No1DraftPick said:[/b]Ever heard of Mark Bolton
No...no, can't say I have. Is he a footballer of some kind?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
who would west coast trade for Judd
- Thread starter cousins_hodge
- Start date
- Tagged users None
No...no, can't say I have. Is he a footballer of some kind?
No1DraftPick
Draftee
Lukazzz777
All Australian
Chris Judd is the best player we will all ever see.
He is worth the top three players at any club unfortunately and noone would give that up.
For the Hawks it would be Mitchell, Hodge and Franklin
For Sydney Hall, Goodes and Kirk
For Demons
Johnston, McLean and Robertson
etc, etc.
he is untradeable and will stay at the Eagles.
He is worth the top three players at any club unfortunately and noone would give that up.
For the Hawks it would be Mitchell, Hodge and Franklin
For Sydney Hall, Goodes and Kirk
For Demons
Johnston, McLean and Robertson
etc, etc.
he is untradeable and will stay at the Eagles.
Lukazzz777 said:
Now I'm not denying that Judd is a freak and will go down as one of the All-Time Greats, but he's not perfect. He CAN be tagged out of a game, he CAN be frustrated, and he does make a few mistakes.
In 9 games this year he had 23 disposals or less, so its not like he tears apart every game he's involved in, and I have seen him make a fair few dodgy errors (yes, I know, who doesn't). The point I'm trying to make is, he isn't anywhere near the worth of Hall/Goodes/O'Keefe, Hayes/Koschitzke/Riewoldt, Pavlich/Ball/McPharlin etc... Individually he is by far the best midfielder in the competition, but he isn't the best player of all time (yet). Sure, he is a freak, but not a legend.
B: S.Fisher, Hudghton, L.Fisher
HB: Gram, Maguire, Goddard
C: Baker, Hayes, Montagna
HF: Harvey, Riewoldt, X.Clarke
F: Brooks, Gehrig, Milne
Foll: Koschitzke, Ball, Dal Santo
Int: Ackland, Hamill, McQualter, Voss
Is far better than:
B: S.Fisher, Hudghton, L.Fisher
HB: Gram, Maguire, Goddard
C: Dal Santo, Judd, Montagna
HF: Harvey, Watts, X.Clarke
F: Brooks, Gehrig, Milne
Foll: Ackland, Ball, Dal Santo
Int: Baker, Rix, Hamill, Voss
mad-saint-guy said:
That is true, but WC still wouldn't give him up for any less.
mad-saint-guy said:
only because dal santo would be so tired from playing on the wing and as a rover [sorry for being pedantic]
yes kossi/Riewoldt/hayes are worth more than judd ... well when they are all fit anyway
romanwfw
Club Legend
if judd wasn't a class act, which he is, he would opt for the pre-season draft at the end of 2007 and any victorian club w/o a reasonable chance to make the 8 from round 13 onwards would immediately tank every game in the the hope they get the wooden spoon
sydney eagle
Norm Smith Medallist
Gee usually these threads wait a little longer before being created (along with the "Judd is going to Collingwood in 2007" thread). Why don't you go onto the Eagles official site and post your question to the "Ask Woosha" section? You should get a definitive answer that way !
THE ENTIRE SYDNEY SIDE, FOR STARTERS!
you are kidding right, he is not even on the trading radar. The "coming home to Melbourne" rumours have been around for years.
He's a good ex-Caulfield Grammar boy and every year when he comes back over he continually denies his desire to " come home". He is well and truly cemented at the Weagles!
IMO, he will play 300-plus at the Wet Toast and will be a true champion of their club. They may even name Subi Oval after him, he's that good!
you are kidding right, he is not even on the trading radar. The "coming home to Melbourne" rumours have been around for years.
He's a good ex-Caulfield Grammar boy and every year when he comes back over he continually denies his desire to " come home". He is well and truly cemented at the Weagles!
IMO, he will play 300-plus at the Wet Toast and will be a true champion of their club. They may even name Subi Oval after him, he's that good!
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
The day someone like Chris Judd is traded is the day when the AFL takes a step towards having soccer like player transfers.
onlyhandball
Senior List
Lampard, Ballack, Schevchenko, Drogba and Terry for Judd.
What do you think?
What do you think?
Imagine if Judd had a fallout with wc like Aker did with Bris.And he went into the psd for nothing!! How p****d would the eagles be??
onlyhandball
Senior List
DOG GOD said:
Imagine your house was made out of chocolate.
worthy
Cancelled
Can we please have a school kids board?
or
A provisional board where new posters have to earn the right to post on the main board.
or
A provisional board where new posters have to earn the right to post on the main board.
onlyhandball
Senior List
worthy said:
What do you have to do to prove yourself?
worthy
Cancelled
onlyhandball said:
Post new and interesting threads/posts.
Player comparisons and silly trade questions/proposals are a strike against.
Spelling and Grammar not an issue as long as it can be deciphered.
hkfootyfan
Debutant
cousins_hodge said:
Clown
except = exclude or do you mean ACCEPT?
ill give wce a years supply of hungry jacks!
no picks or players, just the creamy sloppy goodness of hungry smacks
no picks or players, just the creamy sloppy goodness of hungry smacks
This will be the thread of 2007
His contract expires end of 2007
he stays behind after every Melbourne game for a day or two
interesting times ahead.....
Being a bit self indulgent here........but look what i wrote last September...
indeed interesting times ahead
Daniel Wells plus their first round draft pick [maybe even another pick]
- Oct 6, 2006
- 7,802
- 471
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Chris Grant & Muhammed Ali
The two best players in the comp 
