Review Winners and losers - trade week 2024

Remove this Banner Ad

Richmond have walked into the casino and exchanged nearly all of their money for chips. It's 8pm and they will be high rolling until the sun rises. Will their strategies see them leaving better off than they came in with?

I get that they've just about made the best of a terrible situation and they got great returns on every player that left, but the decisions will not pay off (if at all) for a very long time.
Richmond have invested in an ETF tracking the NASDAQ. Overweight growth in a high-growth draft. Maybe we'll return worse than we expect, but we've invested in a strong portfolio that has a decent chance to pay off above market.
 
Little worried about Carlton moving up in the draft... do they have their eyes on Fin O'Sullivan OR Sid Draper. There will be meltdowns galore if they pick Draper at 3 ahead of the Crows.

1.*Brisbane: Ashcroft
2. Richmond: Smith
3. North Melb:?? (Do North pick best available or go for a need here?
4. Carlton: O'Sullivan/Draper
5. Adelaide: Draper/Smille/O'Sullivan
 
Winners: Matt Owies (somehow secured a three-year deal).

Losers: Rory Atkins (no matter where he ends up, no one seems to want him).
 

Log in to remove this ad.

How are suns losers?

Fixed our salary cap and probably the best its been ever trading out Atkins and lukocious.

Acquired 2 future first rd picks for next year

Acquired Noble and Rioli ( needed half-back flankers)

Banked enough points for a top 10 academy player in this draft
This
 
Richmond the obvious big winner despite the fact that they are in for years of pain they had no choice and got significant overs for departing players. 14 for Baker simply astounding.
West Coast could have gotten a lot more in the door so to me the biggest losers. They are not much further than Richmond in terms of rebuild but look at the difference in draft hands next 2 years, especially when Richmond live trade out their later first round early second round picks for futures.
 
Tigers traded out four of their most reliable, durable and best players. Three of their top 5 in their B&F are going to be playing against them next year. To expect they'll only be marginally worse in the short-term is very optimistic.
I understand what you are saying, but they finished wooden spooners and won two games.
Difficult times have already hit and those players were actively looking to greener pastures.
Rioli will be 28 next year, Baker 27. They have the majority of their careers in the rear view mirror. Bolton is great when he's switched on and in a good side, he's not putting a side on his back and giving grunt any time soon.
If it ends up a year-long stretch of belting after belting, that can leave a big mark, but it doesn't have to be that way and the point remains:
That was their starting configuration, and they traded incredibly well against that backdrop, plus it is apparently a year with a deep first round. Or they can stagger it.
It is obviously not ideal and you have to feel for Yze a bit, whether he will still be around when the rewards are reaped is iffy.
 
Shout-out to Hawthorn and Adelaide, too, fwiw.
Adelaide got in some handy players who are ready to go for a pretty modest outlay. Flew under my radar at least.
Hawthorn targeted some defensive help and got two blokes who are ready to go.
 
How many years now without a first round pick not sure your a winner Fly banking on this group to go for it again.
The trades will look OK if we win next year's premiership. Houston is a good pick up but our lack of young talls forward and back is a worry that the club has not seemed to keen on addressing. It's going to be a very boring draft for Collingwood supporters but an exciting one for the clubs with multiple picks in the top 30.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Micky son is not rd 1 selection mate shows promise.
The Collingwood faithful will howl you down on that particularly that our trading was conducting with not needing next year's first uppermost in mind. If he is not round one then we have made a mistake throwing away yet another first round pick.
 
Little worried about Carlton moving up in the draft... do they have their eyes on Fin O'Sullivan OR Sid Draper. There will be meltdowns galore if they pick Draper at 3 ahead of the Crows.

1.*Brisbane: Ashcroft
2. Richmond: Smith
3. North Melb:?? (Do North pick best available or go for a need here?
4. Carlton: O'Sullivan/Draper
5. Adelaide: Draper/Smille/O'Sullivan

Draper absolutely ticks all the boxes for the Blues 😎
And he would arrive with the twins which would be great in helping him settle in.
We do like dealing with young Reid though, maybe he might like to make us an offer to swap picks 3&4 … 😎
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Review Winners and losers - trade week 2024

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top