Maybe. I think it is relevant (whether or not a guy can get a game), in terms of judging his effectiveness.
I don’t think Bellchambers was every really in and out of the side was he? If so, I see it more as a function of his age and our list. He’s now well and truly overtaken Hille and won’t be dropped again, barring a huge dip in form. He’s solid best 22 at Essendon, and would be at Hawthorn as well.
Pears, on his 2012 form, isn’t best 22 at Hawthorn or Essendon. He’s in truly horrible knick. Hopefully he recovers.
I think the thing with either of them is there’s extenuating situations for both – Pears may get a game at Hawthorn (on 2012 form), but only because they lacked key defenders, not based on his performances. His performances were terrible. For TBC, we simply had a relatively strong ruck division (Ryder and Hille), which is all that ever really stopped him getting games.
You could extend the same outlook to Young at Hawthorn, if say they had a very weak midfield, therefore he’s getting games on the back of that. But it’s not the case – if anything they have a strong midfield.
Conversely, ours is weak, and Dyson still can’t get a game.
This is the thing. Their midfield is not as good as it is given credit for. I'd go as far as saying that their midfield core is hardly better than ours. They are just as one paced as we are without the young ball carriers, have more proven inside players but, and it is a key but, their defensive structure and ability to retain the ball is what protects them and enables them to dictate the pace of a game.
Hawthorn's ball carriers are average at best, especially when the ball isn't frequently in Cyril's hands. It is in exploiting this weakness that Adelaide and Sydney bridged the supposedly insurmountable gap. It wasn't about being the Bloods, or courageous or unselfish, harder at the contest or any other ill considered cliche, the reality is that if you can keep the contest on the outside Hawthorn struggle to keep up.
In this respect Clinton Young is a vital player to the proper balance of their team (just as Zaharakis is to ours) because he is one of their few good ball carriers.