2009 club best and fairests

[STC]

Probably:
1. Joel Selwood
2. Gary Ablett
3. Corey Enright
4. Paul Chapman
5. Matthew Scarlett
6. Joel Corey
7. Jimmy Bartel
8. Cameron Ling
9. Steve Johnson
10. Andrew Mackie

 

[FRUMPY]

1. Murphy
2. Judd
3. Simpson
4. Gibbs
5. Fev
6. Thornton
7. Betts
8. Bower
9. Kruezer
10. Joseph

 

[POPE]

Black
Rich
Brown
Clark
Drummond
Sherman
Bradshaw
Power
Adcock
Patfull

 

[LordJimmy]

Can a mod yellow card anyone who picks Riewoldt as St Kilda's best player this year?

That being said,

1. Lenny Hayes
2. Leigh Montagna
3. Brendon Goddard
4. Nick Dal Santo
5. Sam Gilbert
6. Nick Riewoldt
7. Michael Gardiner
8. Clinton Jones
9. Sam Fisher
10. Stephen Milne

 

[Tiger Battler]

1. Brett Deledio
2. Daniel Jackson
3. Richard Tambling
4. Ben Cousins
5. Shane Tuck
6. Chris Newman
7. Luke McGuane
8. Nathan Foley
9. Mitch Morton
10. Jack Riewoldt

 

[prattsta]

Sandilands
Tarrant
Duffield
Haselby
Pavlich
Broughton
Schammer
Mundy
Dodd
Suban

1. Sandilands
2. Tarrant
3. Pavlich
4. Duffield
5. Hasleby
6. Mundy
7. Schammer
8. Broughton (Only playing the 14 games will stop him finishing higher)
9. Ibbotson
10. Dodd

Hill has had 2-3 more standout games than Suban, he should finish higher in the voting. Deservedly as well.

Grover and Solomon will both come close. Despite missing several games they generally do all the dirty work that coaches like (Dodd is in the same boat).

 

[WCE Ebert #18]

1. M LeCras
2. A Selwood
3. S Hurn
4. D Glass
5. M Priddis
6. J Kennedy
7. A Embley
8. M Rosa
9. Q Lynch
10. D Cox

 

[Alatna]

Can a mod yellow card anyone who picks Riewoldt as St Kilda's best player this year?

That being said,

1. Lenny Hayes
2. Leigh Montagna
3. Brendon Goddard
4. Nick Dal Santo
5. Sam Gilbert
6. Nick Riewoldt
7. Michael Gardiner
8. Clinton Jones
9. Sam Fisher
10. Stephen Milne

Eh?

May not win it, but he'll finish at least top 5.

 

[AG]

Eh?

May not win it, but he'll finish at least top 5.

Haha, as if you take LJ seriously. He said it would be criminal if Milne doesn't make the AA team.

 

[Alatna]

Haha, as if you take LJ seriously. He said it would be criminal if Milne doesn't make the AA team.

 

[DOCKER MAN]

1. Sandilands
2. Duffield
3. Tarrant
4. Pavlich
5. Haselby
6. Broughton
7. Ibbotson
8. Mundy
9. Shammer
10. Hill

 

[UpForGrabs]

1. Adam Selwood
2. Mark LeCras
3. Darren Glass
4. Matt Priddis
5. Matt Rosa
6. Quinten Lynch
7. Shannon Hurn
8. Dean Cox
9. Josh Kennedy
10. Andrew Embley

Hurn too low.

 

[DonMania#5]

1. Watson
2. Lovett
3. Ryder
4. Stanton
5. Fletcher
6. Pears
7. Winderlich
8. Dempsey
9. Mcphee
10. Dyson

 

[SwanBet]

1. Dane Swan
2. Scott Pendlebury
3. Leon Davis
4. Alan Didak
5. Nick Maxwell
6. Harry Obrien
7. Simon Presti
8. Shane Obree
9. Josh Fraser
10. Heath Shaw

Dane Swan no doubt to take out our b&f, pendlebury should get his 3rd top 3 finish ahead of didak and davis who have missed a few each, davis and didak hard to split, dids played more b.o.gs but davis more consistent and more games. Maxwell, harry and presti great seasons and seeing how in b and f counts backmen actually get recognised they will be up there. Cheesey Obree will feature from 8 - 10 due to paying every game imo one of only a few and this will help. Fraser was blistering early in the year and will get aolt of votes then and shaw has been in great form since the half way mark.
Beams making a late run may finish in the top 10 for any one ranked 7 - 10.

 

[robertg22]

1. Dane Swan
2. Scott Pendlebury
3. Leon Davis
4. Alan Didak
5. Nick Maxwell
6. Harry Obrien
7. Simon Presti
8. Shane Obree
9. Josh Fraser
10. Heath Shaw

Dane Swan no doubt to take out our b&f, pendlebury should get his 3rd top 3 finish ahead of didak and davis who have missed a few each, davis and didak hard to split, dids played more b.o.gs but davis more consistent and more games. Maxwell, harry and presti great seasons and seeing how in b and f counts backmen actually get recognised they will be up there. Cheesey Obree will feature from 8 - 10 due to paying every game imo one of only a few and this will help. Fraser was blistering early in the year and will get aolt of votes then and shaw has been in great form since the half way mark.
Beams making a late run may finish in the top 10 for any one ranked 7 - 10.

Our b&f is heavily weightwed towards players who don't miss games, based on that Josh won't be top 10. Though finals are included, so if he dominates you never know.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Surely for the spud teams like mine - a top 3 would suffice

1. Selwood, A
2. LeCras, M
3. Hurn, S

Raffle the rest

 

[RM_3]

Lovett and Watson to draw for Essendon.

 

[damochandler]

1. watson
2. lovett
3. ryder

 

[scooter22]

1 A Selwood
2 Mark LeCras
3 Shannon Hurn
4 Darren Glass
5 Quinten Lynch
6 Chris Masten
7 Matt Pridis
8 Josh kennedy
9 Matt Rosa
10 Andrew Embley

 

[Thommo 42]

Swan will win ours, not just because he has had a great year - but because his nearest opponents in Didak, Shaw, Maxwell, Davis have all missed 3 or more games.

Bit of a lottery really, as Presti and Harry O deserve to be up in the votes too.

 

[Sandi2Palmer]

1. Sandilands - AA ruckman
2. Tarrant - We're all shocked
3. Pavlich - Expected
4. Duffield - Nice Surprise
5. Hasleby - 1 more year
6. Mundy - Should be at the top with his ability
7. Schammer - Trade value
8. Suban - Will terrorise the comp in 2 years
9. Ibbotson - Hasn't come on as I thought he would
10. Dodd - Shows you how little depth we have

 

[Duskfire]

Enright
Selwood
Ablett
Chapman
Scarlett
Johnson
Mackie
Bartel
Corey
Rooke

 

[Juddy88]

1. Lecca
2. Selwood
3. Hurn
4. Glass
5. Priddis
6. Lynch
7. Cox
8. JK
9. Embley
10. Masten

 

[NTRabbit]

1. Simon Goodwin
2. Scott Thompson
3. Bernie Vince
4. Graham Johncock
5. Michael Doughty
6. Tyson Edwards
7. Jason Porplyzia
8. Kurt Tippett
9. Chris Knights
10. Ben Rutten

 

[jonoman89]

1) Murphy
2) Judd
3) Thornton
4) Fevola
5) Betts
6) Simpson
7) Gibbs
8) Bower
9) Joseph
10) Kreuzer