2016 trade hypotheticals

[philthy05]

North will be getting an end of first round compensation pick for Daniel wells so will still head into the draft with 11 and 20ish.

Can't possibly happen

They take three factors , contract size, length and age.

He is just shy of 32 years old. So he needs to make that up in the other numbers. But of course being 32 how long is his contract gonna be? Not as long. So then it would take even bigger numbers. It would take an absolute record breaking contract for a 32 yr old to get band 2 compo. It won't happen for a 32 year old player who has had a history of injury.

The age is a factor but he will become a top 3 highest paid player at Collingwood next year, which will favour an end of first round pick to North.

Im struggling to think of anyone besides Pendles who would be on over 500k next year at collingwood next year, especially with treloars back ended deal.

No chance wells becomes a top 3 paid player at the pies



I'm calling it. Band 4 compo at the very best. I'm expecting that as we have seen previously they will decide that that many years of service to a club is dues done and paid. I don't think we will ever see any player over 30 get more than a 3rd round pick, and nor should they. It's much different to a player leaving in his prime after years of development from his club that drafted him.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Dawes, does he still have any value?

He'd be your best forward.

 

[blueiris]

He'd be your best forward.

No he wouldn't Hipwood and Schache are easily better players Dawes wouldn't get a game at the Lions

 

[Draft mad]

Ge

No he wouldn't Hipwood and Schache are easily better players Dawes wouldn't get a game at the Lions

get a grip! Dawes would be better now. But the Shack and hipwood will be better

 

[Since 2001]

Would love Cutler to stay at Brisbane, it is hard to watch other clubs pick off their good young players.

Mostly because that could be us in a few years if we don't get it right.

i think that is already you guys. talent leaving every year. you won't be as bad as Brisbane, but expect to have clubs come at your players even harder.

 

[Bojan KantKick]

Can't possibly happen

They take three factors , contract size, length and age.

He is just shy of 32 years old. So he needs to make that up in the other numbers. But of course being 32 how long is his contract gonna be? Not as long. So then it would take even bigger numbers. It would take an absolute record breaking contract for a 32 yr old to get band 2 compo. It won't happen for a 32 year old player who has had a history of injury.




No chance wells becomes a top 3 paid player at the pies



I'm calling it. Band 4 compo at the very best. I'm expecting that as we have seen previously they will decide that that many years of service to a club is dues done and paid. I don't think we will ever see any player over 30 get more than a 3rd round pick, and nor should they. It's much different to a player leaving in his prime after years of development from his club that drafted him.

Wells will be on $1.8m over three years with most of it front ended. Look at their list. He will be a top 3 earner at the pies. Pretty sure the AFL don't take injury history into account when making compo decisions lol

 

[Bojan KantKick]

Can we just have the 2nd rounder?

We have enough shit forwards.

you'll take him and you'll like it

 

[cotter101]

He'd be your best forward.

What a load. We'd probably have 3 better forwards on the list.

 

[Suma Magic]

Wells will be on $1.8m over three years with most of it front ended. Look at their list. He will be a top 3 earner at the pies. Pretty sure the AFL don't take injury history into account when making compo decisions lol

If he was 25 that would get band 2 compo. But he's 31.

 

[Carlos Danger]

He'd be your best forward.

Hipwood, scahche, walker, close & freeman

Dunno how many KPFs are carried on most lists but im doubtful bris would look to add another KPF especially when they are crying out for KPDs

 

[eth-dog]

Brisbane's defence will be very good in a couple of years time, it's just really inexperienced. If you have a back 6 like:

Paparone - Andrews - Gardiner
Lester - McStay - Cutler

You have an almost perfect back 6. All of them are capable of playing tall (except maybe Lester), all of them are athletic and they're usually pretty good distributors (except Paparone. Bloke should be banned from kicking anything other than long down the line). Problem is only one has played more than 50 games.

 

[go_the_dockers]

Pick 3 and 2017 2nd round pick for mccarthy , pick 8 and 16.

Ballanyne and freo 3rd for eagles 3rd round pick and 2nd tound pick

Kersten for eagles 3rd round pick.

Silvagni for Brisbanes 3rd round pick.

Conca for Suban.

Hill for eagles 2nd round pick.

 

[Kwality]

Ge

get a grip! Dawes would be better now. But the Shack and hipwood will be better

No future grabbing Dawes, he no longer cuts it at AFL level.

 

[TedDougChris]

Brisbane just need time and to hold onto as many of the kids as they can.... Developing a good list up there, just need a coach to teach and develop. Every year I suspect a few talented youngsters will pop up and cement a permanent place in the 22, meaning there are less and less holes in the list that they need to fill. Short term-ism shouldn't be the aim in this trade period.

 

[go_the_dockers]

I wonder if Brisbane or GC would want Spurr. Still in our best 22 easily, but a Qld boy and we are reloading.

 

[Kwality]

Pick 3 and 2017 2nd round pick for mccarthy , pick 8 and 16.
Ballanyne and freo 3rd for eagles 3rd round pick and 2nd tound pick
Kersten for eagles 3rd round pick.
Silvagni for Brisbanes 3rd round pick.
Conca for Suban.
Hill for eagles 2nd round pick.

You suggesting Brad Hill to the Eagles, take Joshs spot when he is delisted.

 

[Jordie_tackles]

You suggesting Brad Hill to the Eagles, take Joshs spot when he is delisted.

No he acquired that for Ballantyne

 

[dazbroncos]

Webb for a 3rd rounder , honeychurch for a 4th , Stevens for a 3rd and Jong for a 2nd

Id give the 4th for Honeychurch.

GO Catters

 

[blueiris]

Brisbane's defence will be very good in a couple of years time, it's just really inexperienced. If you have a back 6 like:

Paparone - Andrews - Gardiner
Lester - McStay - Cutler

You have an almost perfect back 6. All of them are capable of playing tall (except maybe Lester), all of them are athletic and they're usually pretty good distributors (except Paparone. Bloke should be banned from kicking anything other than long down the line). Problem is only one has played more than 50 games.

We're probably a little top heavy in our defense prefer McStay forward with Watson or Hammelmann at CHB

 

[doona]

If he was 25 that would get band 2 compo. But he's 31.

I reckon it will be a similar compo to Malceski who had a 3 year 500k+ contract which netted us an end if 2nd round I think it was.

On Nexus 6P using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bonts1000]

Id give the 4th for Honeychurch.

GO Catters

If we win the flag tomorrow , you can have him for free

 

[dazbroncos]

If we win the flag tomorrow , you can have him for free

Well, that would be awesome on both counts.

Go Woofers!

 

[apuchar]

You suggesting Brad Hill to the Eagles, take Joshs spot when he is delisted.

Ballanyne and freo 3rd for eagles 3rd round pick and 2nd tound pick

 

[Suma Magic]

I reckon it will be a similar compo to Malceski who had a 3 year 500k+ contract which netted us an end if 2nd round I think it was.

On Nexus 6P using BigFooty.com mobile app

Malceski got band 3 (mid second round). Compo has probably decreased a bit since then.

Wells would be on more than Malceski per year, but TPP would have increased around 10-15% (I'm not sure on this) over two years which makes the difference pretty small.

Ages at the time of FA:
Wells 31 yrs 8 months
Malceski 30 yrs 2 months

Not an insignificant difference.

So band 3 possible, but could easily be band 4.

 

[Suma Magic]

Ballanyne and freo 3rd for eagles 3rd round pick and 2nd tound pick

That would be a great deal for the dockers.