2011 Captains Mega Thread (Part 1)

[Knighta21]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

According to the HS's final teams he is now an emergency. Unfortunetly.

Owell, can still cover him.
Thinking of making a last minute switch and going Buddy captain, no real difference between him and cox i belelive.

 

[Big Fozza]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Lower out means i have no back cover.... Not happy

 

[Headless]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Lower out means i have no back cover.... Not happy

Assuming you have Sandilands, this could be a blessing in disguise should the big man not get up.

I'm trying to work out whether it's worth having Smith or Petrie as an emergency to cover Sandilands who is in some doubt or not..

 

[Vinnieee]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Don't have Swan, so who should I pick?

Pendlebury vs Cox vs Franklin vs Rioli

Gut feel says to go with a Hawk down in Tassie.

Likeiwse, My gut is telling me to go with Rioli so that's the way I'm going to go.

 

[Tetris]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Which two to play on field and which to have as emergency out of Heppell, Curnow, Harris and Swallow?
ATM I have Heppell and Curnow on field with Swallow as emergency...

Also, Should I have Stanley as emergency in the backline, or no emergency with Smith as emergency in the ruck?

Thoughts appreciated...

 

[illnino]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Which two to play on field and which to have as emergency out of Heppell, Curnow, Harris and Swallow?
ATM I have Heppell and Curnow on field with Swallow as emergency...

Also, Should I have Stanley as emergency in the backline, or no emergency with Smith as emergency in the ruck?

Thoughts appreciated...

I'd probably be tempted to go with Harris and Curnow with Swallow as the emergency. In saying that, Heppell is the only one of those 4 whose in my side and I'm quite happy with him....Really is a 50/50 call but Heppell misses out of your side for mine.

Cox or Buddy for captain? Have Pendles and even Fyfe as a smokey over there against the Roos in mind too.....? Appreciate some thoughts

 

[cooneyman]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

who would you start out of Matera and Richardon?

 

[Tetris]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

I'd probably be tempted to go with Harris and Curnow with Swallow as the emergency. In saying that, Heppell is the only one of those 4 whose in my side and I'm quite happy with him....Really is a 50/50 call but Heppell misses out of your side for mine.

Cox or Buddy for captain? Have Pendles and even Fyfe as a smokey over there against the Roos in mind too.....? Appreciate some thoughts

Thanks, I've decided on Curnow and Harris with Heppell as emergency.

I actually have Swan and am still tempted to go Buddy captain, so i would say him...

 

[toxic]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

who would you start out of Matera and Richardon?

richo richo man

 

[coryne]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Put your hand up if you have Swan and DIDN'T make make him captain (and are now regretting it).


Myself, Swan (c) all the way

 

[Ed D]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Put your hand up if you have Swan and DIDN'T make make him captain (and are now regretting it).


Myself, Swan (c) all the way

Wow, would take some different thinking to not have Swan C if you had him.

If it wasn't for a quiet 3rd qtr he might have got 200!

 

[rhaz]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Dont have Swan, stuck with Franklin as captain for the second week in a row and he just kicked his sixth goal. Happy.

146 points... not bad not bad

 

[Headless]

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

Dont have Swan, stuck with Franklin as captain for the second week in a row and he just kicked his sixth goal. Happy.

146 points... not bad not bad

Don't have Swan, was tempted by Franklin and particularly Pendlebury, but went with Cox.

Paying big time.

 

[Team Mo']

Re: Round 4 Captain and Emergencies

God dang! Changed Pendulbury to Cox with about 20 minutes to go before lock out. Kill me now!

 

[IDIG]

Round 7 Captain

Our perma-capt gets a rest this week and us shmucks finally have a decision to make

Poll coming.

EDIT: Forgot Chappy, averages 122 v NM last 5

 

[kreuze_missile]

Re: Round 7 Captain

Joel Selwood (C) for me.

 

[Impromptu]

Re: Round 7 Captain

ROFL at naming Goodes/ROK after this weekend..

Franklin v Port looking juicy

 

[Daniels]

Re: Round 7 Captain

Franklin v Port looking juicy

Agreed. Only downside Fri night @ AAMI the ground will prob have that dodgey dew / wetness on ground...

 

[Super Hans]

Re: Round 7 Captain

Selwood/Sandilands are leading the way so far, probs Sandi!

 

[1989]

Re: Round 7 Captain

Agreed. Only downside Fri night @ AAMI the ground will prob have that dodgey dew / wetness on ground...

It shouldn't worry him. He scored 140 odd in the wet against Richmond a few weeks ago.

I wouldn't hesitate sticking the captaincy on him if I knew he wasn't going to give away 25 free kicks.

 

[GotTheGoodes]

Re: Round 7 Captain

If I had Selwood or Bartel then I'd lock them in after their break this week and against the Roos... They will go BANG!

But since I don't have either, I think Sandi (after his break) against the tigers ruck looks pretty good too and is probably where I'll go.

 

[CrazyEighty8]

Re: Round 7 Captain

The suns to bounce back next week and lose within 100pts to the lions.

GAJ to lead and score 120+.

 

[Koutafidamedis]

Re: Round 7 Captain

chapman or sandi for me

 

[Daniels]

Re: Round 7 Captain

It shouldn't worry him. He scored 140 odd in the wet against Richmond a few weeks ago.

I wouldn't hesitate sticking the captaincy on him if I knew he wasn't going to give away 25 free kicks.

True, fair call.

 

[TigerGlory]

Re: Round 7 Captain

Dane Swan.

Wait... bye...?