Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Collingwood

    Votes: 110 51.4%
  • Carlton

    Votes: 104 48.6%

  • Total voters
    214

Remove this Banner Ad

In ur opinion we've gone backwards... Yet we're currently sitting 3rd (above the Pies) on the markets to win the 2025 Premiership.

I'd say the Blues made some necessary changes to the list and are backing in some promising youngsters to make up the gap, just as the Pies did in 2022/23 bringing in Ginnipig, McReery, Nicky, Bobby Hill etc.
Far too funny, again.

Surprise, surprise.... yet another year where people are getting seduced by Carlton's top 6 players. Who would have thought?

Are you forgetting that Collingwood also brought in Mitchell and McStay at the start of 2023?

Good clubs don't stand still - they improve their lists every year when they believe they're in the premiership window.

And then we have Carlton....
 
Cripps loves being undisputed top dog at Princes Park, that's why he bottles it in big games and finals, any team success will see him lose his status

Is he the most selfish player in history? Either him or Robert Harvey

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
😂 Everything Cripps has done in his career to date has screamed the exact opposite of selfish.

Nicky on the other hand is narcissist personified
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Far too funny, again.

Surprise, surprise.... yet another year where people are getting seduced by Carlton's top 6 players. Who would have thought?

Are you forgetting that Collingwood also brought in Mitchell and McStay at the start of 2023?

Good clubs don't stand still - they improve their lists every year when they believe they're in the premiership window.

And then we have Carlton....
We just brought in who we consider the best kid in the draft lmao. Not sure they'd be calling that moving backwards.

Pies on the other hand brought in another senior player to surround their ancient geriatric army... Will Dan be enough to cover the mass decline of the senior citizens down at Pieland?
 
😂 Everything Cripps has done in his career to date has screamed the exact opposite of selfish.

Nicky on the other hand is narcissist personified
How can you say that?

You blokes have constantly been telling us Daicos costs Collingwood games, despite having played in a team that has contended for the premiership twice in his four year career to date.

Meanwhile, Cripps' team is yet to contend for a premiership in his 11 year career.

How can Daicos be selfish when he's experienced the ultimate team success, and Cripps not selfish despite never getting near team success?
 
Everything Cripps has done in his career to date has screamed the exact opposite of selfish.

Nicky on the other hand is narcissist personified
Rubbish, Cripps get caught htb all the time trying to do everything himself so he can get another 3 votes

Daics wins finals, grand finals

Cripps wins games against bottom 3 sides

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

How can you say that?

You blokes have constantly been telling us Daicos costs Collingwood games, despite having played in a team that has contended for the premiership twice in his four year career to date.

Meanwhile, Cripps' team is yet to contend for a premiership in his 11 year career.

How can Daicos be selfish when he's experienced the ultimate team success, and Cripps not selfish despite never getting near team success?
Was Jason Akermanis selfish Fadge?
 
We just brought in who we consider the best kid in the draft lmao. Not sure they'd be calling that moving backwards.

Pies on the other hand brought in another senior player to surround their ancient geriatric army... Will Dan be enough to cover the mass decline of the senior citizens down at Pieland?
You know I think Jagga will be a gun, eventually.

But to expect him to compensate for what was offered by Kennedy, Owies and Martin (when fit) combined?

Not as a 19 year old I'm afraid.
 
Was an interesting leap indeed....

But I'm reliably informed Akermanis held the goal assist record for a number of years (suspect until Stevie J and Mooney waxed off of one another when they were able to play Harlem Globetrotters type footy when they were the dominant team of the competition).

So he can't have been that selfish...
 
Rubbish, Cripps get caught htb all the time trying to do everything himself so he can get another 3 votes

Daics wins finals, grand finals

Cripps wins games against bottom 3 sides

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Cripps just got voted the 2nd best captain in the AFL 😂

He's had dozens of offers to join other teams and get more money yet he's stuck by Carlton throughout, taken paycuts to bring in more talent and has played through hardship and injury for years and years when he could have easily chucked in all in to move on to greener pastures.

This is almost as dumb as the 'Walsh is a soft runner' clown show last night 😂😂😂
 
You know I think Jagga will be a gun, eventually.

But to expect him to compensate for what was offered by Kennedy, Owies and Martin (when fit) combined?

Not as a 19 year old I'm afraid.
Kennedy will be missed, but Cerra being fit will account for him quite easily.

Owies was an absolute spud and you all said so yourselves for years, the second he left he's all of the sudden the 2nd coming 😂

Martin was made of cellophane so yes, we might miss the 3 good games a year he played for us... Moir should have that covered no problem if he continues on his trajectory.

So yeah... I'm just not really buying the 'we've gone backwards' rubbish your trying to make stick Fudgey...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Back
Top