Your top 50

[qldbluesman_43]

1. Pendlebury
2. Mitchell
3. Ablett
4. Franklin
5. Murphy
6. Cox
7. Judd
8. Cloke
9. Dal Santo
10. Kelly
11. Goodes
12. Swan
13. Enright
14. Glass
15. S. Johnson
16. Boyd
17. S. Thompson
18. Bartel
19. McPharlin
20. Thomas
21. Fyfe
22. Priddis
23. Reid
24. Scotland
25. Scarlett
26. Davis
27. Goldstein
28. Fisher
29. Ball
30. Gibson
31. Petrie
32. Cotchin
33. Selwood
34. Watson
35. Birchall
36. Kennedy
37. Milne
38. Rockliff
39. Gibbs
40. Corey
41. Deledio
42. Mumford
43. Goddard
44. Bock
45. Griffen
46. Walker
47. Hodge
48. Swallow
49. R. Murphy
50. Maloney

My just missed out list: Podsiadly, J. Bolton, Embley, Simpson, Martin, Black, Pavlich, Wells, Lewis, Stanton

Selwood and Watson would have been top 10 if they didn't miss so many games.

 

[Harvey_35]

Just did mine, could be missing some of my favourites as I just went off the 60 listed players on herald website

1. Ablett
2. Pendlebury
3. Judd
4. Franklin
5. Swan
6. Murphy
7. Mitchell
8. Goodes
9. Enright
10. Cox
11. Scarlett
12. Cloke
13. Dal Santo
14. Kelly
15. Glass
16. Thomas
17. Fisher
18. Kennedy
19. Selwood
20. Bartel
21. Ball
22. Corey
23. Johnson
24. Fyfe
25. Watson
26. R. Murphy
27. McPharlin
28. Rioli
29. Cotchin
30. Birchall
31. Bock
32. Hodge
33. Mumford
34. Goddard
35. Moloney
36. Gibbs
37. David
38. Naitanui
39. Thompson
40. Milne
41. Hepell
42. Goldstein
43. Petrie
44. Deledio
45. Black
46. Embley
47. Griffin
48. Lewis
49. Swallow
50. Martin

 

[lmach]

Just did mine, could be missing some of my favourites as I just went off the 60 listed players on herald website

1. Ablett
2. Pendlebury
3. Judd
4. Franklin
5. Swan
6. Murphy
7. Mitchell
8. Goodes
9. Enright
10. Cox
11. Scarlett
12. Cloke
13. Dal Santo
14. Kelly
15. Glass
16. Thomas
17. Fisher
18. Kennedy
19. Selwood
20. Bartel
21. Ball
22. Corey
23. Johnson
24. Fyfe
25. Watson
26. R. Murphy
27. McPharlin
28. Rioli
29. Cotchin
30. Birchall
31. Bock
32. Hodge
33. Mumford
34. Goddard
35. Moloney
36. Gibbs
37. David
38. Naitanui
39. Thompson
40. Milne
41. Hepell
42. Goldstein
43. Petrie
44. Deledio
45. Black
46. Embley
47. Griffin
48. Lewis
49. Swallow
50. Martin

Where's Priddis and who is David?

 

[Prudster]

Where's Priddis and who is David?

Hahaha i seriously lol'd at this.

 

[94_Eagles]

1. Scott Pendlebury
2. Sam Mitchell
3. Chris Judd
4. Lance Franklin
5. Gary Ablett
6. Marc Murphy
7. Travis Cloke
8. Scott Thompson
9. Dean Cox
10. Dane Swan
11. Nick Dal Santo
12. James Kelly
13. Dale Thomas
14. Tom Rockliff
15. Andrew Swallow
16. Luke McPharlin
17. Matthew Boyd
18. Nathan Fyfe
19. Ben Reid
20. Josh Gibson
21. Adam Goodes
22. Daniel Wells
23. Darren Glass
24. Heath Scotland
25. Ryan Griffen
26. Leon Davis
27. Trent Cotchin
28. Todd Goldstein
29. Luke Ball
30. Josh Kennedy
31. Sam Fisher
32. Ryan O'Keefe
33. Matthew Priddis
34. Drew Petrie
35. Liam Shiels
36. Brent Moloney
37. Matthew Leuenberger
38. Corey Enright
39. Nathan Bock
40. Jobe Watson
41. Brett Deledio
42. Brent Stanton
43. Simon Black
44. Joel Selwood
45. Andrew Walker
46. Luke Hodge
47. Steve Johnson
48. Bryce Gibbs
49. Sean Dempster
50. Joel Corey

Surely taking the piss?

 

[Harvey_35]

Where's Priddis and who is David?

David would be Leon Davis, a typo there.

Priddis is unlucky to be miss out, and to be fair i'd happily interchange him with anyone in my bottom 5 as he is a gun.

I'm not a fan of his, hence why he missed out, but I do rate him

 

[StringyDog]

1. Pendlebury
2. Ablett
3. Murphy
4. Mitchell
5. Franklin
6. Judd
7. Cloke
8. Cox
9. Swan
10. Kelly
11. Dal Santo
12. Goodes
13. Thomas
14. Thompson
15. Goldstein
16. Boyd
17. Priddis
18. McPharlin
19. Scotland
20. Griffen
21. Wells
22. Fyfe
23. Gibson
24. Swallow
25. Cotchin
26. Reid
27. Davis
28. Enright
29. Selwood
30. Watson
31. Ball
32. Bartel
33. Corey
34. Fisher
35. Glass
36. Bock
37. Johnson
38. Scarlett
39. O'Keefe
40. Petrie
41. Moloney
42. Rockliff
43. R. Murphy
44. Gibbs
45. Deledio
46. Birchell
47. Black
48. Embley
49. Milne
50. Hodge

 

[Exactive]

1. Pendlebury
2. Ablett
3. Franklin
4. Murphy
5. Mitchell
6. Judd
7. Cloke
8. Cox
9. Swan
10. Del Santo
11. Glass
12. Goodes
13. Kelly
14. Enright
15. S. Johnson
16. Boyd
17. S. Thompson
18. McPharlin
19. Bartel
20. Ball
21. Goldstein
22. Priddis
23. Scotland
24. J. Kennedy
25. Thomas
26. Swallow
27. Mumford
28. Fisher
29. Cotchin
30. Corey
31. Gibbs
32. Selwood
33. Griffen
34. Reid
35. Fyfe
36. Scarlett
37. Davis
38. Rockliff
39. Milne
40. Moloney
41. Wells
42. Hodge
43. Goddard
44. Watson
45. Petrie
46. Deledio
47. Walker
48. R. Murphy
49. Embley
50. Bock

May have (and probably did) miss a few...

 

[magpieswmb]

Typical Magies supporters. What relevence does Shaw at Collingwood have to do with anything?

Stanton been around for long enough to be classified as good. Relevence to 2011?

was stanton really that good this year? Zaharakis won your best and fairest

 

[BluesKreuz]

Roughly picking from Sheehan's list of 60...

1. Ablett
2. Judd
3. Franklin
4. Pendlebury
5. M. Murphy
6. Goodes
7. Mitchell
8. Swan
9. Cloke
10. Glass
11. Cox
12. Selwood
13. Bartel
14. Scarlett
15. Thomas
16. Dal Santo
17. Johnson
18. Fisher
19. Kelly
20. Enright
21. Boyd
22. Scotland
23. Priddis
24. Davis
25. Simpson
26. Fyfe
27. Watson
28. Goldstein
29. Goddard
30. Hodge
31. R. Murphy
32. S. Thompson
33. Petrie
34. Cotchin
35. Ball
36. Deledio
37. Black
38. Bock
39. Gibbs
40. McPharlin
41. Mumford
42. Reid
43. Birchall
44. Kennedy (wce)
45. A. Swallow
46. Wells
47. A. Walker
48. Moloney
49. Milne
50. Corey

 

[eaglespremiers]

was stanton really that good this year? Zaharakis won your best and fairest

Pays to play every game in regards to the B&F.
Stanton missed two games this year.

 

[Dukes Of Hurley]

I really didnt think corey was that good this year

Anyone who has him in their top 30 is having a laugh
Plenty of players ahead of him this year

 

[Peacock]

All the bigfooty experts are always talking about no Judd no Carlton, yet you all rank Murphy ahead of him Love this place