Boris the Contradiction
Cancelled
If this is on performances alone I think Langdon is too low. He may not have the ceiling of some of the others, but he played like a 100 gamer from the get go.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
Hine would trade all 3 of those blokes for bonti in a heartbeat, and even throw in a couple of first rounders. Lol.Scharenberg, Aish & Langdon is a better haul than the Bulldogs.
Hine would trade all 3 of those blokes for bonti in a heartbeat, and even throw in a couple of first rounders. Lol.
Hine would trade Treloar for bonti in a heartbeat, and even throw in a couple of first rounders (if in fact you had any left.......).I doubt it. Scharenberg will own once he has a full preseason behind him and Hine has just procured a superior midfielder than Bontempelli with Treloar.
Hine would trade Treloar for bonti in a heartbeat, and even throw in a couple of first rounders (if in fact you had any left.......).
Hahahaha.... oh wait you're seriousWould you Trade Bont for Cloke Then?
Hahahaha.... oh wait you're serious
Where would hogan and Martin rank if they were available in this draft?
1: Hogan
2: McCarthy
3: Brown
4: Boyd
That's how I rank the KPF from this draft on exposed form
Was being serious. No way the dogs would trade bonti for Langdon, aish and scharenberg. No way. Would anyone?Well as Serious as @fronkalicious is
They pies are still crying over Bonti because they think we stole him from themHine would trade all 3 of those blokes for bonti in a heartbeat, and even throw in a couple of first rounders. Lol.
Thank you! Appreciate your kind wordsObligatory post asking why a Richmond player isn't on the list (Lennon).
Seriously good job. Agree with most. Would have Sheed higher but its been mentioned. Not sure on Taylor. Would have Billings at 4. But really good job and great read.
Fair call. I was just basing it on first two years. I think Boyd and McCarthy will overtake him in years to comeKolodjashnij is a gun...but would I pick him over McCarthy, Boyd, Bontempelli, Billings, Merrett...not sure I would. Think number 5-7 is about his range.
Fair call. I was just basing it on first two years. I think Boyd and McCarthy will overtake him in years to come
Fair call. I was just basing it on first two years. I think Boyd and McCarthy will overtake him in years to come
I would in a heartbeat. Scharenberg and Aish in particular are going to be seriously good players, and Langdon, whilst not having the ceiling of the previous two, will be a 200 game player.Was being serious. No way the dogs would trade bonti for Langdon, aish and scharenberg. No way. Would anyone?
Really? Because to me it looks like they're neck and neck despite Aish having much of this season ruined by injuries. Do some research before accusing others of bias.You say you're basing it on the first 2 years, but also state "I rate Aish a little higher than Sheed at the moment. That's just my opinion though".
Clearly Sheed has been far better than Aish in these first 2 years, which is supposedly your criterion.
I suspect the only reason you rate Aish higher is that he's now at your club.
No doubt you started the thread for the same reasons.