2009 All-Australian Team

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Cyril Rioli is one of the most over rated players! How can anyone have him ahead of Betts or Milne.
He is overrated if people and the media consider him a top 20 player in the league this season. The herald sun had him in the top 5 at the half way point, what a joke. However, he is ahead of Milne and Betts. Rioli has been more effective around the F50 then those two.
 
He is overrated if people and the media consider him a top 20 player in the league this season. The herald sun had him in the top 5 at the half way point, what a joke. However, he is ahead of Milne and Betts. Rioli has been more effective around the F50 then those two.

Milne yes, Betts no.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

For the first few rounds I did. I never had him in the side, but Enright, Goddard, Drummond, Davey, and Duffield are definitely ahead.

Bower is ahead of all of them (he'd be just as at home rebounding off the HBF as he would playing on a key forward).

That he would. :thumbsu:

Ladies and gentlemen, here is your winner, and the new WWE World Heavyweight Champion... Delicious Cyril!
 
Bower is ahead of all of them (he'd be just as at home rebounding off the HBF as he would playing on a key forward).
BOwer is very overrated in most of his games this year. He has not stopped the oppostion's forward that he played on and has just drifted into one on one contests and taken the easy mark. He gets easy touches on the half back line. When carlton played wce earlier in the year, he played on Lecras. although he got 30 touches, he got 6 goals kicked against him and didnt really have an impact on the game.
 
I really like the debate going on the AA Team.
I really don't see any reason why Both Presti and Bock couldn't be in the starting team.
My best back 6 at this stage would be
Scarlett, Presti, Gilbert
Drummond, Bock , Tarrant.

But I love the healthy debate all!
 
I really like the debate going on the AA Team.
I really don't see any reason why Both Presti and Bock couldn't be in the starting team.
My best back 6 at this stage would be
Scarlett, Presti, Gilbert
Drummond, Bock , Tarrant.

But I love the healthy debate all!
They could both be in at the end of the season. Fisher, Bolton and Tarrant are ahead of Bock at CHB. I don't think you can have 4 key defenders in your back 6 though. Enright or Goddard should be on the other HBF.
 
BOwer is very overrated in most of his games this year. He has not stopped the oppostion's forward that he played on and has just drifted into one on one contests and taken the easy mark. He gets easy touches on the half back line. When carlton played wce earlier in the year, he played on Lecras. although he got 30 touches, he got 6 goals kicked against him and didnt really have an impact on the game.
Bower has been good overall. Stopped Franklin and Pavlich. Stopped Riewoldt in the 2nd half. He has stopped some big players and has improved a lot this season. Bower is normally on an opponent so I'm not sure about the easy marks/touches statement. If anyone, that was Waite before he got injured.
 
BOwer is very overrated in most of his games this year. He has not stopped the oppostion's forward that he played on and has just drifted into one on one contests and taken the easy mark. He gets easy touches on the half back line. When carlton played wce earlier in the year, he played on Lecras. although he got 30 touches, he got 6 goals kicked against him and didnt really have an impact on the game.

Bower kept Buddy to 2 goals, both of which came in the final QTR.

He kept Pavlich goal-less (when Pav was in the forward line)

He wasn't on LeCras for all of the 6 goals, Jamison played on LeCras for 2 or 3 of them.
 
Bower has been good overall. Stopped Franklin and Pavlich. Stopped Riewoldt in the 2nd half. He has stopped some big players and has improved a lot this season. Bower is normally on an opponent so I'm not sure about the easy marks/touches statement. If anyone, that was Waite before he got injured.

You're too good.

Yarran demands that Bower get in your team.
 
My team overall:
B: Drummond Scarlett Goddard
HB: Ray Presti Lovett
C: J. Selwood Montagna Swan
HF: S.Johnson Reiwoldt Davis
F: Roughead Fevola LeCras
Foll: McIntosh G. Ablett Judd
Inter: Pendlebury Cox Goodes Dal Santo
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top