-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Discussion 2011 Jumper Suggestion
- Thread starter just_kick_it
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Mr Eagle
Bird-brain
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
What I would do:
Adelaide: Home - Same. Clash - It's horrible but clash does the job.
Brisbane: Home - Same. Clash - Same as home but with white.
Carlton: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Collingwood: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Essendon: Home - Same. Clash - Black sash on red.
Fremantle: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Geelong: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Hawthorn: Home - Same. Clash - Needs to be either mostly white or mostly brown. White front with a brown back as it is now complicates things.
Melbourne: Home - Same. Clash - Red with filled blue V.
North Melbourne: Home - Same. Clash - Blue with white V.
Port Adelaide: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Richmond: Home - Same. Clash - Inverted black sash on yellow.
St Kilda: Home - Same. Clash - Same (I'd like to see the red and black go round to the back though).
Sydney: Home - Same but with white back. Clash - Same but red and white swapped.
West Coast: Home - Royal Blue with yellow wings. Clash - Yellow with royal wings.
Bulldogs: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
This would solve all clashes.
What I would do:
Adelaide: Home - Same. Clash - It's horrible but clash does the job.
Brisbane: Home - Same. Clash - Same as home but with white.
Carlton: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Collingwood: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Essendon: Home - Same. Clash - Black sash on red.
Fremantle: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Geelong: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Hawthorn: Home - Same. Clash - Needs to be either mostly white or mostly brown. White front with a brown back as it is now complicates things.
Melbourne: Home - Same. Clash - Red with filled blue V.
North Melbourne: Home - Same. Clash - Blue with white V.
Port Adelaide: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
Richmond: Home - Same. Clash - Inverted black sash on yellow.
St Kilda: Home - Same. Clash - Same (I'd like to see the red and black go round to the back though).
Sydney: Home - Same but with white back. Clash - Same but red and white swapped.
West Coast: Home - Royal Blue with yellow wings. Clash - Yellow with royal wings.
Bulldogs: Home - Same. Clash - Same.
This would solve all clashes.
- Jun 28, 2010
- 552
- 4
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Banned
- #55
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
They should be making the bloody Gold Coast style their jumpers to fit in with the existing teams!! Stuff em
Having said that, some really good ideas.
On that sydney clash one, couldnt GC go majority yellow or blue so the reds of both teams wouldnt clash? And maybe keep the red banding around arms and neck, that wouldnt clash with the swans ones, especially if GC was yellow.
They should be making the bloody Gold Coast style their jumpers to fit in with the existing teams!! Stuff em
Having said that, some really good ideas.
On that sydney clash one, couldnt GC go majority yellow or blue so the reds of both teams wouldnt clash? And maybe keep the red banding around arms and neck, that wouldnt clash with the swans ones, especially if GC was yellow.
lionsman_16
Rookie
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
true and i know the public would love it, but the afl might not
true and i know the public would love it, but the afl might not
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
What I would like to see next year is Fremantle to bring back the three v's heritage design they have used. Use that design with a purple base and white v's as a home jumper and the inverse for a clash jumper. Like their training jumpers for this year. It gets rid of the anchor and the unneccesary green and red.
What I would like to see next year is Fremantle to bring back the three v's heritage design they have used. Use that design with a purple base and white v's as a home jumper and the inverse for a clash jumper. Like their training jumpers for this year. It gets rid of the anchor and the unneccesary green and red.
- Moderator
- #58
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
2011 - should be Purple Haze as the home, and the white strip as the away/clash
The anchor has become synonymous with Freo and to see it go would be a step back IMO.
2011 - should be Purple Haze as the home, and the white strip as the away/clash
- May 25, 2009
- 4,039
- 2,801
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Thread starter
- #60
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
Id say the same thing about the colours aswell. I wouldnt like to see Freo drop the red and green, they do look better in the purple haze but not enough better IMO to warrant going to just two colours. The odd mismatch of colours is something I would also like to see Freo sick with as home colours.
Yep I agree with on the anchor issue. As much as Id prefer the tradional triple vee over the anchor, Ive gotten used to the anchor running out week after week.The anchor has become synonymous with Freo and to see it go would be a step back IMO.
2011 - should be Purple Haze as the home, and the white strip as the away/clash
Id say the same thing about the colours aswell. I wouldnt like to see Freo drop the red and green, they do look better in the purple haze but not enough better IMO to warrant going to just two colours. The odd mismatch of colours is something I would also like to see Freo sick with as home colours.
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
The current St Kilda home jumper has been criticised for the disparity between the front and back. The current clash jumper, while generally appreciated as a clash jumper, is quite bland.
The first jumper above is a compromise between the current two designs.
The second jumper creates a more symmetrical design with a mirrored version of the current home jumper.
The third jumper is another possible clash jumper.
St Kilda Saints 2011
The current St Kilda home jumper has been criticised for the disparity between the front and back. The current clash jumper, while generally appreciated as a clash jumper, is quite bland.
The first jumper above is a compromise between the current two designs.
The second jumper creates a more symmetrical design with a mirrored version of the current home jumper.
The third jumper is another possible clash jumper.
Omegaville
Club Legend
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
This design kicks butt
The second jumper creates a more symmetrical design with a mirrored version of the current home jumper.
This design kicks butt
Sports Guru
Rookie
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
@Alex3549: Come on man! They’ll look like jokers in it … lolx it should have rather been in some mixture of colors, what do you say?
@Alex3549: Come on man! They’ll look like jokers in it … lolx it should have rather been in some mixture of colors, what do you say?
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
Don't intend on being rude or dumb! but what do you mean?? lol
Don't intend on being rude or dumb! but what do you mean?? lol
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
The first design is relatively the same as the current Richmond jumper.
An inverted clash design (yellow with a black sash) sounds good in theory, but ends up looking like a WA State of Origin jumper. Instead, the second design has a single vertical stripe. This design may seem reminiscent of Carlton's 1998 pre-season jumper, but it does have some elements of Richmond history. The first Richmond jumper from 1908-9 had vertical stripes; this was followed from 1910 to 1913 by jumpers with a single stripe. Both of these elements are represented in the predominantly yellow jumper.
The third jumper is predominantly white, but features the sash of the first jumper.
Any comments? More teams to come...
Richmond Tigers 2011
The first design is relatively the same as the current Richmond jumper.
An inverted clash design (yellow with a black sash) sounds good in theory, but ends up looking like a WA State of Origin jumper. Instead, the second design has a single vertical stripe. This design may seem reminiscent of Carlton's 1998 pre-season jumper, but it does have some elements of Richmond history. The first Richmond jumper from 1908-9 had vertical stripes; this was followed from 1910 to 1913 by jumpers with a single stripe. Both of these elements are represented in the predominantly yellow jumper.
The third jumper is predominantly white, but features the sash of the first jumper.
Any comments? More teams to come...
Omegaville
Club Legend
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
Away jumper, no way would Richmond ever get that past the supporters - my first thought too was that it's based on a Carlton jumper! Wouldn't mind seeing a horizontal bar though, like the 1910 jumper, but of course black bar on yellow.
Clash jumper isn't too bad. Definitely a design the club should look at.
Away jumper, no way would Richmond ever get that past the supporters - my first thought too was that it's based on a Carlton jumper! Wouldn't mind seeing a horizontal bar though, like the 1910 jumper, but of course black bar on yellow.
Clash jumper isn't too bad. Definitely a design the club should look at.
- May 25, 2009
- 4,039
- 2,801
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Thread starter
- #67
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
Do think any clubs care what fans think about what jumpers they wear. Take Adelaide's clash for example nobody likes that and Brisbane's new designs everybody hates those aswell.
Do think any clubs care what fans think about what jumpers they wear. Take Adelaide's clash for example nobody likes that and Brisbane's new designs everybody hates those aswell.
Omegaville
Club Legend
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
In the case of Richmond, yes! The two proposed clash jumper designs were put to a vote of members (conducted online).
I'm pretty sure Essendon would consult their members too, given that their club's constitution defines the jumper... Collingwood would be loath to change their design radically without consulting the fans.
In the case of Richmond, yes! The two proposed clash jumper designs were put to a vote of members (conducted online).
I'm pretty sure Essendon would consult their members too, given that their club's constitution defines the jumper... Collingwood would be loath to change their design radically without consulting the fans.
- Jun 28, 2010
- 552
- 4
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Banned
- #69
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
I think majority of the time it comes down to sponsors - especially with the interstate teams that dont have the heritage of the jumpers that the victorian teams do - oh and North Melbourne...
I think majority of the time it comes down to sponsors - especially with the interstate teams that dont have the heritage of the jumpers that the victorian teams do - oh and North Melbourne...
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
There's not much to be improved on with Port's jumpers. I tried a mostly teal jumper just as another clash option but realistically it's unnecessary.
Port Adelaide 2011
There's not much to be improved on with Port's jumpers. I tried a mostly teal jumper just as another clash option but realistically it's unnecessary.
- May 25, 2009
- 4,039
- 2,801
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Thread starter
- #71
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
Its not like anyone is going to change their tradional home designs, except Collingwood, they might add a few sponsor template lines to wrech their jumper even more. Away/clash designs are more a cash grab and to draw in the young kids, that is only going to be used for 3 years max, then they can design a new jumper to get more people to buy it.
Im guessing you dont count over 30 years of the Fizroy/Brisbane lion as a logo and over 10 years of this logo on a jumper as heritage then. Its good to clear that up then.I think majority of the time it comes down to sponsors - especially with the interstate teams that dont have the heritage of the jumpers that the victorian teams do - oh and North Melbourne...
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
I think it looks better with the black side panels actuallyPort Adelaide 2011
There's not much to be improved on with Port's jumpers. I tried a mostly teal jumper just as another clash option but realistically it's unnecessary.
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
North's home jumper is great and the current clash jumper is definitely not one of worst clash jumpers in the league at the moment. However, I think it would be better to return to a jumper similar to the clash jumper of 2007-8, which was based on North Melbourne's original jumper in the VFL. Not only does it maintain the royal blue, it better deals with clashes with other teams with stripes (Collingwood, Geelong). The white jumper with the blue vee provides a light clash option.
North Melbourne Kangaroos 2011
North's home jumper is great and the current clash jumper is definitely not one of worst clash jumpers in the league at the moment. However, I think it would be better to return to a jumper similar to the clash jumper of 2007-8, which was based on North Melbourne's original jumper in the VFL. Not only does it maintain the royal blue, it better deals with clashes with other teams with stripes (Collingwood, Geelong). The white jumper with the blue vee provides a light clash option.
Re: 2011 Jumper Discussion
The anchor is WAY more unique than 3 V's. It's not as if Freo are in any sort of membership crisis like Port and Brisbane so they have no reason to make any drastic changes to their jumper. I prefer the purple haze to their home jumper but a lot of their supporters feel strongly about it so I'd leave it to them to decide.
The V's definitely shouldn't b used though as the Fremantle team that wore them has nothing to do with the new Fremantle except for their names.
The anchor is WAY more unique than 3 V's. It's not as if Freo are in any sort of membership crisis like Port and Brisbane so they have no reason to make any drastic changes to their jumper. I prefer the purple haze to their home jumper but a lot of their supporters feel strongly about it so I'd leave it to them to decide.
The V's definitely shouldn't b used though as the Fremantle team that wore them has nothing to do with the new Fremantle except for their names.
