Search results for query: *

Thanks KM, interesting info on both boys. Appreciate you taking the time to respond.

Hi KM, Appreciate your work mate. Feel free to point me to another post if this has been covered already… But it seems to me that Daicos is having as dominant a season at the level as anyone ever has.. have there been as/more dominant seasons in recent history? Also, how do you rate young Dib?

It's called a sock

I own one, so that puts me ahead of the VFL Pies

In that case, I will pipe down.. All yours

Stolen my thing Apex ;)

Where are all the f’wits that have been bagging this bloke for the last 3 years? Too slow, can’t kick, bad decision maker, blah blah... Onya Schaz

I probably would have agreed with you at the start of this year, but a couple of his games and bursts within games this year changed my mind. He won the West Coast game (from memory) off his own boot and had one or two others where I saw genuine dominance from him. Also I don’t think he had more...

Really surprised at your assessment of De Goey KM. I though he showed on a few occasions last year, especially late, that he has the ability to be a genuine game changer and potentially develop into a top 3 player on our list in the next two years. Consistency clearly something he needs to work...

Appreciate the response mate. On that description Mihocek sounds like Dunn mkII. Could do a lot worse (I’m an unashamed fan of big Dunny)

KM - thoughts on the Pies rookie picks? Like the look of the two new lads and seems that Hine & co have targeted character whilst filling list needs. Do you rate them? Mihocek in particular seems genuinely ready to go Oxley we obviously committed to but seems an odd one to recycle given we now...

Score update please?

KM, love your work. Any chance Battle or Berry make it to the Pies at 28? If not who would be other KPP options around that mark?

Coming from a bloke whose handle is named after one of the shittest players around that means heaps

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/gold-coast-flag-their-interest-in-collingwood-ruckman-jarrod-witts-20160913-grfaw5.html

Spot on.

This rumour starting to gather some steam with talk being a swap for Kennedy (unclear whether pick exchange would also be involved). If it was a straight swap I don't mind this.. Reckon Kennedy has real potential but has struggled at AFL level. Howe's salary my biggest concern. Interested in...

I completely understand Brisbane not wanting to get reamed again in a trade but coming out and blatantly refusing to trade before even knowing what is on the table just shows how badly that club is run. Surely even their supporters would want a trade looked at first? If they feel they are...

So did the Beams rumours. Then one day...

Demanding and being rejected on all fronts except interstate where he doesn't want to go (according to media). The rest of your comments aren't worth responding to.. Agree to disagree

Aggot a much better idea howe isn't undersized he's 190cm ffs.. Can't get my head around everyone comparing him to Elliott and Fas other than the fact he's a lead up type forward, he has 8 cms on Fas and 11-12 on Jamie... Taller and stronger than them and brings a different dynamic to our...

Tend to agree with this. If Freo or anyone else are willing to pay his supposed 500k asking price I doubt we'll be trying to chase that down (and rightly so).

Lockyer was a completely different player and Pushing 30 in 2010. Anthony had a single year where he showed anything at all in a team that played a lot of good footy. Howe has shown ability in multiple positions over 100 odd games. You're comparing apples with oranges there Sunshine. Next...

Jesse showed little in a good team. I'd argue Howe's 2013 was better than anything White produced in his career and did it in a terrible team. Others may argue but I think circumstances around the two are different.

The difference is Freeman has never played a game and is no guarantee to have a meaningful career.Freeman's contract after incentives would have been around the mark anyway if reports are to be believed, he just didn't back himself in to meet the hurdles. With Howe I think people are seriously...

450 is the absolute top end, 350-400 would hopefully be more like it

Howe is 190cm not 178-180

He kicked 28 goals in 2013 playing in a team that had the worst offense in the league that year, won 2 games, and had an average losing margin of 70 points. If he can reproduce similar effort in a team getting more forward entries and has some other targets around him I don't see why he...