List Mgmt. 2023 List Management and Trading

[Bearded Clam]

Didn't Daicos go off early, due to injury, when we played the Pies?

Dont recall it.. but i do recall his brother having a pretty decent game..

 

[Bearded Clam]

What do you reckon Keays trade value is?

I mean, it's a trade thread, he seems superfluous to the side as a half forward soft tagger, what's his value, mid to late first, early second?

Mid to late first?.. early second?….


SOLD!!..

 

[spenze]

Mid to late first?.. early second?….


SOLD!!..

I get where you are coming from but I think it is a valid question. I don't want to hear "well the coaches rate him" or " we'd never sell him off he brings professionalism" " or you can't get rid of his experience" etc etc, what do people seriously think trade value is.

 

[pjcrows]

What do you reckon Keays trade value is?

I mean, it's a trade thread, he seems superfluous to the side as a half forward soft tagger, what's his value, mid to late first, early second?

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

I get where you are coming from but I think it is a valid question. I don't want to hear "well the coaches rate him" or " we'd never sell him off he brings professionalism" " or you can't get rid of his experience" etc etc, what do people seriously think trade value is.

Keays would be a third rounder.

 

[cleanhands]

Keays would be a third rounder.

And rounder and rounder and rounder

 

[jackster83]

Didn't Daicos go off early, due to injury, when we played the Pies?

He went off for treatment but came back on.

 

[rabidcrow]

Didn't Daicos go off early, due to injury, when we played the Pies?

Played 87% game time so must have been late. I reckon he went off for a few minutes after getting tackled at a point in the last


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[FR0GGY]

Played 87% game time so must have been late. I reckon he went off for a few minutes after getting tackled at a point in the last


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Nah it was in the first half I’m pretty sure.

 

[Mostyn]

Keays would be a third rounder.

Nah. He's a guy who's featured in club best and fairests and is established best 22. The market for those kind of players is higher than that.

 

[George Kramer]

Nah. He's a guy who's featured in club best and fairests and is established best 22. The market for those kind of players is higher than that.

That means little when he has a known weakness

 

[Mostyn]

That means little when he has a known weakness

So there's only a market for players with zero weaknesses?

 

[George Kramer]

So there's only a market for players with zero weaknesses?

We are talking the price, sure he will get a game at some other clubs but they aren’t going to pay a lot.

He’s been moved out of our midfield because he can’t kick, given he was racking up the possessions and finished high in our B&F playing that role, it gives a pretty clear indication of his value.

And I doubt he finishes top 10 this year so that relevance is there anymore.

 

[Scorpus]

I doubt a club would trade for Keays when he's an unrestricted free agent at the end of next year.

 

[Bearded Clam]

Keays would be good for someone like west coast..

Go in there and help stem the current bleeding.

Its what he did for us in the rebuild.

See ball.. get ball… keep it moving forward and away from the opponents goal. Who cares how ugly it is and who cares if keays doesnt hit his team mates.. its all about keays winning the ball and moving it forward any way he can and while he does that its not in the oppositions hands going the other direction!

That way you dont suffer as many humiliating, soul destroying defeats..

But once your rebuild progresses and you start adding talent.. you move on quickly from needing the keays types. You need to prioritise skill and talent.

But a rebuilding club arent gonna give up much to get a keays type player.. you pick them up as delists from other clubs that are generally contenders at the time and have no need for a scrapper..

 

[Brasher]

Keays would be good for someone like west coast..

Go in there and help stem the current bleeding.

Its what he did for us in the rebuild.

See ball.. get ball… keep it moving forward and away from the opponents goal. Who cares how ugly it is and who cares if keays doesnt hit his team mates.. its all about keays winning the ball and moving it forward any way he can and while he does that its not in the oppositions hands going the other direction!

That way you dont suffer as many humiliating, soul destroying defeats..

But once your rebuild progresses and you start adding talent.. you move on quickly from needing the keays types. You need to prioritise skill and talent.

But a rebuilding club arent gonna give up much to get a keays type player.. you pick them up as delists from other clubs that are generally contenders at the time and have no need for a scrapper..

Yep. You don't get the guy pouring the concrete to lay the $200/m parquetry floor.

 

[Bearded Clam]

I doubt a club would trade for Keays when he's an unrestricted free agent at the end of next year.

We should keep hold of him and make him our sanfl captain.

Go into the sanfl team and set the standard to the youth in regards to giving it 110% and never giving up on a contest.

Lead by example.

Reckon his manic play and endless gut running would cause a lot of drama and worry to opponents at Sanfl level.

 

[The Perfect Stranger]

What do you reckon Keays trade value is?

I mean, it's a trade thread, he seems superfluous to the side as a half forward soft tagger, what's his value, mid to late first, early second?

3rd rounder at best. I respect Keays and he has had some great moments of toughness and courage, but you cannot take a player into finals who has skills as bad as his are. He's the ultimate momentum killer so most good clubs would give him a wide berth.

 

[Mutineer]

Elijah nothing startling again today in the GCS's big win over the Footscray Bulldogs

 

[PeterSalt]

Elijah nothing startling again today in the GCS's big win over the Footscray Bulldogs

View attachment 1697983

Change of scenery and a roll of the dice? If he came for sfa?

 

[cleanhands]

We should keep hold of him and make him our sanfl captain.

Go into the sanfl team and set the standard to the youth in regards to giving it 110% and never giving up on a contest.

Lead by example.

Reckon his manic play and endless gut running would cause a lot of drama and worry to opponents at Sanfl level.

Let’s give it a try

 

[Mutineer]

Change of scenery and a roll of the dice? If he came for sfa?

He's not coming for SFA while contracted (2024) and wouldn't be on the big bucks that would make him an attractive salary cap dump if they were that way inclined. GCS wouldn't be inclined to do us any favours after snaffling Rankine who they were desperate to keep.

 

[PeterSalt]

He's not coming for SFA while contracted (2024) and wouldn't be on the big bucks that would make him an attractive salary cap dump if they were that way inclined. GCS wouldn't be inclined to do us any favours after snaffling Rankine who they were desperate to keep.

Fair enough to all of that

I don't follow or watch any VFL at all, beyond what's posted here.

Curious if you think he'd be worth a roll of dice at all though?

 

[Mutineer]

Fair enough to all of that

I don't follow or watch any VFL at all, beyond what's posted here.

Curious if you think he'd be worth a roll of dice at all though?

Of course but it's becoming a worry now he's 2 years post ACL and doesn't seem to be anything like the player everyone had visioned him to become.

 

[spenze]

Elijah nothing startling again today in the GCS's big win over the Footscray Bulldogs

View attachment 1697983

sweet, get him at a reduced price. Bit of money being spent in the magoos