I originally had him at 8 just behind Boak. I found 8-10 could have gone in any order tbh, but I went the quality ruckman, the quality small defender then the good midfielder in that order.
I could see how you could have him slightly ahead of Boak but I have no idea how you could even consider Gibbs being near Goldy
Goldy is putting together another very year - would be his 5th by my calculations. He may have more in him - those that wrote him off at the start of the year look to have got that wrong.
Not sure that is correct - he had 1 bad game V the Dees. He received coaches votes in 5 games in the 1st half of the year.
Yeah, could see that. Don't think a lot seperates the list after Goldstein, anyway.
Trash tier name, Kurt/Tobias/Tyler. I've done him a favour calling him Kirk and putting him over Westhoff who in his first year gave one of the best defenders ive ever seen in Darren Glass an absolute bath in one of the more rare dominant performances, some skinny first year player with the dumbest ****ing haircut bullying probably the best 1v1 highball defender to live in Glass
Goldy has been a fine player but you'll have a very tough time convincing the masses he's been better than Hawkins, Riewoldt, JPK and Gray. I think I'd take Boak before him also.
Ill die on this hill.
Hes not even the best in his position for the year?To me Hawkins was the best player in the draft.
You could go thirty years in the AFL as a club and not find a player like that as a key forward.
Selwood obviously a great player but there are more Selwood types around than Hawkins.
The fact that the cats got Hawkins for pick 41 is f’ed
Riewoldt will very likely retire end of year. Hawkins I think will play on next year, especially if the Cats are still contending. Unsure about Goldstein, I could see Clarkson maybe tapping Goldstein on the shoulder end of year as they are a rebuilding side and it might be time to move to a younger player in his place on the list. Boak was runner up in Port's B&F so there's no signs of him dropping off, but at that age things can change quickly with a bad injury or form drop so you never know, think he goes on in 2024 though.
