Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[WalshistheGOAT]

so would i to be honest. But you guys would win the flag

I disagree, think the Pies would be more chance of winning the flag with Cripps than us with Daicos. Either way, purely for the heart and soul element you couldn't trade Cripps for anyone without mass outrage.

 

[HeathySure]

I disagree, think the Pies would be more chance of winning the flag with Cripps than us with Daicos. Either way, purely for the heart and soul element you couldn't trade Cripps for anyone without mass outrage.

lol Naicos is the most damaging player in the league. We dont win in 2023 without him. Cripps is a nice plodder who kicks a few goals here and there, but there are 10 replicas of him out there, There is only 1 Naicos

 

[carlton_99]

lol Naicos is the most damaging player in the league. We dont win in 2023 without him. Cripps is a nice plodder who kicks a few goals here and there, but there are 10 replicas of him out there, There is only 1 Naicos

It was such a nice conversation and then you had to go Collingwood it up

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

lol Naicos is the most damaging player in the league. We dont win in 2023 without him. Cripps is a nice plodder who kicks a few goals here and there, but there are 10 replicas of him out there, There is only 1 Naicos

Only one player came top 2 or won the Brownlow, Coaches Award and AFLPA MVP in 2024. And funnily enough it wasn't seagull boy.

But in case you've forgotten...


10 replicas my ass

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Think we can all agree it wouldn't be a popular trade, sickening for both sets of supporters

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[HeathySure]

Only one player came top 2 or won the Brownlow, Coaches Award and AFLPA MVP in 2024. And funnily enough it wasn't seagull boy.

But in case you've forgotten...


10 replicas my ass

He has played 12 years and won 2 finals lol

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

He has played 12 years and won 2 finals lol

And 2 Brownlows.

Just because he was drafted to a rabble doesn't mean he isn't a great player.

 

[HeathySure]

And 2 Brownlows.

Just because he was drafted to a rabble doesn't mean he isn't a great player.

Yeah he is obviously a good player, but he is not destructive. I would rather have 10 current midfielders in my side rather than Cripps though, he is not a matchwinner

 

[Fadge]

He has played 12 years and won 2 finals lol

Are there any other Carlton players this century who have won more finals?

 

[Arr0w]

Are there any Collingwood players to have won 3 flags since WWII?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Yeah he is obviously a good player, but he is not destructive. I would rather have 10 current midfielders in my side rather than Cripps though, he is not a matchwinner

Name them

 

[Worm4]

Yeah he is obviously a good player, but he is not destructive. I would rather have 10 current midfielders in my side rather than Cripps though, he is not a matchwinner

Name and shame
By this, I mean name the lucrative 10, then hang your head , in shame

 

[HeathySure]

Name them

Butters, Serong, Horne Dog, Heeney, Warner, Ashcroft the older, Zerrett, Petracca if recovered, Josh Kelly who should be on the ball not the wing, and a few young up and comers like Wardlaw, Harley Reid and Sheezel just off the top of my head

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Butters, Serong, Horne Dog, Heeney, Warner, Ashcroft the older, Zerrett, Petracca if recovered, Josh Kelly who should be on the ball not the wing, and a few young up and comers like Wardlaw, Harley Reid and Sheezel just off the top of my head

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

This may even be dumber than ol' mate Cox>Walsh

 

[Worm4]

This may even be dumber than ol' mate Cox>Walsh

Let's see if any of his mates try and rescue this shipwreck

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Let's see if any of his mates try and rescue this shipwreck

Crippa s***stomping Nicky in the Brownlow has really broken their hearts.

 

[Lockyer24]

Crippa s***stomping Nicky in the Brownlow has really broken their hearts.

Congrats on joining Woewodin, Priddis and Wines in that illustrious club.

Lou’s Handball in a more prestigious award after the embarrassment that Brownlow night has thrown up the last few years.

The umpires don’t even hide that it is a betting rort for their friends and family anymore.

https://www.theroar.com.au/2022/11/15/umpire-at-centre-of-brownlow-betting-scandal-revealed-as-afl-investigation-continues/amp/

Record votes for bog standard seasons (Wines/Cripps), 3 votes in 10 goal losses (hello Juddy), 3 votes for 10 touches and 2 farts (Neale), forwards and defenders getting nothing (I suppose it makes it harder to rort if there is too much of a pool to give votes to) .

Your brown paper bag flags had more merit than the Brownlow.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Congrats on joining Woewodin, Priddis and Wines in that illustrious club.

Lou’s Handball in a more prestigious award after the embarrassment that Brownlow night has thrown up the last few years.

The umpires don’t even hide that it is a betting rort for their friends and family anymore.

https://www.theroar.com.au/2022/11/15/umpire-at-centre-of-brownlow-betting-scandal-revealed-as-afl-investigation-continues/amp/

Record votes for bog standard seasons (Wines/Cripps), 3 votes in 10 goal losses (hello Juddy), 3 votes for 10 touches and 2 farts (Neale), forwards and defenders getting nothing (I suppose it makes it harder to rort if there is too much of a pool to give votes to) .

Your brown paper bag flags had more merit than the Brownlow.

And yet theres been mass meltdowns from the Pies faithful the last 2 years when poor little Squibby came runners up.

I wonder why?

 

[carlton_99]

Congrats on joining Woewodin, Priddis and Wines in that illustrious club.

Lou’s Handball in a more prestigious award after the embarrassment that Brownlow night has thrown up the last few years.

The umpires don’t even hide that it is a betting rort for their friends and family anymore.

https://www.theroar.com.au/2022/11/15/umpire-at-centre-of-brownlow-betting-scandal-revealed-as-afl-investigation-continues/amp/

Record votes for bog standard seasons (Wines/Cripps), 3 votes in 10 goal losses (hello Juddy), 3 votes for 10 touches and 2 farts (Neale), forwards and defenders getting nothing (I suppose it makes it harder to rort if there is too much of a pool to give votes to) .

Your brown paper bag flags had more merit than the Brownlow.

Yep Cripps had a "BOG standard season" - this thread continues to amaze

 

[Kenny Hunter09]

Butters, Serong, Horne Dog, Heeney, Warner, Ashcroft the older, Zerrett, Petracca if recovered, Josh Kelly who should be on the ball not the wing, and a few young up and comers like Wardlaw, Harley Reid and Sheezel just off the top of my head

Google Search

 

[Worm4]

Butters, Serong, Horne Dog, Heeney, Warner, Ashcroft the older, Zerrett, Petracca if recovered, Josh Kelly who should be on the ball not the wing, and a few young up and comers like Wardlaw, Harley Reid and Sheezel just off the top of my head

Just for the sake of discussion, on what basis are you having Zac Merrett in your team ahead of Cripps ?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Just for the sake of discussion, on what basis are you having Zac Merrett in your team ahead of Cripps ?

The only basis is trolling

 

[JustaBattler]

Congrats on joining Woewodin, Priddis and Wines in that illustrious club.

Lou’s Handball in a more prestigious award after the embarrassment that Brownlow night has thrown up the last few years.

The umpires don’t even hide that it is a betting rort for their friends and family anymore.

https://www.theroar.com.au/2022/11/15/umpire-at-centre-of-brownlow-betting-scandal-revealed-as-afl-investigation-continues/amp/

Record votes for bog standard seasons (Wines/Cripps), 3 votes in 10 goal losses (hello Juddy), 3 votes for 10 touches and 2 farts (Neale), forwards and defenders getting nothing (I suppose it makes it harder to rort if there is too much of a pool to give votes to) .

Your brown paper bag flags had more merit than the Brownlow.

You should consider being a guest writer for the roar and then you could quote yourself and make it two peanuts in a soggy bag of of tearful whining.

 

[jezzajay]

Congrats on joining Woewodin, Priddis and Wines in that illustrious club.

Lou’s Handball in a more prestigious award after the embarrassment that Brownlow night has thrown up the last few years.

The umpires don’t even hide that it is a betting rort for their friends and family anymore.

https://www.theroar.com.au/2022/11/15/umpire-at-centre-of-brownlow-betting-scandal-revealed-as-afl-investigation-continues/amp/

Record votes for bog standard seasons (Wines/Cripps), 3 votes in 10 goal losses (hello Juddy), 3 votes for 10 touches and 2 farts (Neale), forwards and defenders getting nothing (I suppose it makes it harder to rort if there is too much of a pool to give votes to) .

Your brown paper bag flags had more merit than the Brownlow.

yep...salty much