Your clubs 8 untouchable players

[Juddbemetron]

After the recent news hawthorn said only 8 players were safe from trade week

What would your clubs 8 untouchables be

i already started this thread but its name is not good

so ill copy come of the respones

My top 8 is

Judd
Fevola
Stevens
Murphy
Gibbs
Kreuzer
Warnock (now that he is there)
Waite

Henry Yoghurts top 8 is
Brent Harvey
Drew Petrie
Michael Firrito
Daniel Pratt
David Hale
Daniel Wells
Adam Simpson
Brady Rawlings

and numbat06 top 8 is
cox
lynch
a selwood
masten
ebert
mckinley
kerr
glass

please add your top 8 for your club

 

[Judd2Sewell]

Hodge
Franklin
Croad
Roughead
Mitchell
Sewell
Bateman
Brown

I think that'd probably be it. Maybe Renouf/Ellis in a season or two.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Take out Stevens and put in Jamison and Bower. Not sure who else to take out ... probably Warnock.

 

[DidaksLeftFoot]

Thomas
Pendlebury
Maxwell
Medhurst
Clarke
Davis
H. Shaw
Didak

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Scarlett
Mooney
Ottens
Ablett
Bartel
S.Johnson
Chapman
Selwood

Corey and Ling a little bit stiff but we'd have no forward line without Mooney and SJ and no ruck without Ottens and Selwood is the future.

 

[Warwick]

Brown
Merrett
Black
Clark
Patfull
Power
Henderson
Adcock

In roughly that order.

 

[Juddbemetron]

Take out Stevens and put in Jamison and Bower. Not sure who else to take out ... probably Warnock.

i put stevens in there is he is our vice captain so is obviously rated highly
and also had many great qauters when we cameback fomo the dead
4th in brownlow as well
but i am too a huge fan of bower and jamison
but there was a lot of talk bower would be the sweetner in the warnock deal

 

[Falchoon]

no such thing

offer Pavlich and Warnock for Riewoldt and deal is done, outside of that


1 Riewoldt
2 Goddard
3 Fisher
4 Ball
5 Hayes
6 McEvoy
7 Dal Santo
8 Koschitzke

The last 2 can be scoffed at but we're never going to get perceived value.

 

[The Cotch]

Thursfield
Deledio
Riewoldt
Cotchin
Rance
Morton
Foley
Edwards

 

[Juddbemetron]

Hodge
Franklin
Croad
Roughead
Mitchell
Sewell
Bateman
Brown

I think that'd probably be it. Maybe Renouf/Ellis in a season or two.

no rioli

 

[RUNVS]

In no particular order

1. Craig Bolton
2. Adam Goodes
3. Jarrad McVeigh
4. Patrick Veszpremi
5. Craig Bird
6. Kieren Jack
7. Jarred Moore
8. Paul Bevan

It may be a slightly odd list but most of those guys are young and will be very important for the Swans over the next decade.

 

[Juddbemetron]

Thomas
Pendlebury
Maxwell
Medhurst
Clarke
Davis
H. Shaw
Didak

why no swan
leading brownlow vote getter at collingwood
but agree on no vice captain fraser

 

[Juddbemetron]

Brown
Merrett
Black
Clark
Patfull
Power
Henderson
Adcock

In roughly that order.

why do love for bradshaw

 

[Juddbemetron]

In no particular order

1. Craig Bolton
2. Adam Goodes
3. Jarrad McVeigh
4. Patrick Veszpremi
5. Craig Bird
6. Kieren Jack
7. Jarred Moore
8. Paul Bevan

It may be a slightly odd list but most of those guys are young and will be very important for the Swans over the next decade.

no kirk
and just coz okeef doesn't want ot be there doesnt mean he shouldnt be untouchable

 

[Judd2Sewell]

no rioli

He can go in the Ellis/Renouf catagory, in a year or two he would be.

But now, those eight players I've mentioned you can build a super team around.

 

[SaintsPremiers08]

1. Nick Riewoldt
2. Brendon Goddard
3. Sam Fisher
4. David Armitage
5. Luke Ball
6. Lenny Hayes
7. Jason Gram
8. Sam Gilbert

 

[that_dood]

van Berlo
Poplyzia
Bock
Rutten
Mackay
Maric
S.Thompson
Vince

 

[Juddbemetron]

no such thing

offer Pavlich and Warnock for Riewoldt and deal is done, outside of that


1 Riewoldt
2 Goddard
3 Fisher
4 Ball
5 Hayes
6 McEvoy
7 Dal Santo
8 Koschitzke

The last 2 can be scoffed at but we're never going to get perceived value.

1. Nick Riewoldt
2. Brendon Goddard
3. Sam Fisher
4. David Armitage
5. Luke Ball
6. Lenny Hayes
7. Jason Gram
8. Sam Gilbert

surely hudgeton and milne can be in there over players like mcevoy and armitage and gilbert

 

[RUNVS]

no kirk
and just coz okeef doesn't want ot be there doesnt mean he shouldnt be untouchable

Kirk nearly made my list but he is 31 which traditionally is nearing the end of a footballers career (though Kirk is the type of player who could go on for another 5 years and if there is a chance of that i would add him to my list).

As for O'Keefe he doesnt want to be at the club which means i dont want him at the club.

 

[Juddbemetron]

van Berlo
Poplyzia
Bock
Rutten
Mackay
Maric
S.Thompson
Vince

are you saying your captain in goodwin would be up for trade

 

[that_dood]

are you saying your captain in goodwin would be up for trade

He will retire next year. No one would pick him up anyway. The players mentioned still have lengthy careers. No one would touch Goodwin, McLeod, Edwards, etc. at their age.

 

[NTRabbit]

are you saying your captain in goodwin would be up for trade

He's saying, and I agree with him, that Goodwin, Edwards, McLeod and Burton are all untouchable because no one would want to actively recruit a group of 31-33 year olds, and as career one club players they would never be interested in leaving anyway.

 

[edgehead47]

Palmer
Sandilands
Pavlich
McPharlin
Ibbotson
Mayne
Hayden...only 7, Warnock was the 8th

 

[Tonche]

McVeigh
Hille
Ryder
Gumbleton
Reimers
Houli
Watson
Lonergan

 

[SaintsPremiers08]

surely hudgeton and milne can be in there over players like mcevoy and armitage and gilbert

Ok. Hudghton should be in there but the reason I put Armo/Gilbert in there is because they are both young and starting to come of age.

They will all be guns.