Draft Review 2011 - Redo the 2011 AFL Draft

[Chaisa]

To say that he's anywhere near Wingard and Talia is just.... idk what to say.
Hill is an outside runner where as ellis is an inside mid, Hill doesnt even need that many possessions to be effective, so suggesting a comparison of their stats is quite proposterous. Ellis a good player, but if the draft is held today, he still wouldn't be top 5.
1. Wingard
2. Talia
3. Patton
4. Tyson
5. Mitchell
6. Hill
7. Ellis
8. Conigilio
9.Greene
10. Smith

Again, the Talia drafted in this draft is not Adelaide's Talia. The Talia drafted here can't make the Dogs side.....

 

[Shaneprice97]

Ellis number 1 for mine.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Wingard
Ellis
Tyson
Hill
Neale
Greene
Smith
Patton
Coniglio
Sutcliffe

 

[beetz]

1. Wingard
2. Tyson
3. Mitchell
4. Ellis
5. Greene
6. Hill
7. Newnes
8. Rowe
9. Neale
10. Blicavs

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

I'd have no problem with taking Patton #1 again.

 

[Stylo]

To say that he's anywhere near Wingard and Talia is just.... idk what to say.
Hill is an outside runner where as ellis is an inside mid, Hill doesnt even need that many possessions to be effective, so suggesting a comparison of their stats is quite proposterous. Ellis a good player, but if the draft is held today, he still wouldn't be top 5.
1. Wingard
2. Talia
3. Patton
4. Tyson
5. Mitchell
6. Hill
7. Ellis
8. Conigilio
9.Greene
10. Smith

Yeh. NFI.

 

[Heaps of fun]

I'd have no problem with taking Patton #1 again.

What about now?

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

What about now?

Yeah, all class, mate...must be proud of that post.

 

[coniglio_number1]

Really? Because list managers know about injuries several years down the track.

 

[cotter101]

1. C Wingard
2. D Tyson
3. B Ellis
4. T Mitchell
5. J Patton
6. L Neale
7. D Smith
9. B Hill
9. J. Clarke
10. J Newnes

Wingard, Tyson and Ellis are pretty well equal. Can't really split them.

 

[Hounddd]

The order I would take these players, with hindsight:

1. Wingard (pure class, match winner personified)
2. Ellis (ball winning machine, hits 40m lasers on both beet)
3. Tyson (class ball winner, who can finish)
4. Devon Smith (class half forward type, could be #1 if he can push into the middle more)
5. Patton (could be an absolute monster FF)
6. Hill (freak engine)
7. Mitchell (contested ball winning bull)
8. Coniglio (accumulator, can play inside or outside, with great skills)
9. Neale (underrated severely outside WA
10. Clarke (big fan, got all the tools to be a gun CHB)

Edit: forgot WHE, he is a deadset gun! For me he sits behind Patton at 6 with everyone moving down accordingly.. his ceiling is so high

 

[Ambrosia]

I know no side would waste a top 10 pick on him due to age but Mark Baguley is a genuine gun and would push Nick Smith as the best lock down back pocket in the comp.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

I know no side would waste a top 10 pick on him due to age but Mark Baguley is a genuine gun and would push Nick Smith as the best lock down back pocket in the comp.

Lol no

 

[Zach Package]

Lol no

7th most games from the draft class almost gets him up in and round the top 20 on it's own for mine.

guy's will obviously go past him as they develop because most of them are 5-6 years younger than him, but on output he just has to be in the conversation

 

[Moist Biscuit]

7th most games from the draft class almost gets him up in and round the top 20 on it's own for mine.

guy's will obviously go past him as they develop because most of them are 5-6 years younger than him, but on output he just has to be in the conversation

I said lol no about the nick smith comment.

 

[Ambrosia]

Lol no

Have you watched him this year he's been great and has only really clearly been beaten once by my count and has gone from only being good against crumbing types to having the ability to play on marking small forwards as well

 

[Tiger Titus]

This thread really highlights to me how difficult/unfair it is to compare talls to smalls in the short term.

3 years on and facing his second serious knee injury I would still take Patton at number 1. I reckon in five years he'll be a bigger, better Jarryd Roughead, and I think there's a fair argument to be made that Roughead should have gone at 1 in his draft (yep, even ahead of Buddy). Tall monsters that can play everywhere are worth their weight in gold.

I would go:
1. Patton
2. Wingard
3. Tyson/Ellis
4. Ellis/Tyson
5. Brad Hill
6. Lachie Neale
7. Hoskin-Elliott
8. Devon Smith
9. Coniglio
10. Mitchell

I reckon Sam Rowe might be top 20 of this draft but he was mature aged.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Have you watched him this year he's been great and has only really clearly been beaten once by my count and has gone from only being good against crumbing types to having the ability to play on marking small forwards as well

Didn't he play on Cripps on the weekend?

 

[Ambrosia]

Didn't he play on Cripps on the weekend?

Yeah among others. He spent time on all of Darling, Cripps, Naitanui and Hill

 

[calumhfc]

I'm not including rookie picks so sorry Clarke,Laird, Williams, Cunningham

1:Wingard
2:Tyson
3:Ellis
4:Hill
5:Smith
6:Coniglio
7:Hoskin-Elliot
8:Greene
9:Neale
10: Patton

Unlucky ones are: Adams, Docherty, Mitchell, Merrett, Newnes, Murdoch

 

[Bailey01]

1. Chad Wingard
2. Dom Tyson
3. Bradley Hill
4. Toby Greene
5. Brandon Ellis
6. Stephen Coniglio
7. Devon Smith
8. Lachie Neale
9. Cameron Sutcliffe
10. Taylor Adams
11. Tom Mitchell
12. Will Hoskin Elliott
13. Adam Tomlinson
14. Jack Newnes
15. Sam Kerridge
16. Nick Haynes
17. Sam Rowe
18. Jordan Murdoch
19. Elliott Yeo
20. Sam Docherty

 

[Groupie_]

Tiges got the steal of the draft

 

[Moist Biscuit]

1. Chad Wingard
2. Dom Tyson
3. Bradley Hill
4. Toby Greene
5. Brandon Ellis
6. Stephen Coniglio
7. Devon Smith
8. Lachie Neale
9. Cameron Sutcliffe
10. Taylor Adams
11. Tom Mitchell
12. Will Hoskin Elliott
13. Adam Tomlinson
14. Jack Newnes
15. Sam Kerridge
16. Nick Haynes
17. Sam Rowe
18. Jordan Murdoch
19. Elliott Yeo
20. Sam Docherty

Nice to see Sutcliffe get some recognition, is very unknown outside of freo.

 

[Bailey01]

Tiges got the steal of the draft

Who is that? Freo got Neale at #58

 

[Bailey01]

Nice to see Sutcliffe get some recognition, is very unknown outside of freo.

Yea he's a very good role player.