Your ideal finals scenario

[Papa Juggs]

Why do Collingwood supporters think their team is better than ours??

We beat you with Riewoldt out for a half then we beat the Bulldogs and Geelong before he came back.

We also made the grand final last year and have beaten you in the finals the last 2 years.

We're better and you'd have to be stupid not to recognise that.

Saints will play Geelong in the grand final.

 

[Wooljay]

Why do Collingwood supporters think their team is better than ours??

Uh...serious question..? Because in our most recent clash, reflective of both of our CURRENT formlines, we not only beat you, but bent you over and sodomized you in front of 10s of thousands of people.

And people think Collingwood supporters are arrogant

 

[Military_man]

Week 1

Collingwood vs Bulldogs.. Collingwood win
Sydney vs Hawthorn...Sydney win
Carlton vs Fremantle... Carlton win
Geelong vs St Kilda... Geelong win

Week 2

Bulldogs vs Sydney .... Bulldogs win
Carlton vs St Kilda... Carlton win

Week 3

Collingwood vs Carlton... Carlton win
Bulldogs vs Geelong.. Geelong win

Final

Carlton vs Geelong.... Carlton win

 

[The Falcon Strike]

My main concern is that the Friday night Prelim final includes two of

Geelong, Collingwood and St Kilda.

I'll be there and they are the 3 best teams by a margin - so would love to see them play. Ideally Collingwood would be one of the teams - I'm keen to experience the crowd!

 

[Papa Juggs]

Uh...serious question..? Because in our most recent clash, reflective of both of our CURRENT formlines, we not only beat you, but bent you over and sodomized you in front of 10s of thousands of people.

And people think Collingwood supporters are arrogant

One match means nothing.

Surely you guys know this all too well.

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/2008/040920080523.html

 

[Nice Guy Adam]

Week 1:
St Kilda def. Geelong
Collingwood def. Western Bulldogs
Fremantle def. Carlton
Hawthorn def. Sydney

Week 2:
Geelong def. Hawthorn
Western Bulldogs def. Fremantle

Week 3:
St Kilda def. Western Bulldogs
Geelong def. Collingwood

GF:
Geelong def. St Kilda.

St Kilda beats us, everyone writes us off, we go through Hawthorn, Collingwood and finally St Kilda again to win it, exercising all demons and becoming one of the greatest sides of all time.

 

[serenityNow]

Week 1
Collingwood v Bulldogs- Collingwood
Geelong v St Kilda- Geelong
Freo v Hawks- Hawks
Carlton v Sydney- Carlton

Week 2
Bulldogs v Hawks- Bulldogs
Stkilda v Carlton- Carlton

Week 3
Collingwood v Carlton- Collingwood
Geelong v Bulldogs- Geelong

Week 4
Geelong v Collingwood- Geelong



Saints out in straight sets.
Dogs fall over at a prelim again.
2 best sides play off in Grand final, Cats by 23pts

 

[dart]

Week 1
Collingwood v Bulldogs- Collingwood
Geelong v St Kilda- Collingwood
Freo v Hawks- Collingwood
Carlton v Sydney- Collingwood

Week 2
Collingwood v Hawks- Collingwood
St Kilda v Sydeny- Collingwood

Week 3
Geelong v Hawks- Collingwood
St. Kilda v Bulldogs- Collingwood

Week 4
Geelong v St Kilda- Collingwood to win flag

Hoping for a pretty even finals series this year!

hahaha

 

[Wooljay]

One match means nothing.

Surely you guys know this all too well.

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/2008/040920080523.html

That argument goes both ways mate, as you implied you were infinitely better because you beat us in One Match.

I wasn't implying that we are better however, you merely asked the questions to why people think that Collingwood are a better team than St Kilda. You can parade your stats up and down the boards as much as you please, but in the end the finals series bases more on form than over-arching season statistics.

Saints supporters should know this best.

 

[Did's Dodgy Knee]

One match means nothing.

Surely you guys know this all too well.

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/2008/040920080523.html

True...

Because this happened...

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/2010/041520100409.html

Then THIS happened

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/games/2010/041520100717.html

 

[goodie23]

Pretty similar to the OP. The idea of Collingwood going out in straight sets makes me feel warm and tingly.

Week 1
Collingwood v Bulldogs- Bulldogs
Geelong v St Kilda- St Kilda
Freo v Hawks- Hawks
Carlton v Sydney- Sydney

Week 2
Collingwood v Hawks- Hawks
Geelong v Sydney- Geelong

Week 3
St Kilda v Hawks- St Kilda
Geelong v Bulldogs- Geelong

Week 4
St Kilda v Geelong - St Kilda

 

[Speck]

Collingwood v Bulldogs - Collingwood
St Kilda v Geelong - St Kilda
Carlton v Sydney - Sydney
Fremantle v Hawthorn - Fremantle

Bulldogs v Fremantle - Bulldogs
Geelong v Sydney - Geelong

St Kilda v Bulldogs - St Kilda
Collingwood v Geelong - Collingwood

St Kilda v Collingwood - St Kilda (Milney after the siren to put us up by a point)

 

[treefingers]

Week 1

Collingwood vs Bulldogs.. Collingwood win
Sydney vs Fremantle...Sydney win
Carlton vs Hawthorn... Hawthorn win
Geelong vs St Kilda... StKilda win

Week 2

Bulldogs vs Hawthorn.... Hawthorn win
Geelong vs Sydney ... Geelong win

Week 3

Collingwood vs Geelong ... Geelong win
Hawthorn vs StKilda Hawthorn win

Final

Hawthorn vs Geelong.... Hawthorn win

So in essence we do what we did in 08 and beat the dogs, the saints and the cats on our way to the flag