2013 Player/s X versus Y

[Krujan]

Cotchin - proving time and time again he can handle a tag - amazing footballer even tho is dressed in a yellow and black dress!

Am I mental for considering a luxury sideways trade of Murphy > Cotchin this week? ...I'm pretty set with my rookies ATM and the price difference between them is only 43k which barely puts a dint in the kitty...

 

[Kadog]

Definitely Gingy

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Am I mental for considering a luxury sideways trade of Murphy > Cotchin this week? ...I'm pretty set with my rookies ATM and the price difference between them is only 43k which barely puts a dint in the kitty...

Yeah, it's crazy!
I think Dangerfield and Cotchin will average about the same from here until the end of the year. Dangerfield was off the field due to a blood nose for a vital part of the game against Port last week and was sick the first week..

 

[toxic]

Am I mental for considering a luxury sideways trade of Murphy > Cotchin this week? ...I'm pretty set with my rookies ATM and the price difference between them is only 43k which barely puts a dint in the kitty...

Gingy - i think deep in your soft centred ginger bread heart you know its complete madness - find other problems to fix - keep the Murphy, he'll fly over in the west this weekend

 

[Patty Healey]

Gingy - i think deep in your soft centred ginger bread heart you know its complete madness - find other problems to fix - keep the Murphy, he'll fly over in the west this weekend

Could not agree more, those considering offloading M.Murphy will do so at their own peril.

MARK MY WORDS - He will be one of the highest scoring SC players come years end.

 

[Krujan]

Definitely Gingy

Yeah, it's crazy!
I think Dangerfield and Cotchin will average about the same from here until the end of the year. Dangerfield was off the field due to a blood nose for a vital part of the game against Port last week and was sick the first week..

Gingy - i think deep in your soft centred ginger bread heart you know its complete madness - find other problems to fix - keep the Murphy, he'll fly over in the west this weekend

Could not agree more, those considering offloading M.Murphy will do so at their own peril.

MARK MY WORDS - He will be one of the highest scoring SC players come years end.

Thanks for the feedback guys. I was hoping someone would make me see sense. Much appreciated, I will stick fat with Murph.

That's the problem with having extra trades this year. If the rest of your side is pretty much spot on and your cash cows are still weeks away from mooing, you can feel like you should be doing something else to improve your team, because you can with extra trades at hand.

I'm sure that extra trade that I will have up my sleeve for not doing this sideways trade will come in very handy in the final round or two.

 

[jonesy03]

Looking to offload P Karnezis for someone cheaper. could go with Crozier, Lee or someone else, thoughts?

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Looking to offload P Karnezis for someone cheaper. could go with Crozier, Lee or someone else, thoughts?

Mayes?

 

[Krujan]

Looking to offload P Karnezis for someone cheaper. could go with Crozier, Lee or someone else, thoughts?

Rowe & Sinclair both on the bubble this week..

 

[Patty Healey]

Mayes?

Ditto what he said, Mayes or Rowe if you don't already have.

 

[Embleberry]

Westhoff, Monfries or Lecras. All purely for their cash potential so you can hopefully do a straight upgrade to a prem.

 

[Patty Healey]

Westhoff, Monfries or Lecras. All purely for their cash potential so you can hopefully do a straight upgrade to a prem.

LeCras, cheapest of all 3 and should average the highest by years end IMO.

He has the most upside after coming off injury as well he will only get better.

 

[Krujan]

LeCras, cheapest of all 3 and should average the highest by years end IMO.

He has the most upside after coming off injury as well he will only get better.

That's not what he's asking though. He's asking who is the best short term sub-premo cash cow.

Embleberry Westhoff will get you any premo you want the fastest out of those 3 players as he has the lowest B/E this week, averaging higher than the 2 ATM and an easy opponent this week.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hi guys looking to trade out karnezis the cheapies are rowe,sinclair seeing nitnat prob wont play for 6-8weeks.More costly players are dwyer just heard beams is out for another 2-3 weeks mayes or stringer or anyone else worth looking at.

 

[Patty Healey]

That's not what he's asking though. He's asking who is the best short term sub-premo cash cow.

Embleberry Westhoff will get you any premo you want the fastest out of those 3 players as he has the lowest B/E this week, averaging higher than the 2 ATM and an easy opponent this week.

Ahh your right didn't even read it properly haha!

 

[Patty Healey]

Hi guys looking to trade out karnezis the cheapies are rowe,sinclair seeing nitnat prob wont play for 6-8weeks.More costly players are dwyer just heard beams is out for another 2-3 weeks mayes or stringer or anyone else worth looking at.

Go Mayes ahead of Rowe and Sinclair unless need MPP for ruck.

 

[Embleberry]

That's not what he's asking though. He's asking who is the best short term sub-premo cash cow.

Embleberry Westhoff will get you any premo you want the fastest out of those 3 players as he has the lowest B/E this week, averaging higher than the 2 ATM and an easy opponent this week.

Yeah that's what I'm leaning towards atm it would be bloody awesome if Westhoff goes BANG and rips out another 130!! Imagine that

 

[Waspy79]

Crouch + $60K or Dwyer (to replace Kommer).

 

[toxic]

Crouch + $60K or Dwyer (to replace Kommer).

Crouch + 60K - injuries to Van Berlo etc should increase his JS

 

[frozensage]

fyfe vs westhoff?

I like fyfe's form and looks like mundy getting number 1 tag week in week out so he is free running around kicking goals. Downside is injury.

Westhoff, pure cash grab and with gc this week thinking he will go up even more, then makes for an easy upgrade to a true prem.

Other option is go for a rookie like crouch for pure money but won't be winning me any league games or pushing me up the ranking I don't think.

 

[Patty Healey]

fyfe vs westhoff?

I like fyfe's form and looks like mundy getting number 1 tag week in week out so he is free running around kicking goals. Downside is injury.

Westhoff, pure cash grab and with gc this week thinking he will go up even more, then makes for an easy upgrade to a true prem.

Other option is go for a rookie like crouch for pure money but won't be winning me any league games or pushing me up the ranking I don't think.

Fyfe will be more consistent and is capable of huge scores.

 

[Jmac2225]

fyfe vs westhoff?

I like fyfe's form and looks like mundy getting number 1 tag week in week out so he is free running around kicking goals. Downside is injury.

Westhoff, pure cash grab and with gc this week thinking he will go up even more, then makes for an easy upgrade to a true prem.

Other option is go for a rookie like crouch for pure money but won't be winning me any league games or pushing me up the ranking I don't think.

Fyfes a keeper get on him.

 

[frozensage]

Fyfes a keeper get on him.

Reckon he will b in top 8 mids by season end?

 

[Krujan]

Reckon he will b in top 8 mids by season end?

He was ranked top 15 mid in 2011 for average (108) in only his second year. Could easily go top 8 this year injury permitting.

 

[toxic]

He was ranked top 15 mid in 2011 for average (108) in only his second year. Could easily go top 8 this year injury permitting.

who does he pass?
GAJ, Pendles, Swan, Cotchin, Lids, Selwood, Watson, JPK, Sam Mitchell, Scott Thompson, Dangerfield, Murphy, Kane Cornes, Dayne Beams (if he ever ever ever comes back) Andrew Swallow, Priddis..

was a great pick at 490K odd just not so sure he is that great a pick now