The rabbi
Brownlow Medallist
- May 13, 2007
- 12,916
- 15,945
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- St.Albans (Geelong Football League)
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
He is not that great. I would take him but only very lateDoes anyone know how Wooller played through the U18 Champs?
I can only see that he kicked 1 goal in the WA vs VM game, but was not in the Best.
He is not mentioned in any other VM games; Was he exposed at that grade level? Was he injured? Or not selected for other VM games?
What aspect of his game is his weakness?He is not that great. I would take him but only very late
His height for a start. Man child. Doesnt seem to be mobile enough to be a shorter tall.What aspect of his game is his weakness?
Does anyone know how Wooller played through the U18 Champs?
I can only see that he kicked 1 goal in the WA vs VM game, but was not in the Best.
He is not mentioned in any other VM games; Was he exposed at that grade level? Was he injured? Or not selected for other VM games?
His height for a start. Man child. Doesnt seem to be mobile enough to be a shorter tall.
Its not that i dont like him. Its more that he should be a late pick if not rookie
Is he a ruckman who can spend some time forward? Could he play as a key forward?Hayes is outstanding, relatively in this draft, for his position as #1 Ruck and ability to go forward.
Would be stunned if he fell below 10.
yesIs he a ruckman who can spend some time forward? Could he play as a key forward?
He is never going to be a midfielder at AFL and his chance at making it as a key forward are low due to his height and he has ok speed but not enough to cause issues.You may have seen more of him than me .. but when I watched he did play like a Hawkins type which was a baby hewy type situation.. he leadup to the ball ..when he played around the ball maybe then he was the big body ?
Scotch oh know I was very keen on him but not a Scotch boy. Off to the Hawks for himGarner was a Scotch College student iirc. Played for Eastern Ranges. You are of course joking about the Joey's uniform- sorry, I jumped.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/...e/news-story/f7ff591114ce547e1239541f8c8ec931
He is never going to be a midfielder at AFL and his chance at making it as a key forward are low due to his height and he has ok speed but not enough to cause issues.
If he makes it, it will be as a smaller lead up forward who provides the link between the defebce and attack.. even then.. most of the better lead up forwards are partly midfielders -Okeefe, lynch and even duncan in his draft year.
I'm happy to take him but only late in the draft. He is a much better player than mccartin at the moment but mccartin does have some very developable traits as well. The hit rates are very low with key forwards late anyway.
Much easier to find small backman, ruckman, key backman and small fwds later in the draft
yes
yes
we won't get him
beware Tigers etc- they have picks before us and will get what they want
19 may haveAll it really takes is a slider though say wb bod on naish 17 is gone and brander slides they take him at 20 then hayes is at 22.
Twomey is saying top 10 for hayes is unlikely now.
I’d be very happy if we got Garner, Miers, Wooller and Worpel. And agree on hayball I don’t understand why we’d re rookie him he hasn’t shown anythingGarner has good athleticism and an elite kick
Will probably play his best footy as an outside midfielder/half back.
A tremendous leader on and off the pitch too as he captained the Vic Metro Side
Reckon he may fall to #22 and we should definitely take him.
Matt Ling for me will be another Jordan Murdoch. He drifts in and out of games too often and will need time in the gym. I don't see the hype in him IMO. Lachlan Fogarty, although he has a great character & is a good guy (which the club likes aka GHS) is a party animal. My cousin has gone clubbing with him multiple times as they are graduating from the same school together. Lachlan obviously still wants to have a regular late teens party life but he can't allow this to impact his footy in any way.
As for #24 and #35 - It has to be Gryan Miers and Toby Wooller. Both fills big needs for our club and both are good enough for the big time.
I'd consider Worpel at #58 maybe. Reckon he will continue to slide. Seems unlikely but we all remember Jonty Scharenberg and Sam Walker from last year who were nailed as late second rounders and weren't chosen by anyone in the ND/Rookie Drafts. Worpel is a contested beast but his kick does let him down. He does love to break away from packs though which is good.
As for mature agers. Tom Atkins I would love. I think he could seriously make it in Afl. Tackling machine, good disposal and an eye for Goal. Stuff Hayball as a rookie, this guy is much better.
I’d be very happy if we got Garner, Miers, Wooller and Worpel. And agree on hayball I don’t understand why we’d re rookie him he hasn’t shown anything
The change has been that most of the talls taken late that have some success have been late to the game or from other sports. Examples tippett, lobb, goldstein, jenkins. I think thats what we have tried to emulate with rat and buzza and have tried to find someone with a point of difference to increase the likelyhood of making it.Enjoy your work. I like informative opinions and your are usually good and worth reading..
Id like more info before I was definitive about not making as a mid .. Ling was a small forward who made it as a mid.. so Id not say never.. , not without seeing his combine data. Any idea on the yoyo and 2K ?
As I said I have only seen small amounts of him and I liked what I saw at that time.. he lead at the ball well..not all players are comfortable doing that, he was good below his knees and had good hands. McCartin is so young he would have more development in him.. but id not complain if we took either with 35 or later. Your point on Key forward later in draft is historically true.. but I wonder if that is heading towards a change. The game at the TAC level is not quite the same , one almost has to look at players with adaptable games even if they did not standout in their year. Our picks are what they are.. and Id certainly like to have a single figure pick but even then I doubt the quality of forward are as quite as good as they will be next year. As usual however we will not get to them if our season goes as planned.
19 may have
I'd be thrilled if we got him at 22- is it possible?
No one drafted Dalhaus ..he made it the Rookie draftedThe more I think about it, I think Wellsy really wanted to draft Dalhaus late and missed him; and I think he won't make the same mistake with Miers.