No Oppo Supporters 2016 General AFL Discussion Part 2 (Sydney Posters Only)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Was watching some Swans games from this year because I am getting footy withdrawal and remembered how much I don't rate Sinclair.

 

Log in to remove this ad.

Was watching some Swans games from this year because I am getting footy withdrawal and remembered how much I don't rate Sinclair.


Have now watched all of last season and half the season before...

Re Sinclair, I reckon that's a bit unfair. I could find a million of these type of clips for just about any player in the game. Try re-watching the round 2, Carlton game. He has ability, agility, and some pretty good skills. I don't know what happened this year, but the skills and ability are there...
 
Have now watched all of last season and half the season before...

Re Sinclair, I reckon that's a bit unfair. I could find a million of these type of clips for just about any player in the game. Try re-watching the round 2, Carlton game. He has ability, agility, and some pretty good skills. I don't know what happened this year, but the skills and ability are there...
I bet you couldnt find a million clips of him doing something resembling afl level. Maybe 1. Thats the problem
 
You joke about Towers being a NEAFL player now, but anything is possible, Reid might even play 20 games!
It may surprise you that excluding 2010 when he debuted in the last round. Reid's played 20 games 4/6 seasons.
 
Just like every other player, Clarkson will manage to create space & time for him to dispose of the ball - in turn lifting Titch's disposal efficiency. Not just that but I'd suspect Titch would be tasked with extraction & HANDBALL out of congestion to a waiting kicker. He has good hands & can find the ball, why try to make him another Smitch or Jewis? He's a different beast, I'm sure Clarkson will play him to his strengths.

Tom will be a great player for Hawthorn for a long time, as Josh Dunkley may become for the Dogs. Losing players like that, especially when they are the sons of former champions, really grates. But letting both go was the right decision. We have players whose limitations are similar but their strengths are greater. No point fretting about their loss. Better to relish the players we gained in their place.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
You joke about Towers being a NEAFL player now, but anything is possible, Reid might even play 20 games!

Like he did in 2011, 2012, 2014 and 2015? We really missed Sam this year. His ongoing injuries were frustrating and his brother's problems make you wonder. But Sam has just turned 25. Far more upside to Sam. Let's give him the benefit and see how he goes this year.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

How much bad luck has Ross Lyon had with trades / recruits?

Screwed up the luke ball trade, failed with the Lovett trade.

Bennell been a disaster so far, yarran, the bloke from Melbourne who was trash. Failed in the cam Mccarthy trade last year.

His trade / drafting record has been abysmal and I think it's finally catching up to him.
 
Like he did in 2011, 2012, 2014 and 2015? We really missed Sam this year. His ongoing injuries were frustrating and his brother's problems make you wonder. But Sam has just turned 25. Far more upside to Sam. Let's give him the benefit and see how he goes this year.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk


Fitness is only one of Reids issues

Not getting the bloody football or doing anything of note on the ground is a bit of a weakness

Running around being tall though, he excels at
 
Tippett , Sinclair and Reid are overrated overpaid duds


If sinclair is on 400k then reid and tippetts salary as reported...geez

Never criticise buddys pay packet, rather pay him the amount we pay all 4
 
Tippett , Sinclair and Reid are overrated overpaid duds


If sinclair is on 400k then reid and tippetts salary as reported...geez

Never criticise buddys pay packet, rather pay him the amount we pay all 4
 
Sinkers was the biggest flop of a trade ever.

I have no faith in him even being decent. Soft as butter


Agree
In hindsight better off letting Lewis walk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top