Draft Review 2006 - Redo the 2006 Draft

[Wild Bill]

Sitting at 13th for total. Much harder to average 13 CP a game for 23 games, then 15 for 5. Matt Thomas has played 2 games but sits at 20 because he averaged 12 in those 2 games. Thats why total is a much better stat.
Not to mention there are far more midfielders than forwards.

Well you need someone to go and get their hands dirty. Watching the final - he was about the only one.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Statistically similar to Fevola's output. Over his career, Reiwoldt has not been a great team player, and has rightfully been judged harshly by former footballers n the media. To his credit, the penny has dropped this year, and he's become a more rounded player, and is getting due recognition.

You've been sucked in by the media. He's been playing selfless football since 2011.

2011 - 22 games, 21 assists
2012 - 22 games, 20 assists
2013 - 23 games, 26 assists
2014 - 23 games, 18 assists
2015 - 23 games, 22 assists

 

[Cringle]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Todd Goldstein
3. Josh P. Kennedy
4. Robbie Gray
5. Bryce Gibbs
6. Tom Hawkins
7. Jack Riewoldt
8. Travis Boak
9. Jack Frawley
10. Kurt Tippett

 

[HARKER]

Not often you'd find picks #2, #3 and #4 nowhere near the top 10.....top 20.....or even top 30

Pretty solid year was 2006

 

[Donakebab]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Todd Goldstein
3. Josh P. Kennedy
4. Robbie Gray
5. Bryce Gibbs
6. Tom Hawkins
7. Jack Riewoldt
8. Travis Boak
9. Jack Frawley
10. Kurt Tippett

Gibbs plays a couple of good games and he jumps ahead of Hawkins, Riewoldt and Boak? Nah.

 

[Cringle]

Gibbs plays a couple of good games and he jumps ahead of Hawkins, Riewoldt and Boak? Nah.

lol

"top 10 in no particular order"

 

[Donakebab]

lol

"top 10 in no particular order"

Looks like a pretty particular order given you've put numbers in there.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Due to the large number of late bloomers, this draft more than any other raises the question of how much you rate longevity over top level performance. For example, Robbie Gray didn't really turn into a gun a player until his was 26 years old and in his 8th season. Unless he does a Boomer and plays until he's 40 he'll retire with maybe 6-7 seasons of elite footy under his belt, and 8 seasons of being an injury prone tease. Compare that to other guys like Boak or Riewoldt who have been guns since 2009/10 when they were 20/21 years old. Does Gray's higher peak make up for the fact that he has ~5 fewer quality seasons under his belt? At the moment I'd have him behind Boak, Riewoldt and possibly even Gibbs on output over their career.

 

[avishka5]

Geez west coast did well in this. Schoey and eMac are two very high quality defenders.

Brown may not be that great but to stay on our list for 10 years isnt too bad either. He could have been a much better player if it werent for the injuries. Was really looking forward to him at the start of last season but after the ACL i dont think he will wear the wings again.

 

[philthy05]

lol

"top 10 in no particular order"

Gibbs shouldn't even be in top ten anyway

 

[Cringle]

Gibbs shouldn't even be in top ten anyway

...

Looks like a pretty particular order given you've put numbers in there.

Yeah was actually trying to take the piss out of myself. Too hard to express through typing. Don't worry.

 

[Ekomaira]

Joel Selwood
Todd Goldstein
Robbie Gray
Josh P. Kennedy
Travis Boak
Jack Riewoldt
David Armitage
Kurt Tippett
Bryce Gibbs
James Frawley

something like that

 

[HeHateMe]

Joel Selwood
Todd Goldstein
Robbie Gray
Josh P. Kennedy
Travis Boak
Jack Riewoldt
David Armitage
Kurt Tippett
Bryce Gibbs
James Frawley

something like that

Boak and Armatige, above Tippett and Frawley?

Tippett is close to the best ruck/fwd in the league and Frawley is top 5 kpb. Those two mids are what.... Top 20 - 30 for there position?

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

 

[Donakebab]

Joel Selwood
Todd Goldstein
Robbie Gray
Josh P. Kennedy
Travis Boak
Jack Riewoldt
David Armitage
Kurt Tippett
Bryce Gibbs
James Frawley

something like that

Armitage too high. Replace him with Hawkins who has had a better career to date.

 

[Ekomaira]

Boak and Armatige, above Tippett and Frawley?

Tippett is close to the best ruck/fwd in the league and Frawley is top 5 kpb. Those two mids are what.... Top 20 - 30 for there position?

Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

yeah fair call. I didn't really put a lot of thought into it, guess I'm thinking midfielders first

 

[Wargreymon90]

1. Selwood
2. R.Gray
3. Kennedy
4. Reiwoldt
5. Boak
6. Gibbs
7. Hawkins
8. Frawley
9. Goldstein
10. Westhoff

 

[adammania9]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Josh P. Kennedy
3. Jack Riewoldt
4. Robbie Gray
5. Bryce Gibbs
6. Tom Hawkins
7. Travis Boak
8. Nick Smith
9. Sam Jacobs
10. James Frawley
11. Todd Goldstein
12. Bachar Houli
13. Justin Westhoff
14. Tom Lonergan
15. Ben Reid

Shane Edwards and Shaun Grigg the next two

 

[Love the Drake]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Josh P. Kennedy
3. Jack Riewoldt
4. Robbie Gray
5. Bryce Gibbs
6. Tom Hawkins
7. Travis Boak
8. Nick Smith
9. Sam Jacobs
10. James Frawley
11. Todd Goldstein
12. Bachar Houli
13. Justin Westhoff
14. Tom Lonergan
15. Ben Reid

Shane Edwards and Shaun Grigg the next two

Great list; the only changes I’d have are Edwards and Westhoff top 10, ahead of boak and Frawley.

 

[adammania9]

Great list; the only changes I’d have are Edwards and Westhoff top 10, ahead of boak and Frawley.

Frawley’s position is hard to judge - star for some of his career, plodder for others, but Boak has had a great career to date and he nearly won a Brownlow.

 

[Ambrosia]

Jarrod Harbrow is a gun and has been performing to a high standard since 2009. He gets into my top 10

 

[Wild Bill]

1. Joel Selwood
2. Josh P. Kennedy
3. Jack Riewoldt
4. Robbie Gray
5. Bryce Gibbs
6. Tom Hawkins
7. Travis Boak
8. Nick Smith
9. Sam Jacobs
10. James Frawley
11. Todd Goldstein
12. Bachar Houli
13. Justin Westhoff
14. Tom Lonergan
15. Ben Reid

Shane Edwards and Shaun Grigg the next two

I wouldn’t have Jacobs in front of Goldy. Sauce has no AAs or B&F and never been the premium ruck in the comp. Goldy ticks those 3 boxes.

 

[adammania9]

I wouldn’t have Jacobs in front of Goldy. Sauce has no AAs or B&F and never been the premium ruck in the comp. Goldy ticks those 3 boxes.

I could have sworn he was AA in 2014 but Sandi was the sole ruck. Yeah, fair call - Goldy > Jacobs

 

[00Stinger]

1 Selwood
2 Kennedy
3 Gray
4 Reiwoldt
5 Goldstien
6 Hawkins
7 Boak
8 Jacobs
9 N Smith
10 Gibbs
11 Frawley
12 Reid
13 Westhoff
14 Tippett
15 Edwards
16 Harbrow
17 Grigg
18 Armitage
19 MacKenzie
20 Lonergan

 

[Grisha]

Jack Riewoldt is number two for mine. He will never get the respect he deserves unfortunately.

 

[Ambrosia]

1 Selwood
2 Kennedy
3 Gray
4 Reiwoldt
5 Goldstien
6 Hawkins
7 Boak
8 Jacobs
9 N Smith
10 Gibbs
11 Frawley
12 Reid
13 Westhoff
14 Tippett
15 Edwards
16 Harbrow
17 Grigg
18 Armitage
19 MacKenzie
20 Lonergan

Not a Gibbs fan?