Position 2017 Defenders

[Dark Sharks]

What are peoples thoughts on Robert Murphy?

Good bloke, nice hair, i like his segment on AFL 360

 

[HumanMeatball]

That's not entirely true, Dimma said Vlas had to hone the defensive side of his game and that's why he's playing BP/HB.
He said that after he'd played about 6 AFL games.
He's still stuck in the back pocket, 74 games later.
That lasted

But for real tho I really wanna pick Vlas.
In his 3rd AFL game he scored 105, followed up by a 141, a 87 in a 5 goal loss then bagged 3 snags out of the middle against the Wet Toast for 108 points.
That's when Dimma decided we didn't need any more midfielders and that he'd make a pearler of a BP. What a bellend. Just put him back in the midfield you numpty.

Some good numbers there

 

[go you pups]

What are peoples thoughts on Robert Murphy?

Lock and load friend


Should play more games than Bennell who is similarly priced at the other end

 

[Keg on legs]

Not much talk about Vince. Consistent bugger, great disposal... can see him replicating Boyds role and form from last year off half back. Any dees fan care to comment?

Every time I hear someone mention Vince I think someone must've farted.......

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Every time I hear someone mention Vince I think someone must've farted.......

 

[freddy mercury]

Lock and load friend


Should play more games than Bennell who is similarly priced at the other end

Will it effect Jason Johannisens score? Or will Johannisen effect Murphys output?

 

[Dark Sharks]

 

[freddy mercury]

Good bloke, nice hair, i like his segment on AFL 360

Made the premiership all about him..

 

[I Lost My Keays]

My wildcard choice is Tom Cutler

 

[King_Steele]

My wildcard choice is Tom Cutler

He's certainly in that Mills/Roberton/Pig Hibberd range of going 90+ imo

 

[Feerits Elf]

My wildcard choice is Tom Cutler

What do you think Cutler will average?

 

[I Lost My Keays]

He's certainly in that Mills/Robertson range of going 90+ imo

I think it was the second half of the season? He was just racking up the disposals

 

[I Lost My Keays]

What do you think Cutler will average?

80-85

 

[Feerits Elf]

80-85

I am confuse.

He's your wildcard choice to average 80-85?

 

[I Lost My Keays]

I am confuse.

He's your wildcard choice to average 80-85?

He averaged 75 last season and I believe he will improve for the season

 

[Feerits Elf]

Nah, I'm still confused.

 

[toxic]

80-85

So not enuff to pick?

 

[I Lost My Keays]

So not enuff to pick?

Worth a punt at $412k I think it was?

 

[toxic]

Worth a punt at $412k I think it was?

If he averages 80-85 he's a putrid option.

He needs to average 95ish to be a good pick.

Not saying he's not capable, just saying if what your hoping for is 85 then raise your expectations/goals for your choices

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

Sorry if it's been covered before, but anybody thinking about Zac Touhy this year?
Taking over from Enright in the Geelong backline could be a chance to move to premo level?

 

[Dark Sharks]

Reckon Zac Dawson is a bargain, should go on to average 60 which i'd be happy with for that price.

 

[go you pups]

Will it effect Jason Johannisens score? Or will Johannisen effect Murphys output?

Na

Both started the year on fire last year before injury hit them both


We don't have great mids in regards to ceiling except Bont, which would steal points off many in other teams, they're very even, guys like Hunter and Macrae are better Dters than SCers for example though.


I'd say their ranges are

Bont 105-120
Dahl 95-110
Libba 90-105
JJ 90-105
Macrae 95-103
Hunter 90-100
Murph 85-100 (90-95 avg at his price would be an excellent return)

 

[Hairy Lager]

Na

Both started the year on fire last year before injury hit them both


We don't have great mids in regards to ceiling except Bont, which would steal points off many in other teams, they're very even, guys like Hunter and Macrae are better Dters than SCers for example though.


I'd say their ranges are

Bont 105-120
Dahl 95-110
Libba 90-105
JJ 90-105
Macrae 95-103
Hunter 90-100
Murph 85-100 (90-95 avg at his price would be an excellent return)

liked post for this bit.

 

[Fooler]

liked post for this bit.

A 35 year old that's only averaged 84 over the past 7 years where he's played 10 or more games, coming off an ACL injury. Pass.

 

[Super Hans]

Na

Both started the year on fire last year before injury hit them both


We don't have great mids in regards to ceiling except Bont, which would steal points off many in other teams, they're very even, guys like Hunter and Macrae are better Dters than SCers for example though.


I'd say their ranges are

Bont 105-120
Dahl 95-110
Libba 90-105
JJ 90-105
Macrae 95-103
Hunter 90-100
Murph 85-100 (90-95 avg at his price would be an excellent return)

I reckon you're def underselling Libba there. I'd argue his SuperCoach potential is up there with the second level elite mids. Eg not Pendles, Ablett, Danger etc. Sits with the likes of Priddis, Gray etc for me. Agree with the rest tho.