TiarneSwersky
Senior List
- May 8, 2015
- 207
- 455
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Los Angeles Lakers
You say you're basing it on the first 2 years, but also state "I rate Aish a little higher than Sheed at the moment. That's just my opinion though".
Clearly Sheed has been far better than Aish in these first 2 years, which is supposedly your criterion.
I suspect the only reason you rate Aish higher is that he's now at your club.
No doubt you started the thread for the same reasons.
You couldn't be further off. I wasn't a fan of Aish coming to the Pies because I thought we had a good crop of young players and I don't even think he is in our best 22 at the moment.
I have said numerous times I overlooked Sheed - and that could be because he plays in the West. My bad.
I have redrafted every draft since 2001 so this isn't a thread to boast Collingwood's recruiting and drafting. I started the thread because these articles have been quite popular and a great way to gauge different footy opinions.