Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Fadge]

So you say that Carlton made the eight because of an easy draw when the Pies couldn't beat a side that finished below them once, can you think about that one?

There was a certain team that finished below Carlton that played them twice, and won both games.

You really don't think before you post, do you?

 

[Robertio]

Couldn't beat the Suns, Dockers, Bombers x 2, but apparently we had the soft draw

Seems like the Pies had the soft draw and couldn't make the 8

I can't believe how many smooth brainers are in here mate.

 

[Arr0w]

Cox better than Walsh

You really don't think before you post, do you?

 

[Robertio]

There was a certain team that finished below Carlton that played them twice, and won both games.

You really don't think before you post, do you?

Well that's two of us buddy because you definitely have no clue do you?

 

[Arr0w]

I can't believe how many smooth brainers are in here mate.

Can't believe they want to continue to play the poster, but get salty when you return serve

 

[South of the Yarra]

Give yourself a pat on the back and you get yourself to somewhere where you can learn how the AFL system works.

Thank you for admitting Collingwood is the greatest club in the history of football and Collingwood is greater than Carlton. Appreciate it.

 

[Arr0w]

Thank you for admitting Collingwood is the greatest club in the history of football and Collingwood is greater than Carlton. Appreciate it.

Where was that written?

 

[Fadge]

Where was that written?

Since when does anything need to actually be written for other posters to miscomprehend, lie and/or gaslight by saying it has been written?

I mean, that's the way Carlton posters operate.

 

[South of the Yarra]

Where was that written?

Well you keep telling us Carlton is better than Collingwood last season as you finished higher on the ladder. Collingwood have finished higher on the ladder than Carlton significantly more times so every time you raise this you are simply acknowledging Collingwood as the greatest club ever. Thank you

 

[Arr0w]

Since when does anything need to actually be written for other posters to miscomprehend, lie and/or gaslight by saying it has been written?

I mean, that's the way Carlton posters operate.

Ironic, given your posting history and even here with another deflection to play the poster

You really do struggle

 

[Arr0w]

Well you keep telling us Carlton is better than Collingwood last season as you finished higher on the ladder. Collingwood have finished higher on the ladder than Carlton significantly more times so every time you raise this you are simply acknowledging Collingwood as the greatest club ever. Thank you

Yeah, nah

Pies haven't been relevant since the Beatles

 

[South of the Yarra]

Yeah, nah

Pies haven't been relevant since the Beatles

No your metrics. The team that finishes higher is better. Thank you for admitting Collingwood are better than Carlton. Twist it anyway you like, Collingwood are the greatest.,

 

[Arr0w]

No your metrics. The team that finishes higher is better. Thank you for admitting Collingwood are better than Carlton. Twist it anyway you like, Collingwood are the greatest.,

If that makes you feel better SOY, embrace it

I couldn't give a stuff about finishing positions, we are both on 16 flags and now in 2025

If you and any other Pie supporter want to reference the past, others will likely entertain it

Hopefully, without questioning someone's level of intelligence, especially if they have a delusional posting history (not directed at you of course)

 

[caloschwaby]

If you and any other Pie supporter want to reference the past, others will likely entertain it

All you guys talk about is the past it is all you have

 

[Fadge]

All you guys talk about is the past it is all you have

Pre 21st Century.

'The Halcyon Days'

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Not sure any Collingwood supporter has disputed the fact we had a poor year by our high standards.

It is a shame those high standards didn't extend to failing to win Grand Finals less often than 64 of the last 66 seasons.

 

[Arr0w]

All you guys talk about is the past it is all you have

Anything prior to this year is the past, yeah?

 

[JustaBattler]

It is a shame those high standards didn't extend to failing to win Grand Finals less often than 64 of the last 66 seasons.

A benchmark so low that it cant help but be met and even then needing the obvious help of umpires ...

 

[doppleganger]

Who thinks Carlton were the 2nd best team?

?? Who wrote that?

Your logic seems to be that Port were the 2nd best team because they finished 2nd on the H&A ladder.

The reality is Port got a soft H&A fixture that enabled them to finish 2nd on the H&A ladder. They were then shown up in finals by a "weaker" team.

Unlike the 1960s, the H&A ladder doesn't effectively rank who is better anymore as teams have different fixtures.

 

[kreuze_missile]

Cox better than Walsh

Dean? Maybe.

Mason is a poor man’s Robbie Warnock

 

[caloschwaby]

Anything prior to this year is the past, yeah?

Give up on this semantic pursuit lmao, the last 25 years could be considered "the present" and you still couldn't fit in the last time the Carlton Football Club was relevant

 

[Arr0w]

"There they go again, blaming the draw"

 

[Arr0w]

Give up on this semantic pursuit lmao, the last 25 years could be considered "the present" and you still couldn't fit in the last time the Carlton Football Club was relevant

That's the great thing about history we can all pick a timeline to the "past"

 

[caloschwaby]

That's the great thing about history we can all pick a timeline to the "past"

Ah yes that amazing 15-year timeline where Carlton wasn't a poverty franchise

 

[Arr0w]

Ah yes that amazing 15-year timeline where Carlton wasn't a poverty franchise

15 years? Not sure what you are referencing