Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Collingwood

    Votes: 110 51.4%
  • Carlton

    Votes: 104 48.6%

  • Total voters
    214

Remove this Banner Ad

17 Clubs that didnt win all lost to the winning Club. That is equality by definition 17 non winners.

True - well done finally you get it. Show me your workings if you want to disagree and no I amm not interested in yoru erpsonal biased ruminations and shouting at clouds.
doppleganger - it didn't take long...
 
Carlton president getting his wang out on twitter.

Collingwood’s best player has cooked feet.

Looks like we’re both having a great start to 2025 :$

"Daicos watched on during a physical session that was highlighted by a bit of a push and shove between Dan McStay and Tom Jiath"

Nick Daycare taking his well known aversion to the physical side of the game to new and unprecedented lengths I see.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

"Daicos watched on during a physical session that was highlighted by a bit of a push and shove between Dan McStay and Tom Jiath"

Nick Daycare taking his well known aversion to the physical side of the game to new and unprecedented lengths I see.

He should be resting on the couch wearing really warm socks, not hanging around training, don't these guys know anything...

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Did you know that pussy Dustin Martin played in ZERO wins in his final year? Daics would never be as soft as that View attachment 2201684

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
I remember Dusty used to get tagged a lot. His response was dragging his opponents down to the forward line to single handedly embarrass them and force their coach to change the match up.

When Nicky Daycare gets tagged he cries to the umps and runs down to the backline to get some cheap kick ins and play a bit of kick to kick to get away from the physical attention.

The two are not made of the same stuff.
 
I remember Dusty used to get tagged a lot. His response was dragging his opponents down to the forward line to single handedly embarrass them and force their coach to change the match up.

When Nicky Daycare gets tagged he cries to the umps and runs down to the backline to get some cheap kick ins and play a bit of kick to kick to get away from the physical attention.

The two are not made of the same stuff.
Daics owns the Blues

In fact we all do Screenshot_20250111-133906_Chrome.jpg

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
I remember Dusty used to get tagged a lot. His response was dragging his opponents down to the forward line to single handedly embarrass them and force their coach to change the match up.

When Nicky Daycare gets tagged he cries to the umps and runs down to the backline to get some cheap kick ins and play a bit of kick to kick to get away from the physical attention.

The two are not made of the same stuff.
Much easier toargets to point the finger at as far as Collingwod players go though isnt there- starting with their (cough) Captain. I like Naicos one of the most exciting players to hit the scene in a long time, in good company with Sheezel and the 'little bloke' over at WA the Darcy bloke at the doggies, the freakish wizard kid at the Hawfs...- all different stengths impacting differently - looking forward to seeing how quickly Smith can adapt to AFL and in a year or two Walker jnr....TDK/Smith/Walsh/Walker ....future is so bright i got to wear shades :cool:
 
When was the last time you beat us in a grand final again? Anyone still alive from back then?
Present tense, we own the Blues

Aren't you embarrassed referencing events from over 40 years ago as a burn?

You should be sparring with the likes of the Saints and Dockers, bottom 4
Screenshot_20250111-115534_Chrome.jpg

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Present tense, we own the Blues

Aren't you embarrassed referencing events from over 40 years ago as a burn?

You should be sparring with the likes of the Saints and Dockers, bottom 4
View attachment 2201713

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app


Years since 3rd most recent Grand Final victory:

8 Richhistorymond
12 Hawthorn
16 Geelong
23 Brisbane
31 Eagles
40 Essendon
43 Carlton
50 North Melbourne
65 Melbourne
67 Collingwood
92 Sydney
103 Fitzroy

Congratulations Collingwood, you are above South Melbourne & Fitzroy on this list. 😍
 
Years since 3rd most recent Grand Final victory:

8 Richhistorymond
12 Hawthorn
16 Geelong
23 Brisbane
31 Eagles
40 Essendon
43 Carlton
50 North Melbourne
65 Melbourne
67 Collingwood
92 Sydney
103 Fitzroy

Congratulations Collingwood, you are above South Melbourne & Fitzroy on this list. 😍
Nice.

Can you now do that for the 14th most recent Grand Final win?
 
Years since 3rd most recent Grand Final victory:

8 Richhistorymond
12 Hawthorn
16 Geelong
23 Brisbane
31 Eagles
40 Essendon
43 Carlton
50 North Melbourne
65 Melbourne
67 Collingwood
92 Sydney
103 Fitzroy

Congratulations Collingwood, you are above South Melbourne & Fitzroy on this list.
Years since 3rd most recent premiership:

8 Tankmond
12 Hawthorn
16 Geelong
23 Brisbane
31 Eagles
35 Collingwood
40 Essendon
43 Carlton
48 North Melbourne
65 Melbourne
92 Sydney
103 Fitzroy



On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Back
Top