Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Chronz]

Lets start a timeline from 2024 the most recent season, oh and guess who's in front.

Collingwood beat Carlton two out of two times in 2024.

 

[Robertio]

Pies 2-0

Pies finished 9th by the look of the ladder, they might have lost to a team that Carlton beat.

 

[Robertio]

Collingwood beat Carlton two out of two times in 2024.
View attachment 2197908

Where did they officially finish?

 

[South of the Yarra]

Not sure why you need to keep mentioning the Tigers, we have you covered on our own since WWII

The fact you have to select World War 11 shows you do not have us covered. You have to cherry pick time frames hence your status as a non-powerhouse of the AFL.

 

[South of the Yarra]

Don't you know when it started mate? Google is your friend.

I am happy to embrace my club's entire history. Not cherry pick time frames like Carlton.

 

[Fadge]

How about inside the eight and collecting pick 3, does that sound like the truth to you?

Poor Jagga.

Such a gun, but unlikely to see team success in his career.

Hopefully you don't Paddy Dow him before he's ready to come home to Collingwood in 5 years.

 

[Robertio]

Poor Jagga.

Such a gun, but unlikely to see team success in his career.

Hopefully you don't Paddy Dow him before he's ready to come home to Collingwood in 5 years.

How many 1st round picks have the Pies destroyed, started with 2013 where there was two of them.

 

[Fadge]

Lets start a timeline from 2024 the most recent season, oh and guess who's in front.

0 finals wins each, and head to head - Pies 2 v. Blues 0.

Enjoy being 'ahead'.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

MR never disappoints with his made up statistical analyses. Save it for the Geelong fred.
I do find reading through your long winded posts entertaining though. Can you give us your in depth insights about the 2010 grand final series now?

I must object in the strongest possible terms Chronz. I do not make up these facts and figures. I merely notice them.

The 2010 Grand Final was drawn by the way.

Cogrstulations on your victory in the mulligan match by the way. Pastries FC specialises in taking out flags through mulligan matches. Embrace it. I do.

 

[Robertio]

0 finals wins each, and head to head - Pies 2 v. Blues 0.

Enjoy being 'ahead'.

Carlton were better we finished ahead of the Pies, the ladder doesn't work like you think it does oh boy.

 

[Fadge]

How many 1st round picks have the Pies destroyed, started with 2013 where there was two of them.

Three first rounders that I can think of off the top of my head...

Darcy Moore - premiership captain.

Jordan De Goey - premiership player and proven elite finals performers.

Nick Daicos - premiership player and the best performed player in the competition across 2023/24.

 

[Robertio]

I must object in the strongest possible terms Chronz. I do not make up these facts and figures. I merely notice them.

The 2010 Grand Final was drawn by the way.

Cogrstulations on your victory in the mulligan match by the way. Pastries FC specialises in taking out flags through mulligan matches. Embrace it. I do.

Saints are the moral winners from 2010, the ball bounces as it does 99 times out of 100 to Stevie Milne game over.

 

[doppleganger]

Pies finished 9th by the look of the ladder, they might have lost to a team that Carlton beat.

Unlike Carlton's glory VFL era in the 1960s, teams no longer have the same H&A fixture where they play all other teams twice.

So yes in 2024, Carlton got 4 games and 4 wins against historically inept teams and the Pies only played 2 games for 2 wins against them.

Why would a Pie fan care that Carlton beat up on Richmond? We would have too if given the chance.

When Pies played Carlton in 2024, the Pies won both.

2024 timeline is 2-0 to the Pies.

 

[YeoShuey]

Three first rounders that I can think of off the top of my head...

Darcy Moore - premiership captain.

Jordan De Goey - premiership player and proven elite finals performers.

Nick Daicos - premiership player and the best performed player in the competition across 2023/24.

Nice concession there that Collingwood have destroyed all of them.

 

[Chronz]

The 2010 Grand Final was drawn by the way.

It certainly was. Which is why a second grand final was played, and who won said grand final?
Please spare no detail in your response, it's always a good read.

 

[Robertio]

Three first rounders that I can think of off the top of my head...

Darcy Moore - premiership captain.

Jordan De Goey - premiership player and proven elite finals performers.

Nick Daicos - premiership player and the best performed player in the competition across 2023/24.

Two of them father sons and Carlton Weitering, Mckay Curnow Walsh Hollands Moir who are guns and 2 who will be

 

[Robertio]

Unlike Carlton's glory VFL era in the 1960s, teams no longer have the same H&A fixture where they play all other teams twice.

So yes in 2024, Carlton got 4 games and 4 wins against historically inept teams and the Pies only played 2 games for 2 wins against them.

Why would a Pie fan care that Carlton beat up on Richmond? We would have too if given the chance.

When Pies played Carlton in 2024, the Pies won both.

2024 timeline is 2-0 to the Pies.

Carlton played more games against top 4 sides didn't they?

 

[South of the Yarra]

Saints are the moral winners from 2010, the ball bounces as it does 99 times out of 100 to Stevie Milne game over.

Not sure Carlton supporters should be talking about 'moral' Grand Finals.

 

[Fadge]

Nice concession there that Collingwood have destroyed all of them.

Indeed.

Destroyed all of them, by turning them into premiership players, including one premiership captain, and another the best player in the competition by the end of his second year in the system.

 

[Fadge]

Two of them father sons and Carlton Weitering, Mckay Curnow Walsh Hollands Moir who are guns and 2 who will be

'Will be'.

Is that like 'You know we're coming'?

No premiership players amongst them?

 

[Robertio]

Not sure Carlton supporters should be talking about 'moral' Grand Finals.

Don't go there mate you don't have any proof only that you think they cheated.

 

[Robertio]

'Will be'.

Is that like 'You know we're coming'?

Just like Daicos will be the GOAT mate.

 

[South of the Yarra]

Picture of the MCG when Carlton won their last flag.

 

[Fadge]

Just like Daicos will be the GOAT mate.

Daicos is more likely to become the GOAT than those players premiership players...

 

[YeoShuey]

Indeed.

Destroyed all of them, by turning them into premiership players, including one premiership captain, and another the best player in the competition by the end of his second year in the system.

I see reading comprehension is still not your strong point.

QUESTION: How many 1st round picks have the Pies destroyed, started with 2013 where there was two of them.

ANSWER:

Three first rounders that I can think of off the top of my head...

Darcy Moore - premiership captain.

Jordan De Goey - premiership player and proven elite finals performers.

Nick Daicos - premiership player and the best performed player in the competition across 2023/24.

So which is it?

A: Lack of reading comprehension that you are unable to answer a question that was asked, instead by answering with something that wasn't asked?, or

B: You concede to the argument that Collingwood destroyed these first round picks.

There are no ifs and buts about this. It is one or the other.