![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/richmond.png)
If Short goes to Gold Coast, I’ll back is to snap our 99 or 100 game losing streak against the SunsHe and Rioli are exactly what the suns need off HB
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
![Thumbs up :thumbsup: 👍](https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/ajax/libs/twemoji/14.0.2/72x72/1f44d.png)
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
If Short goes to Gold Coast, I’ll back is to snap our 99 or 100 game losing streak against the SunsHe and Rioli are exactly what the suns need off HB
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
The Richmond Back , better than the legFair to say I am not a fan of Jayden's "efforts" lately. Watching him pre-game, he seems to really struggle in all the ground ball drills they do. I suspect he may be carrying a back injury. If so, he has become a liability and needs to be rested. There are plenty of kids who can play in his place. On the otherhand if he is not injured and this is his standard, then he needs to be jettisoned asap.
Best described in cricketing terms as a flat track bully.Upon reflection I reckon Short was always this bad he was just very well hidden. Never had to be accountable for a man. Was fed the ball on the outside so he could wind up and kick long to a contest. Problem we have now is there's no contest, so the ball just sails into the hands of an oppo defender. The dude won a b&f doing this as it was the crown jewel of Dimma's game plan. Completely goes to shit when not propped up by guns and has to do the hard stuff.
Who is going to do that? Seriously we aren’t ChelseaI wonder if Short was advised that he’ll no longer be considered for senior selection, would he then try to get to another club?
richoatthedisco?Upon reflection I reckon Short was always this bad he was just very well hidden. Never had to be accountable for a man. Was fed the ball on the outside so he could wind up and kick long to a contest. Problem we have now is there's no contest, so the ball just sails into the hands of an oppo defender. The dude won a b&f doing this as it was the crown jewel of Dimma's game plan. Completely goes to shit when not propped up by guns and has to do the hard stuff.
I'm not even sure if it's VFL standard.zero tackles and 9 turn overs is not AFL standard
It’s so frustrating and why I keep saying Yze sets low standards. Senior players continue to be gifted games after constantly failing, yet younger guys are dropped the minute they have a bad game. Smith should be playing before Short no matter what as long term is more important than Short term.I'm not even sure if it's VFL standard.
Surely we can't be the only ones who are seeing this?
Disagree. He was always a clean enough player and one of his worst flaws this year is fumbling and over running the ball which has resulted in I don't know how many goals. He never used to turn the ball over as badly as he has and he's having his worst tackling year of his career. There's been a drop off from his game.Upon reflection I reckon Short was always this bad he was just very well hidden. Never had to be accountable for a man. Was fed the ball on the outside so he could wind up and kick long to a contest. Problem we have now is there's no contest, so the ball just sails into the hands of an oppo defender. The dude won a b&f doing this as it was the crown jewel of Dimma's game plan. Completely goes to shit when not propped up by guns and has to do the hard stuff.
I think you're right. He was doing it in 2017 and late in the season, he was dropped and we improved immediately. Nothing's changed. He was never accountable then and he's not now. He didn't put his head over the ball then and he doesn't now. The only thing different is now he's vice-captain and won't be dropped. The icing on the cake was a) when he had a go at Cumberland for costing us a shot at goal against Adelaide. Fair enough it was really dumb by Noah, but coming from Short...and b) when he had a go at Nank for kicking across goal when he could have at least made a contest but pulled out.Upon reflection I reckon Short was always this bad he was just very well hidden. Never had to be accountable for a man. Was fed the ball on the outside so he could wind up and kick long to a contest.
He was always a vanilla footballer and low on defensive pressure. His disposal was always appearing better as Lynch and Jack with the three amigos scrapped , defended and locked the ball in. Then all our gun mids with Houli covered for him in the BL. He was always a role player in a champion side and would capitulate in an average side. Brandon Ellis says hello at the Suns.Disagree. He was always a clean enough player and one of his worst flaws this year is fumbling and over running the ball which has resulted in I don't know how many goals. He never used to turn the ball over as badly as he has and he's having his worst tackling year of his career. There's been a drop off from his game.
Ellis had more heart.He was always a vanilla footballer and low on defensive pressure. His disposal was always appearing better as Lynch and Jack with the three amigos scrapped , defended and locked the ball in. Then all our gun mids with Houli covered for him in the BL. He was always a role player in a champion side and would capitulate in an average side. Brandon Ellis says hello at the Suns.
I agree , but that wouldn’t be hard to eclipse.Ellis had more heart.
I said this months ago, the problem is further up the field, otherwise change his role.Upon reflection I reckon Short was always this bad he was just very well hidden. Never had to be accountable for a man. Was fed the ball on the outside so he could wind up and kick long to a contest. Problem we have now is there's no contest, so the ball just sails into the hands of an oppo defender. The dude won a b&f doing this as it was the crown jewel of Dimma's game plan. Completely goes to shit when not propped up by guns and has to do the hard stuff.
You're describing most HBFs in the AFL though. For some reason his kicking has turned to dogshit and that was his 1 wood. Without it he's an absolute passenger.Upon reflection I reckon Short was always this bad he was just very well hidden. Never had to be accountable for a man. Was fed the ball on the outside so he could wind up and kick long to a contest. Problem we have now is there's no contest, so the ball just sails into the hands of an oppo defender. The dude won a b&f doing this as it was the crown jewel of Dimma's game plan. Completely goes to shit when not propped up by guns and has to do the hard stuff.
Think that's a bit unfair on Brando, perhaps not the most courageous player, but he ran hard both ways, not something I can say with any conviction about Short.I agree , but that wouldn’t be hard to eclipse.![]()
If he's not smart enough to realise every time he kicks it to the hotspot that interceptors sit in behind the ball it gets intercepted he should not be in an AFL side.I said this months ago, the problem is further up the field, otherwise change his role.
Just wanted to show a bit of love for Shorty.
Yes, he hasn’t had a good season on field. But in a year where every second bloke has been rumoured to “want out” (including a lot of his close mates), Jayden continues to front the media and talk about the club in such a glowing and positive way- something we have really needed in a tough year this season.
I appreciate him for everything he’s done so far in his career for our great club.. and characters like him are going to be vital in this next 2-3 year period as we develop young talent.
Go easy on him, he’s a good egg!