2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[KardiniaPark]

Isn't boak going to win the Brownlow?

Hannebery averaged like 102 one year and got close to a Brownlow.

 

[toxic]

Both will be top 2 rucks come year end, but mummy likes to get round the ground more and will share ruck duties less than Jacobs will imo.
I'm taking neither as they are both 2 expensive and I'm hoping I can get 1 after the byes when they come down in price.
Due to rule changes I think most rucks will drop in price

Top 2 in average or top 2 in total points

 

[Lums23]

Hannebery averaged like 102 one year and got close to a Brownlow.

Priddis averaged more than Danger and actually did win the Brownlow

But yeah it was meant to be a bit tounge in cheek

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Ablett, Leuenberger, Shaun Edwards vs Parker, Minson, Dalgleish

Top if fit, but risky.

 

[Goats]

Boak by a country mile
Mitchell
Toss a coin

How have you arrived at this opinion? Danger has averaged more than Boak every year apart from last and the difference was only .1%

 

[debra17]

Bennell vs Devon smith?

 

[debra17]

Ablett, Leuenberger, Shaun Edwards vs Parker, Minson, Dalgleish

Option 2 - I think you'll get a higher overall point score with this option

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Bennell vs Devon smith?

Bennell.

 

[toxic]

Option 2 - I think you'll get a higher overall point score with this option

Does your point score include captain options

 

[Broar]

JPK or Sloane?

 

[toxic]

JPK or Sloane?

Jpk

 

[King_Steele]

Bennell vs Devon smith?

JPK or Sloane?

Bennell & JPK.

 

[King_Steele]

Swan & Leuy

V

Bonts & Giles

 

[lopylaa]

That's a short country mile imo

I guess we will see season end then, but I think boak will be 15 pts better avg, that's a country mile to me

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Swan & Leuy

V

Bonts & Giles

I don't personally like either of Giles and Leuy but i'd have Swan & Leuy. IF anything happens around Essendon take Giles & Bonts.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

JPK or Sloane?

JPK

I guess we will see season end then, but I think boak will be 15 pts better avg, that's a country mile to me

I've gone with Boak so i'll just ride high on your thoughts..

 

[lopylaa]

How have you arrived at this opinion? Danger has averaged more than Boak every year apart from last and the difference was only .1%

Read back all explained
There is no right or wrong at this stage it's my opinion and I've gave my reasoning behind it, that being said I look forward to season end when I'm proved right

 

[rocker_oz33]

Swan & Leuy

V

Bonts & Giles

Swan and Looney.
Looney is still a good tap ruck hes already said hes working on hes game because of Stef.
If stef gets hurt looney will score more if looney gets hurt trade up to stef.

 

[Lums23]

I guess we will see season end then, but I think boak will be 15 pts better avg, that's a country mile to me

It's only opinions obviously, but 15 points seems like a lot. Boak has averaged about 105 the last two seasons, and other than that he hasn't gone above 90 odd. While boak may well improve, I couldn't see danger, who had gone 118 and 112 before an injury affected 105 over the last three years, averaging under 100 as he would have to for boak to be 15 ppg better

 

[SnappyHappy]

JPK v Gray

 

[rocker_oz33]

JPK v Gray

Jpk for mine.

 

[King_Steele]

JPK v Gray

JPK.

Unless you want to miss out on 5-10pg IMO, for flexibility.

 

[Stickers32]

Dangerfield and D.Martin or J.Selwood and Rioli


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[lopylaa]

It's only opinions obviously, but 15 points seems like a lot. Boak has averaged about 105 the last two seasons, and other than that he hasn't gone above 90 odd. While boak may well improve, I couldn't see danger, who had gone 118 and 112 before an injury affected 105 over the last three years, averaging under 100 as he would have to for boak to be 15 ppg better

I'm predicting danger won't go above 100 this year I guess is more where I'm coming from that and I think boak can go 110-115

 

[New_Frrost11]

Dangerfield and D.Martin or J.Selwood and Rioli


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Danger/Martin

I am doing a draft league and for my last pick I needed to pick a def backup (so not directly related but is still asking a supercoach relevant question). Who do you guys suggest...

Varcoe // Docherty // Everitt //Dempster // Hooker // Rampe // Grimes

My other 3 defenders are : Simpson // Taylor // Yarran

Cheers.