2013 Player/s X versus Y

[tracygrimshaw]

Nic Nat v K. Jack?

 

[toxic]

Nic Nat v K. Jack?

Kieran Jack but a whisker

 

[karaoke]

Nic Nat v K. Jack?

Plenty of options other than Jack (usual suspects), but he should be top 10-12ish

have to have NicNat, should be top 3-4 both Ruck & Fwds,

IMO

 

[LukeH]

Nic Nat v K. Jack?

NN for me, even his ordinary games still crank out 100s.

Maric or Minson?

 

[toxic]

NN for me, even his ordinary games still crank out 100s.

Maric or Minson?

Maric - currently better value for your $$$

 

[Propagandhi]

Kieran Jack or Joel Selwood??

Jelwood will give me almost the same average for the rest of the year and is 70K cheaper...

Jack is an untapped superstar but i do worry a tad that with the emergence of Tmit his pints may be slightly diluted

last spot will complete my mids for now:
Pendles, Cotchin, Watson, JPK, Hannaberry, Barlow, GAJ, Kmart & Tmit ++++ one other..

No love for Swanny, toxic?
I think Jelwood's value is too good to ignore though. I traded Jack in this week but only because I already have Selwood. Selwood + $ gets my vote.

 

[toxic]

No love for Swanny, toxic?
I think Jelwood's value is too good to ignore though. I traded Jack in this week but only because I already have Selwood. Selwood + $ gets my vote.

Propagandhi
Hannaberry may become Swan as a luxury upgrade later on, what I'm really hoping is that in about 5 weeks TMit hits 450K, Kmart and Staker hit 350K - Tmit out Swan and Cyril in as my M9 & F7.

If no pies bye this weekend I'd be all over Swan, but Jelwoods $$$$ value is too good to ignore. I Like Griffen but think he is over-priced compared to Jelwood
Its a dream but i have to dare to dream

 

[Propagandhi]

Propagandhi
Hannaberry may become Swan as a luxury upgrade later on, what I'm really hoping is that in about 5 weeks TMit hits 450K, Kmart and Staker hit 350K - Tmit out Swan and Cyril in as my M9 & F7.

If no pies bye this weekend I'd be all over Swan, but Jelwoods $$$$ value is too good to ignore. I Like Griffen but think he is over-priced compared to Jelwood
Its a dream but i have to dare to dream

Sounds like a great plan; hopefully the planets align for you... And getting Jelwood this week over Jack/Griffin will make it easier for you to pull off

 

[toxic]

Sounds like a great plan; hopefully the planets align for you... And getting Jelwood this week over Jack/Griffin will make it easier for you to pull off

given my avatar that has never been a problem!

 

[skilfulgun]

After dropping 400 spots after last week, really keen to make sure I get things right this week! Already bringing in J.Selwood to replace Murphy, but have one last midfield spot to upgrade. My question is:

Cotchin vs Jack vs Barlow?

Am leaning towards Cotchin, nice run coming up and a proven performer.

 

[Test Tickle]

R Griffen or J Selwood ??
Selwood much cheaper but he already in 15% teams which leans me to the more expensive Griffen.
I used to be indecisive.......but now I'm not so sure

 

[toxic]

After dropping 400 spots after last week, really keen to make sure I get things right this week! Already bringing in J.Selwood to replace Murphy, but have one last midfield spot to upgrade. My question is:

Cotchin vs Jack vs Barlow?

Am leaning towards Cotchin, nice run coming up and a proven performer.

Barlow has the best run home of all of them

 

[Stealthchicken]

D.Martin vs Riewoldt

 

[SCchamp]

D.Martin vs Riewoldt

That's a tough one...but I'm leaning towards Nroo career best form

 

[Krujan]

That's a tough one...but I'm leaning towards Nroo career best form

and only in 6% of teams

 

[Stickers32]

Griffen Priddis w/ 140k vs JPK Cotchin

Think maybe (a) short term but (B) long term?

What would you pick?

appreciate responses

cheers

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

I w

Griffen Priddis w/ 140k vs JPK Cotchin

Think maybe (a) short term but (B) long term?

What would you pick?

appreciate responses

cheers

I would go JPK and Cotchin for the rest of the season.
Think long-term!

 

[Stickers32]

I w

I would go JPK and Cotchin for the rest of the season.
Think long-term!

Yeah I know but Griffen's avg is ridiculous and it's a POD. Last chance to get him.

Already have Priddis but ill have to trade him to get Cotch & JPK

Is that silly? I just dont see Priddis as elite. Only got him cos he was so cheap! Maybe time for the chop

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Yeah I know but Griffen's avg is ridiculous and it's a POD. Last chance to get him.

Already have Priddis but ill have to trade him to get Cotch & JPK

Is that silly? I just dont see Priddis as elite. Only got him cos he was so cheap! Maybe time for the chop

Griffen's price is really high at the moment I'd say. Maybe a couple of weeks back would be a good trade but I just don't see the justification in bringing him in at such a high price.
I agree that Priddis is not elite but he can consistently get a few more tonnes before you trade him out.
Unless your team is like uber strong now and Priddis is the weakest link, if not he can wait.

 

[Test Tickle]

Griffen's price is really high at the moment I'd say. Maybe a couple of weeks back would be a good trade but I just don't see the justification in bringing him in at such a high price.
I agree that Priddis is not elite but he can consistently get a few more tonnes before you trade him out.
Unless your team is like uber strong now and Priddis is the weakest link, if not he can wait.

Griffens price is high at the moment for a good reason, i did some research on him and was amazed at what i saw, i picked him up this week but i wish i had picked him up earlier, he is a massive POD and SC Gold has him at $700,000 by years end.

 

[toxic]

Griffens price is high at the moment for a good reason, i did some research on him and was amazed at what i saw, i picked him up this week but i wish i had picked him up earlier, he is a massive POD and SC Gold has him at $700,000 by years end.

he is a good POD and would've been good last week, doubt he'll get to 700K tho and expect him to average about 120 from here in as an average

 

[Stickers32]

Anyone see the point in trading in ibbotson instead of Birchall? Or is Birchall to cheap to pass up? I'm going for POD but don't want to be silly about it.

 

[super saints storm]

Anyone see the point in trading in ibbotson instead of Birchall? Or is Birchall to cheap to pass up? I'm going for POD but don't want to be silly about it.

I like both but ibbotson has a good run of games at home, and birchall still has a suspect back injury, I have them both.

Any pros or cons on J Selwood or Gibbs???

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Griffens price is high at the moment for a good reason, i did some research on him and was amazed at what i saw, i picked him up this week but i wish i had picked him up earlier, he is a massive POD and SC Gold has him at $700,000 by years end.

I get but you're trying to say.
What I mean is if you're paying $635,700 for a player, you would expect him to score around the range of 125~130 for the rest of the year.
Will he able to? Time will tell but he's looking good at the moment.

 

[Kadog]

So glad I traded Griffen in last week