Oppo Camp Jack Ginnivan (Traded to Hawks 2023)

Remove this Banner Ad

I called it last year. The next Milne!

I hope that doesn’t mean what I would normally take it to mean… random player thread bumps are scary enough as it is through injuries!
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I hope that doesn’t mean what I would normally take it to mean… random player thread bumps are scary enough as it is through injuries!
No not in this case. Speaking purely on playing ability if the stars align Ginnivan has “it” to a level which will allow him to make a similar on field impact, IMO (talking 2+ goals a game over a 10 year career). The only reference I’d make to the similarity in what made Milne hatable is the way in which he finds high contact which we’ll love and will become unpopular very quickly.
 
The only frees he gets are for above the shoulder and most times the free is there.
Similar to the Bulldogs’ Weightman. I think it’s just bad tackling technique against smaller (annoying) opponents.

I haven't seen a real pattern emerge of him playing for frees.
Not too much smaller as he is just over 6ft in the old money. Take your point, though.
 
The only frees he gets are for above the shoulder and most times the free is there.
Similar to the Bulldogs’ Weightman. I think it’s just bad tackling technique against smaller (annoying) opponents.

I haven't seen a real pattern emerge of him playing for frees.
He's got a technique of dropping the shoulder at a tackler and then exaggerating the contact. Free has to be paid because it is high contact. But it won't be popular.
 
Look I have no problem with acknowledging Selwood's courage or skill - but - when you deliberately aim your head and run at an opposition players hand that's beyond the pale for me.

I don't dislike Selwood but I am disgusted at such courage and skill being polluted by crass opportunism.

What infuriates me is there is no way the umpiring panel can not be aware that he does it, by turning a blind eye they encourage it and so our game becomes a little bit more like soccer where staging is endemic and youngsters seeing him getting away with it are encouraged to copy.

Pendles has always done the same thing….. just saying.
 
The only frees he gets are for above the shoulder and most times the free is there.
Similar to the Bulldogs’ Weightman. I think it’s just bad tackling technique against smaller (annoying) opponents.

I haven't seen a real pattern emerge of him playing for frees.

I’ve decided I’m blind to them as well.
 
No not in this case. Speaking purely on playing ability if the stars align Ginnivan has “it” to a level which will allow him to make a similar on field impact, IMO (talking 2+ goals a game over a 10 year career). The only reference I’d make to the similarity in what made Milne hatable is the way in which he finds high contact which we’ll love and will become unpopular very quickly.
All jokes aside, Milne was one of the best small forwards to play the game. Over 550 goals at 2 goals a game.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I understand the point that Cornes was attempting to make but I'm sure that the CFC media department would have prepped the lad before he took to the field with his GoPro. Not that I'm endorsing Cornes at all, but this type of 'American Style' bravado will surely invite a small dose of Hubris. I prefer my winners humble and more reserved typically.
 
This the same Kane Cornes that did this in his 9th game…?

B96157B6-6661-4FCC-8A68-74E87DE0212B.jpeg
 
I understand the point that Cornes was attempting to make but I'm sure that the CFC media department would have prepped the lad before he took to the field with his GoPro. Not that I'm endorsing Cornes at all, but this type of 'American Style' bravado will surely invite a small dose of Hubris. I prefer my winners humble and more reserved typically.

Lot of Guns are Cocky like that
 
Let's be honest if the tonic didn't wear the black and white stripes we would all hate him
He does have a bit of swagger about him and yes I probably would not enjoy it from an opposing player but he plays for us and I have no problem with him or his celebrations which I think may infuriate many in the future, he is quite a talent and very young still.

Just wait till he has 50 games up he will really be hated by other teams fans because he can really play, he is also only a couple months older than N Daicos who they will also hate because he will become very good and they do not like that from our players but stuff them they do not do us any favours.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Oppo Camp Jack Ginnivan (Traded to Hawks 2023)

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top