Banter Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood Part 5

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025?


  • Total voters
    129

Remove this Banner Ad

Don't make it personal. You have been really distressed and umpire obsessed the past 24 hours. It'll be okay.
You made it personal lol. I made a comment about the umpiring in a game and you got upset. It's got nothing to do with you. Go talk to the hundreds of other posts talking about the same thing right now if you have an issue.
 
You made it personal lol. I made a comment about the umpiring in a game and you got upset. It's got nothing to do with you. Go talk to the hundreds of other posts talking about the same thing right now if you have an issue.
I didn't, you're on the attack for no reason.

Collingwood weren't great tonight but when the game was on the line, they stood up more than the fumbling bumbling Blues did last night. Reducing it to a 2 night meltdown about umpires is really poor form by you. Every time I think you've changed, you revert back to the same rubbish.
 
Apologising to Dogs fans on behalf of the universe, noble

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Some of them would have paid good money to go to that game. 100th anniversary and all. And then that happens. In a competition this tight 4 points is crucial. Especially against a team you will likely compete with at the latter stages of the season for the top 8. They deserve more than an apology.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Some of them would have paid good money to go to that game. 100th anniversary and all. And then that happens. In a competition this tight 4 points is crucial. Especially against a team you will likely compete with at the latter stages of the season for the top 8. They deserve more than an apology.
When did you learn to play the violin? That was a great touch.
 
I didn't, you're on the attack for no reason.

Collingwood weren't great tonight but when the game was on the line, they stood up more than the fumbling bumbling Blues did last night. Reducing it to a 2 night meltdown about umpires is really poor form by you. Every time I think you've changed, you revert back to the same rubbish.
I posted in the match thread like hundreds of other posters. You aren't a moderator. You don't have to agree with anything I said. It was not a meltdown at all - it's just been a very poor round of umpiring. Should we just bury our heads in the sand a pretend it didn't happen. Umpiring can have a significant impact on games. In some games it's as big of a factor as anything you would deem reasonable to discuss.
 
Some of them would have paid good money to go to that game. 100th anniversary and all. And then that happens. In a competition this tight 4 points is crucial. Especially against a team you will likely compete with at the latter stages of the season for the top 8. They deserve more than an apology.

Ah rubbish, Pies were the better team and deserved the win, maybe watch the game again without obsessing over the umps

Bulldogs fans got their money's worth, huge crowd and an entertaining game against the powerhouse of the comp

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Ah rubbish, Pies were the better team and deserved the win, maybe watch the game again without obsessing over the umps

Bulldogs fans got their money's worth, huge crowd and an entertaining game against the powerhouse of the comp

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Ok so you didn't think the umpires had an influence. That's your right. Just like it's my right to give my view.
 
I posted in the match thread like hundreds of other posters. You aren't a moderator. You don't have to agree with anything I said. It was not a meltdown at all - it's just been a very poor round of umpiring. Should we just bury our heads in the sand a pretend it didn't happen. Umpiring can have a significant impact on games. In some games it's as big of a factor as anything you would deem reasonable to discuss.
Please stop trying to moderate my comments. You comment on things, I comment on things. Let's not get upset about it. You seem to interpret me disagreeing with you as a form of censorship.

You have the umpiring side of things covered. I noticed more Pies standing up in the clutch period of tonight's game than Carlton had last night. Seems a relevant note for this thread.
 
Please stop trying to moderate my comments. You comment on things, I comment on things. Let's not get upset about it. You seem to interpret me disagreeing with you as a form of censorship.

You have the umpiring side of things covered. I noticed more Pies standing up in the clutch period of tonight's game than Carlton had last night. Seems a relevant note for this thread.
I've had many discussions with you in the past without it getting personal and it's been fine. Sometimes we agree sometimes we don't. If you want to discuss what I said then discuss what I said - more than happy to hear your thoughts. No need to make it personal.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I've had many discussions with you in the past without it getting personal and it's been fine. Sometimes we agree sometimes we don't. If you want to discuss what I said then discuss what I said - more than happy to hear your thoughts. No need to make it personal.
For the last time, you going on the attack is not me making it personal or censoring you. Every comment every person makes here is up for feedback. Now we're just talking about the fact we are talking to each other, which is far more pointless.

My OPINION is you reduce threads like these to umpire and injury whinges too extensively. Everyone does it to some degree but it is all you want to focus on.

Collingwood have played better than Carlton the past 2 weeks. Carlton have folded both times the game heated up and entered clutch mode. The Pies had the match winners required, the Blues did not.

I'm just adding those points to add some balance to the 2 night umpiring meltdown you have provided. And I'm fine with you disagreeing, I'm not going to play the victim like you have.
 
My OPINION is you reduce threads like these to umpire and injury whinges too extensively. Everyone does it to some degree but it is all you want to focus on.
What are you on about? I have probably brought up umpiring significantly on the main board less than 5 times in the last 18 months. You are just making stuff up here. I barely post outside of the Carlton related threads. And most of them are about our list/game style.
 
Brunch of plodders beat up on a side missing plenty of good players.
Salt mine in here tonight I see😂

C'mon Worm have some class. That was a bruising contest and we came out on top. If we didn't blow so many chances it would've been a comfortable margin.

You know Carlton would have completely crumbled under the intensity the dogs brought. Bloos would've shat the bed midway through the third under all that pressure and lost by 40..you know it.
That what's really making y'all so salty.
 
Some of them would have paid good money to go to that game. 100th anniversary and all. And then that happens. In a competition this tight 4 points is crucial. Especially against a team you will likely compete with at the latter stages of the season for the top 8. They deserve more than an apology.
The salt is real.
 
Salt mine in here tonight I see😂

C'mon Worm have some class. That was a bruising contest and we came out on top. If we didn't blow so many chances it would've been a comfortable margin.

You know Carlton would have completely crumbled under the intensity the dogs brought. Bloos would've shat the bed midway through the third under all that pressure and lost by 40..you know it.
That what's really making y'all so salty.
Wasn't the game on Thursday night one of the highest pressure rated games in the last few years according to CD?
 
I posted in the match thread like hundreds of other posters. You aren't a moderator. You don't have to agree with anything I said. It was not a meltdown at all - it's just been a very poor round of umpiring. Should we just bury our heads in the sand a pretend it didn't happen. Umpiring can have a significant impact on games. In some games it's as big of a factor as anything you would deem reasonable to discuss.
Wah Wah Umpires.

Eventually you might realise your team is just shite.

Or not.
 

Banter Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood Part 5


Write your reply...
Back
Top