Orange crush
Norm Smith Medallist
- Aug 12, 2017
- 5,196
- 9,664
- AFL Club
- GWS
And then they complain we have too many 1st round picks ā¦. Beyond weirdThey gave us two firsts for Shiel
Trade Period 2023 - winners and losers
- Thread starter Gavin Excell
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Elmer_Hauser
Future Member of Parliament
They gave us two firsts for Shiel
We (Carlton) dodged a bullet with that
Can't brag much given we have also taken a lot of your discards over the years, although I am thrilled Caleb Marchbank has (touchwood) finally gotten over bloody unlucky run of injuries, he had a great finals series for us last year and hopefully will help hold the fort for us whilst Weitering is out.
Won't miss Plowman though, how the hell did he go #3 in his draft year? Jeez Louise
Orange crush
Norm Smith Medallist
- Aug 12, 2017
- 5,196
- 9,664
- AFL Club
- GWS
You guys got burned by SOS as well ā¦. Now itās St Kildas turnWe (Carlton) dodged a bullet with that
Can't brag much given we have also taken a lot of your discards over the years, although I am thrilled Caleb Marchbank has (touchwood) finally gotten over bloody unlucky run of injuries, he had a great finals series for us last year and hopefully will help hold the fort for us whilst Weitering is out.
Won't miss Plowman though, how the hell did he go #3 in his draft year? Jeez Louise
Elmer_Hauser
Future Member of Parliament
Least he got the 2015 draft right (Charlie, Harry and Weitering) but you are right, he kinda sucked and is overated.
They gave us two firsts for Shiel
Good for you mate. It must feel good to get one over another club for a change, after getting fleeced for several of your good players
- Jan 17, 2013
- 8,159
- 9,511
- AFL Club
- GWS
Only good one who we lost and wanted to keep was Cameron.
The sub-par ones, like Shiel, Smith, Stewart and Caldwellā¦ enough said.
Not to mention guys like Edwards and Aylett.
Fair enough. Most normal clubs would be pretty gutted losing guys like Taranto and a few others too, but I guess you just replaced him easily with Tom Green via the academy.
I agree with your assessment of several of those players too. And when you look at the original draft pick spent on them by GWS you have to scratch your head. You can add Setterfield at pick 5 and Hoskin-Elliott at 4 too
SOS got a second rounder out of GWS to move up one spot in the draft for a player we apparently didnāt want.
Effectively means we got Liam Henry for nada.
Fair play by him.
Shiel and a 2ndThey gave us two firsts for Shiel
the long history of that deal
'18
Shiel and Bryan (via WCE/Geel trade)
for Bonar ('18) and Caldwell ('19)
'20
Caldwell, 44 and 74 for Fantasia pick and '21 2nd
'21 2nd was handed to Geel with Cameron (James Willis?)
Lost: Bonar, Fantasia & Willis
For: Shiel, Bryan & Caldwell
Last edited:
eth-dog
Tier 1 WW Player
Sigh. How many times do I need to remind everyone that Mozzie wasn't part of the Shiel deal?Shiel and a 2nd
the long history of that deal
'18
Shiel and Mosquito (gave us the fist pump meme)
for Bonar ('18) and Caldwell ('19)
'20
Caldwell, 44 and 74 for Fantasia pick and '21 2nd
'21 2nd was handed to Geel with Cameron (James Willis?)
Lost: Bonar, Fantasia & Willis
For: Shiel & Caldwell
Last edited:
gruff. the smith deal trips me up every time
it's Bryan via WCE/Geel trade
I'm no fan of him, but the positive for Stkilda is that we are toward the end of the rebuild and not the start. SOS did very well for us this time around and it does look like the club has put in measures to curb his negative aspects. Time will tell.
cryptor
Brownlow Medallist
- May 11, 2008
- 25,144
- 66,575
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
After half a season (12 games) players have settled into their new clubs, and I'm pretty stoked with how Hawthorn have done.
Outgoing Players
Tyler Brockman - 6 games, 0 goals, and unfortunately now dealing with some off field troubles. Still has high potential.
Jacob Koschitzke - 3 games, 1 goal, struggling in the VFL. Bust for Tigers.
Brandon Ryan - 1 game, 1 goal, looking like VFL could be his level (26yo and still very skinny).
Incoming Players
Mabior Chol - 10 games, 14 goals, really impressed by his defensive efforts for a big forward. Big upgrade on Kosi and Ryan.
Jack Ginnivan - 12 games, 14 goals, getting up the ground and putting up a lot of career high numbers. If Brockman was still with us and playing like this we'd be thrilled.
Massmio D'Ambrosio - 11 games, was rated #1 winger in the comp by CD earlier in the year and has been consistent since. Freakishly good kick and his alleged defensive weakness is non-existent.
Jack Gunston - 8 games, 11 goals, his influence in fast-tracking Calsher Dear's development would make this trade a win regardless of his on field input which has been solid.
D+
Outgoing Players
Tyler Brockman - 6 games, 0 goals, and unfortunately now dealing with some off field troubles. Still has high potential.
Jacob Koschitzke - 3 games, 1 goal, struggling in the VFL. Bust for Tigers.
Brandon Ryan - 1 game, 1 goal, looking like VFL could be his level (26yo and still very skinny).
Incoming Players
Mabior Chol - 10 games, 14 goals, really impressed by his defensive efforts for a big forward. Big upgrade on Kosi and Ryan.
Jack Ginnivan - 12 games, 14 goals, getting up the ground and putting up a lot of career high numbers. If Brockman was still with us and playing like this we'd be thrilled.
Massmio D'Ambrosio - 11 games, was rated #1 winger in the comp by CD earlier in the year and has been consistent since. Freakishly good kick and his alleged defensive weakness is non-existent.
Jack Gunston - 8 games, 11 goals, his influence in fast-tracking Calsher Dear's development would make this trade a win regardless of his on field input which has been solid.
D+
