.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

The next best metric is the head to head in Grand finals, when it really counts most.

Isn't it favourite colours? Whoever had the coolest favourite colours is ahead on the table Wormy... [emoji849]

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Worm4]

Isn't it favourite colours? Whoever had the coolest favourite colours is ahead on the table Wormy... [emoji849]

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Black and white are merely shades.
Colour is where it's at I have to agree. Navy blue it is

 

[Fadge]

Chris Judd says hello ( in his 3rd year)

It would be a good point, except....

1. What did Chris Judd lead West Coast to in his third year? It wasn't until his 5th year that West Coast won a premiership, and...

2. Whilst the Fadgelow wasn't a thing in Judd's 3rd year, if it was awarded retrospectively, it wouldn't have gone to Judd. That honour would have been bestowed upon Nick Riewoldt - the Players MVP, and the Brownlow Medal favourite before that year's count.

 

[Worm4]

It would be a good point, except....

1. What did Chris Judd lead West Coast to in his third year? It wasn't until his 5th year that West Coast won a premiership, and...

2. Whilst the Fadgelow wasn't a thing in Judd's 3rd year, if it was awarded retrospectively, it wouldn't have gone to Judd. That honour would have been bestowed upon Nick Riewoldt - the Players MVP, and the Brownlow Medal favourite before that year's count.

I'm getting concerned that a phrase initially coined by me personally, is gaining some serious momentum..
Should I have trademarked the "fadgelow" ?

 

[Thrawn]

is the least impactful player in history.

Leon Davis searching for a possession in the 2002 GF

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

So you'll have no problems finding vision of him being exposed in big moments, like Walsh was when Daicos led him a merry dance to kick the winning goal against Carlton?

But please, keep the articles from round 2, 2024 against St. Kilda coming.... 3 games after their 2023 flag...

Where's the one that he ran away from contact straight out of bounds just to avoid copping a hit?

I'll go dig that one up if u remember which game it was

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Another incredible defensive effort from Squibby after squibbing yet another contest in tight

 

[Arr0w]

Another incredible defensive effort from Squibby after squibbing yet another contest in tight

Damning, cost his side finals in 2024

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Fat spud Walsh is probably still looking for Daics [emoji38] where did he go?

Impact [emoji106]

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

Damning, cost his side finals in 2024

It's actually interesting that you keep saying this, and in fact a massive compliment to how good Nick Daicos is when:

1. He was by far the best player in his team - as a 21 year old;
2. He was again one of the best handful of players in the competition - as a 21 year old;
3. In a team that finished 9th and where he had little support around the ball, and was forced to play a role that is not his most suitable or natural - as a 21 year old.

And despite all of the above, there are some people out there like you that are saying that he was the reason his team didn't make finals - the expectation that he should have played even better?

You're quite brilliant, CArr0w!

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

It's actually interesting that you keep saying this, and in fact a massive compliment to how good Nick Daicos is when:

1. He was by far the best player in his team - as a 21 year old;
2. He was again one of the best handful of players in the competition - as a 21 year old;
3. In a team that finished 9th and where he had little support around the ball, and was forced to play a role that is not his most suitable or natural - as a 21 year old.

And despite all of the above, there are some people out there like you that are saying that he was the reason his team didn't make finals - the expectation that he should have played even better?

You're quite brilliant, CArr0w!

And yet he refused to put his body on the line time after time just looking for the easy handball receives from teammates to up his vote counts.

There's a reason he's not considered a 'leader' on field. Because he's only interested in filling his own pockets and getting as much camera time as he can.

Demanding a Brownlow clause he put in ur contract as an 18 year old is about as narcissistic as one can get.

 

[doppleganger]

Where's the one that he ran away from contact straight out of bounds just to avoid copping a hit?

I'll go dig that one up if u remember which game it was

A few from the 2023 GF for you, all from the sams game to help you find em.

The one where he wins 1st possession in CB in GF when we have just gone behind and then follows up with another ball win and goal assist to get us back in front.

Then perhaps show the highlight of his composure in final manic moments, where je wins the ball but instead of a panic helicopter dump kick he spots WHE and chips it to him for a mark so pressure is releived and we wind down the clock.

Or perhaps post the highlight where just before half time, he takes the game on and cuts inside to eventually lead to a Pies goal, where most players would have played safe and just ran the clock down.

GOATcos dominated the GF and was a huge reason why Pies were premiers.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

A few from the 2023 GF for you, all from the sams game to help you find em.

The one where he wins 1st possession in CB in GF when we have just gone behind and then follows up with another ball win and goal assist to get us back in front.

Then perhaps show the highlight of his composure in final manic moments, where je wins the ball but instead of a panic helicopter dump kick he spots WHE and chips it to him for a mark so pressure is releived and we wind down the clock.

Or perhaps post the highlight where just before half time, he takes the game on and cuts inside to eventually lead to a Pies goal, where most players would have played safe and just ran the clock down.

GOATcos dominated the GF and was a huge reason why Pies were premiers.

Sorry that's not what I asked about. Which game was the one where he ran away from his opponent straight over the boundary line like the squib he is to avoid contact?

I think it was the gold coast game right?

 

[Arr0w]

It's actually interesting that you keep saying this, and in fact a massive compliment to how good Nick Daicos is when:

1. He was by far the best player in his team - as a 21 year old;
2. He was again one of the best handful of players in the competition - as a 21 year old;
3. In a team that finished 9th and where he had little support around the ball, and was forced to play a role that is not his most suitable or natural - as a 21 year old.

And despite all of the above, there are some people out there like you that are saying that he was the reason his team didn't make finals - the expectation that he should have played even better?

You're quite brilliant, CArr0w!

Selfish chasing individual accolades, rather than doing team ethos acts, damning

You're not brilliant at all feathers

 

[Scritchyscroony]

I'm getting concerned that a phrase initially coined by me personally, is gaining some serious momentum..
Should I have trademarked the "fadgelow" ?

Kudos to you for recognising Fadge's excellence in rating players and coming up with the name for footballs most prestigious award.

Legally it's too late to trademark now sorry. It's in common use in the public domain.

 

[Fadge]

A few from the 2023 GF for you, all from the sams game to help you find em.

The one where he wins 1st possession in CB in GF when we have just gone behind and then follows up with another ball win and goal assist to get us back in front.

Then perhaps show the highlight of his composure in final manic moments, where je wins the ball but instead of a panic helicopter dump kick he spots WHE and chips it to him for a mark so pressure is releived and we wind down the clock.

Or perhaps post the highlight where just before half time, he takes the game on and cuts inside to eventually lead to a Pies goal, where most players would have played safe and just ran the clock down.

GOATcos dominated the GF and was a huge reason why Pies were premiers.

Shhhh.

Enough talk about the big moments in the biggest game a player can play in. As a 20 year old.

Let's get back to midway through the second quarter in a round 2 game against St. Kilda.

 

[Arr0w]

Sorry that's not what I asked about. Which game was the one where he ran away from his opponent straight over the boundary line like the squib he is to avoid contact?

I think it was the gold coast game right?

Against the Bombers, damning

 

[Fadge]

Shhhh.

Enough talk about the big moments in the biggest game a player can play in. As a 20 year old.

Let's get back to midway through the second quarter in a round 2 game against St. Kilda.

Sorry that's not what I asked about. Which game was the one where he ran away from his opponent straight over the boundary line like the squib he is to avoid contact?

I think it was the gold coast game right?

Or alternatively a Round 14 game against Gold Coast (where he actually kicked a goal of the year nomination to put his team in front in the dying minutes of the game).

 

[Arr0w]

Or alternatively a Round 14 game against Gold Coast (where he actually kicked a goal of the year nomination to put his team in front in the dying minutes of the game).

But lost the game due to other selfish acts

 

[Ctracks]

Gees the shit talking Carlton flogs love a good yap about H&A games. They love to swallow their own shit out their mouth.

Bunch of geriatric w️
It’s been such a long time they can talk about recent premiership players.
Sad! Pathetic!

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Or alternatively a Round 14 game against Gold Coast (where he actually kicked a goal of the year nomination to put his team in front in the dying minutes of the game).

Oh that's right... That was the game he shamelessly took a dive for a free kick. I get them confused because he does that on a weekly basis.

But thanks to Arr0w above, it was against Essendon... Funnily enough, with the game on the line!

 

[Fadge]

But lost the game due to other selfish acts

3 Brownlow votes and 8 coaches votes in that game, against a team who only lost a single game on their home ground all year (against the eventual premiers).

As a 21 year old.

'But he should have done more'.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Gees the shit talking Carlton flogs love a good yap about H&A games. They love to swallow their own shit out their mouth.

Bunch of geriatric w️
It’s been such a long time they can talk about recent premiership players.
Sad! Pathetic!

Geriatrics? Ironic given u support a team that's fielding the oldest list in AFL history going into 2025

 

[Fadge]

Oh that's right... That was the game he shamelessly took a dive for a free kick. I get them confused because he does that on a weekly basis.

But thanks to Arr0w above, it was against Essendon... Funnily enough, with the game on the line!

'With the game on the line'

25 points down with 10 minutes to go.